I don't accept this premise and I don't think serves as a reasonable excuse for government interference in labor markets. Even if you do accept this, then the solution sacrifices long-term labor stability for short-term labor monopolization.
Either way, I don't see this as a positive outcome, and I regret every administrations attempt to expand the program using any excuse that happens across their desks.
> but how many times do we have to learn the lesson that “more people making software leads to more software jobs”
The connection between this outcome and increased H1-B visas for mostly _corporate sponsors_ is sketchy, at best.
In my view it's the opposite, a perfectly free labor market would be one where anyone can apply to a job. Restricting immigration by denying visas is a government interference in the market. So more visas means less interference.
(Note: I'm not claiming anything about whether it's a good idea or not).
b) There is no evidence that H1B visas have caused labor instability in the IT market.
Lmao. It’s self evident that the IT market, exemplified by the wealthiest tech corps, is literally dominated by foreign workers. The argument for unskilled labor (Americans don’t want those jobs) can’t even be dishonestly argued here. It’s government policy allowing US workers to be sidelined in favor of foreign ones.
The US doesn’t need to “cement itself” as anything. Thanks, but no thanks. Ironically, your kind of attitude is the same one that gave rise to the insane, populist politics of the last few years and has done more harm to immigrants than any other single policy.
H1-B is specifically for specialized occupations and generally requires a minimum of a bachelor’s degree and specialized skills in demand. It is, in fact, called the H1-B Specialty Occupations Visa.
I suspect you’re thinking of the Diversity Visa program, which offers a lottery of 55,000 visas annually to anyone (except for some eye brow raising exceptions).
There are also other programs like migrant worker programs that allow unskilled labor into the country for a limited time to fill seasonal work gaps.
> those workers would qualify for skilled worker visas.
H1B is a skilled worker visa so I’m not sure what the complaint here is.
It sounds like a lot of complaints you have are with well documented abuses of the program by consulting firms and the government’s lack of cracking down on that.
Not if you like high wages, and you want them to stay that way.
The danger, IMHO, isn't wage dilution anyway (that one can be counteracted by politics) - it is that sensitive knowledge will make its way back to China and other current or potentially hostile nations, and it would not be the first time either that this happens.
Devs have been worried about offshoring/immigrants replacing them/lowering their wages for decades.
The only outcome we have ever observed from having more people building software is that dramatically more software jobs have become possible and in-demand.
Also, and I understand why you might not make this argument, but let’s be honest: software engineering wages are extraordinarily high. Slowing or even reversing that growth by small amounts on average would still leave millions of extremely well-paid jobs.
Software is eating the world after all. Seems likely that demand would be high anyway. Perhaps if there were no H1Bs, entry level grads would make $250k, with the average senior dev making $750k+.
YMMV, I guess.
Luckily you don’t control the thoughts of others. US companies should hire US citizens and if there isn’t enough supply we should be enacting policies to fix that issue not continuing to allow US citizens to work “unskilled” labor for pennies while we brain drain other nations and create an upper class of non-citizens.
The U.S. has the opportunity to cement itself as the center of the world as far as technological progress from now into eternity. Why wouldn’t we take every brilliant immigrant we can get?
If you’re a software developer and you are afraid for your job/wages, I get that intuitively; but how many times do we have to learn the lesson that “more people making software leads to more software jobs”