News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by jamiek88 on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:33PM (#38145363)
It's funny thinking back to the hype cycle of Itanium back in the heady days where performance was doubling every year, desktop was king and this was the future.

Turns out it was more like IBM's MCA / PS2 rather than the future.

Compatibility and ubiquity wins. As nearly always.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by chx on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:35PM (#38145388)
2009 summary https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2339629,00.asp

> The failure of this chip to do anything more than exist as a niche processor sealed the fate of Intel—and perhaps the entire industry, since from 1997 to 2001 everyone waited for the messiah of chips to take us all to the next level.

> It did that all right. It took us to the next level. But we didn't know that the next level was below us, not above. The next level was the basement, in fact. Hopefully Intel won't come up with any more bright ideas like the Itanium. We can't afford to excavate another level down.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by cubefox on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:38PM (#38145413)
This piece sounds like a lot of misrepresentation and exaggeration.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by chx on Saturday November 04, 2023 @06:17PM (#38145757)
Whether the DEC Alpha development stopped because of Merced (as it was called then) or because of the 1997 legal mess https://www.wired.com/1997/10/intel-dec-settle-alpha-chip-di... is quite hard to say.

The DEC Alpha architecture was planned for 25 years and it certainly was not technical barriers that killed the Alpha 21464.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by jabl on Saturday November 04, 2023 @06:34PM (#38145899)
In the end it was market forces that did it in. Making new chips was (still is!) exponentially more expensive for each generation, and at the same time mass market chips were getting better and better while they could amortize the NRE costs over zillions of chips sold, eating the market from below. And other RISC competitors (and IA-64) were attacking from the sides. DEC just didn't have the customer base or depth of pockets to fund Alpha development. That it was Itanium that ultimately delivered the coup de grace was but the final insult.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by FullyFunctional on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:35PM (#38146376)
In my limited understanding two factors contributed significantly to Alpha failing. Business-wise, DEC and Ken Olesen were stuck in an old minicomputer mentality and wasn't sufficiently able or willing to "let it loose" and let it take over the market with DEC as the CPU supplier. Technically, Alpha development was taking longer and longer and the schedule slips got worse and worse.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by kstrauser on Saturday November 04, 2023 @08:08PM (#38146588)
If the business end had kept the cash rolling in, do you think the technical side could have kept to schedule?
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by GrilledChips on Saturday November 04, 2023 @08:14PM (#38146616)
It wasn't the technical side that caused the schedule slips. It was constant competition with other aspects of the business, especially the VAX lineup. The VAX 9000 in particular was a $3 billion money pit that didn't make back even 25% of it's development costs and was repeatedly chosen over development of prism and later alpha. Even when it came down to the embarrassingly fast NVAX chip vs the even faster Alhpa, DEC still couldn't get the story straight and lost valuable VAX customers when they could have offered a faster VAX and an upgrade path to Alpha.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by chasil on Saturday November 04, 2023 @09:35PM (#38147106)
I worked on a DECStation 5000/240 running Ultrix, in a student job in 1993.

DEC should have bought MIPS, and ported VMS to it.

Had they made that decision, they might still exist.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by speed_spread on Saturday November 04, 2023 @09:40PM (#38147155)
Yeah, DEC needed to scale the Alpha down, even below PCs. A console deal could have given it a few more years and helped with chip economics.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by javitron on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:37PM (#38186852)
That makes no sense. Alpha was horrible in terms of power consumption.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday November 05, 2023 @10:43AM (#38152100)
The Prism/Alpha project was one long series of disasters. Prism was delayed because the spec kept changing and the architecture had to run on VLSI and ECL - which was already a huge mistake. There was also resistance from the VAX partisans.

So when samples arrived they were 2-3 years later than they should have been and MIPs had made some headway in the same space.

DEC - actually Bob Supnik - decided that even though Prism was the better arch, MIPS products would bring in revenue more quickly.

Which was true. But... then Prism was killed, which led to a mass walkout. The remains were resurrected a year later with some updates as Alpha. But by then it was too late for that particular market.

Prism was a solid arch - some quirks, but nothing unworkable. And very, very fast.

But it was a workstation-grade processor, not a mainstream PC-grade processor.

DEC completely failed to understand the PC market, and it's not obvious what would have happened if Prism had survived. IMO it would have gone the way of MIPS anyway, because the workstation market was already being squeezed hard, and the PC and Mac markets had already made their choices.

It might have had a good run against SPARC for a decade or so, but that would have been it.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by GrilledChips on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:56PM (#38146518)
It wasn't the cost of alpha. It was the bleeding all through the rest of the company.

DEC's terminals? killed by PCs. The VAX lineup? killed by RISC chips, and the VAX 9000 consumed a huge chunk of their cash reserves before embarrassingly being rendered obsolete by their own NVAX.

This was a time of change from minicomputers to microcomputers and DEC made costly decision after costly decision. They kept selling off profitable "non-core" portions of the business that in the process incurred a loss.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by javitron on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:35PM (#38186844)
It is a great representation of the average article written about Itanium. I think the register made most of its revenue from articles about Itanium, where the authors had no clue about what they were talking about.

Not defending Itanium. But the average article on computer architecture has been garbage for decades now, it's fascinating.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by vGPU on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:20PM (#38146256)
This reads like it was written by a discount version of chatGPT.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by postmodest on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:39PM (#38145421)
As someone working in that space at that time, IA64 was still losing to Sparc64 the entire time. We would do big boxes on Solaris and replace older Sun boxes with ia32 Pentium Pros. There wasn't really ever a point at which we thought "hm, RISC isn't working for us, we need VLIW" ...and we were an HP shop!!!
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by GrilledChips on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:51PM (#38146494)
Sun was one of the few processor makers who were sceptical and decided to wait and see before cancelling plans for their architecture, and it's nice to hear that worked out for them for a bit before 64-bit x86 ate their lunch.

Of course, it's also possible that by that point Sun was already paralysed by infighting between various splinter groups, with no big bad DEC to fight against.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by javitron on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:32PM (#38186827)
The irony being that Itanium is basically a SPARC64 on steroids; both wide, both used huge register windows, and both were in order. the only difference being that Itanium exposed a lot of the superscalar bits to the programmer. I still have no clue why an HP shop would be using Solaris boxes, alas...
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by brookst on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:48PM (#38145520)
I still get confused whether the real name is Itanium or Itanic
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by Tsiklon on Saturday November 04, 2023 @09:02PM (#38146912)
It’s a beautiful piece of tabloid journalism - jokingly naming Itanium, Itanic after the Titanic.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by rasz on Saturday November 04, 2023 @06:26PM (#38145826)
It was only the future until release date forced it to face the reality.

Linus Torvalds in 2003: https://yarchive.net/comp/linux/x86.html

>Itanium 2 doesn't hold a candle to a P4 on any real-world benchmarks.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by FullyFunctional on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:36PM (#38146389)
Hilariously, it must be read in the context that Linus actually hated the P4 for it's very imbalanced performance.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by twoodfin on Saturday November 04, 2023 @06:50PM (#38146032)
Compatibility and ubiquity wins. As nearly always.

I’m not particularly confused about Intel’s perspective on compatibility: Even at the time, there were several examples of successful platform CPU transitions across architectural “full breaks”. Apple going from 68k to PowerPC is the closest analogy for Intel, and if the Itanium performance and software (compiler) story had played out as Intel envisioned they likely would have been fine.

But as for ubiquity, I’m befuddled. As far as I’ve been able to determine—having lived through it and followed many retrospective threads like this looking for new evidence—Intel had no plans on any useful timeline to turn Itanium into a (non-workstation) desktop or laptop chip. Did they really think the market would stay bifurcated between “big iron” architectures and x86 personal machines for another decade? I can’t imagine they would have believed that.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by flashback2199 on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:46PM (#38146459)
> Did they really think the market would stay bifurcated between “big iron” architectures and x86 personal machines for another decade? I can’t imagine they would have believed that.

Oh but they did :)

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by bombcar on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:48PM (#38146474)
I think it's the case that they wanted to believe that, because the other story, that all the major "big iron" companies would be absolutely and totally forever wrecked by stupid free Linux running on stupid cheap whiteboxes was simply too horrible to envision.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by twoodfin on Saturday November 04, 2023 @08:28PM (#38146708)
Data center computing being dominated by commodity Linux running on commodity x86 PC architecture—for which the best CPUs were not commodities, but rather made exclusively by Intel—was likely the best of all possible worlds for them!

Going back to at least the i432, Intel seems to have had a deep vein of “mainframe envy” in their culture and strategic thinking. It seems that somehow the market (and a bit of trailblazing into x86-64 by AMD) saved them from themselves.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by watersb on Saturday November 04, 2023 @09:21PM (#38147034)
> Going back to at least the i432, ... “mainframe envy”

Direct quote from Wikipedia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432

""" Intel's iAPX432 was intended to be Intel's major design for the 1980s. Unlike the 8086, which was designed the following year as a successor to the 8080, the iAPX 432 was a radical departure from Intel's previous designs meant for a different market niche...

Referred to as a "micromainframe", the iAPX 432 was designed to be programmed entirely in high-level languages. """

Folklore describes the 8086 as a stop-gap design, an extension of the popular (but tiny) 8080 CPU. The "real" design project at Intel was the i432, which supported object-oriented programming and was THE FUTURE OF ALL COMPUTING.

A cut-down version of the object oriented support was carried over into the x86 architecture, in its segmented memory model and page-description registers. You're welcome.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by bombcar on Sunday November 05, 2023 @12:26AM (#38148199)
It was great for Intel - but it wasn't great for certain big manufacturers (dinosaurs) that they were courting.

I think they knew they could fall back on x86 if everything went wrong - but what they did NOT expect was x86-64 to just smash everything. That caught them on backfoot.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by p_l on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:20AM (#38150498)
I remember the public roadmaps in tech magazines at the time, and Intel planned on keeping "consumer" market 32bit for longer time - then AMD dropped the Hammer ;>
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by initplus on Saturday November 04, 2023 @08:33PM (#38146736)
Same company that completely missed the boat on mobile not that many years later. Intel have consistently made serious mistakes in their strategic direction. Fumbling 64bit, turning Apple down on mobile, missing GPU/AI.

They are basically just building a better version of the same product they were selling 20 years ago… so much opportunity missed here.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by chasil on Saturday November 04, 2023 @09:18PM (#38147005)
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by deaddodo on Sunday November 05, 2023 @12:14AM (#38148105)
I think they're referring to the Core/Penryn series (the "direct" ancestor to modern Intel x86s).

But even that goes back to the P6->P5->486->386->286->8086->8088->8080->8008->CTC lineage of 50+yrs. It literally just cuts out the few years of the abandoned NetBurst architecture.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday November 04, 2023 @10:47PM (#38147563)
> Did they really think the market would stay bifurcated between “big iron” architectures and x86 personal machines for another decade? I can’t imagine they would have believed that.

I can. The x86 hegemony was overpowering in the PC space but the moment you left that corner of the market we had a lot more ISA diversity then than in the following years. In a world that seemed to have no problem with Macs on PowerPC, PCs on x86, and workstations/servers on SPARC/MIPS/PA-RISC, just consolidating workstations and servers probably seemed reasonable. You can even see an analog in the way we've kept x86 on "real computers" while ARM has dominated mobile. IMHO the only reason it didn't work out is because workstations and servers merged with PCs.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by bitwize on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:05PM (#38146148)
Itanic was hype from the word go. Intel tried and failed twice to make "VLIW CPUs that rely on 'sufficiently smart' HLL compilers doing the right instruction packings" a thing before Itanium came along (iAPX 432 and i860). I think someone very high up at Intel was in love with the idea despite its repeated failures.

Alpha was clearly the future -- and Itanic ruined Alpha. We didn't even get to see it live on inside some other corporate sarlacc.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by BirAdam on Saturday November 04, 2023 @11:27PM (#38147791)
Well, zero speculation would have saved from all of the exploits over the years… so there’s that.
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by fulafel on Sunday November 05, 2023 @02:48AM (#38149174)
I hadn't heard about compiler vs 432 before, any links?
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by p_l on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:25AM (#38150525)
I do recall some discussion about combination of really bad code generation combined with some ridiculously bad design decisions (I think it might have been total lack of cache?)
Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by tjalfi on Sunday November 05, 2023 @10:26AM (#38151897)
The blog entry Revisiting the Intel 432[0] and the cited paper Performance Effects of Architectural Complexity in the Intel 432[1] discuss the compiler issues.

[0] https://bcantrill.dtrace.org/2008/07/18/revisiting-the-intel...

[1] https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/45059.214411

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by bitwize on Sunday November 05, 2023 @02:10PM (#38154498)
All I know is the Wikipedia article references a crappy Ada compiler whose lack of optimization made it run slower than a 286:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by kstrauser on Saturday November 04, 2023 @07:42PM (#38146421)
> Compatibility and ubiquity wins. As nearly always.

In this case, that means AMD showing up with the first x86-compatible 64-bit CPUs killed Itanium dead. For big software projects already running on x86, there were 2 options:

- Port everything to a new architecture that only looked good in specific benchmarks, cross your fingers, and hope for the best.

- Keep running your code on new 64-bit CPUs that were backward compatible with your existing code, then recompile for 64-bit as you got around to it.

As a bonus, amd64/x86-64 CPUs were faster than the P4 chips that practically needed 3 phase power to boot up.

It was kind of a no brainer.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by justin66 on Sunday November 05, 2023 @12:27AM (#38148205)
> Turns out it was more like IBM's MCA / PS2 rather than the future.

It was quite a bit worse than that. If you ignore the horror of IBM vendor lock-in, which in retrospect made the whole thing untenable, and the overpriced nature of the systems, MCA was a fine thing for its time. The PS/2s had some nice features. They were compatible with everyone's DOS and Windows stuff, even if IBM would have preferred you use OS/2, and so on.

Itanium was a piece of crap, even if you could somehow ignore the cost and lock-in.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by fulafel on Sunday November 05, 2023 @02:47AM (#38149168)
> Compatibility and ubiquity wins. As nearly always.

Counterexample: GPU compute.

Re:Intel Itanium IA-64 Support Removed with the Linux 6.7 Ke... by spamizbad on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:17AM (#38150868)
> Compatibility and ubiquity wins. As nearly always.

I'm not sure that was Itanium's only problem. Intel's Itanium launch focused on a market that was not captured by the so-called "Wintel" monopoly: high performance servers. The software support needed in this market was relatively narrow. Nevertheless, it failed there too.

The biggest issue with Itanium is that the juice was never worth the squeeze. It was expensive. The cost to migrate your existing 64bit systems never made sense. So, you might ask, what about 32-bit shops that needed to make the leap to 64 bits? Well, by the time intel and its vendors started getting costs under control, the AMD Opteron hit the scene with commodity 64bit hardware that had the added benefit of full backwards compatibility. And that pretty much killed it.