Typewriters didn't need multiple dash characters, because you can extend a hypen into an en-dash by typing hypen, backspace, half-space, hypen. You can make an em-dash with another backspace, half-space, hypen. Of course, computers lost half spaces and overstriking, for the most part.
Maaaaaaybe you need a separate minus from hypen, but that could be something you swap in, if needed (my typewriter has two keys that you can swap out, if you sent away for the keys anyway; not sure if smith-corona still stocks those)
And gained option and option+shift, which is even better (and many programs will auto-convert multiple hyphens to an en- or em-dash anyway).
How common was half spaces and overstriking anyway? I don't recall seeing it much, but it's been years since I've seen a typewritten letter.
Most people have already decided they prefer variable-width fonts (except when writing code) and multiple typefaces to setting everything in 12pt Courier. Using different dashes instead of just the keyboard hyphen-minus is the same issue.
Now we do our own typing, and increasingly, our own typesetting.
Less than 5% of what I'm doing is related to typography (namely: only when displaying text for the end user). 95% of the time when I manipulate text, the text is intended for a computer to process further. I don't want typographic issues such as the proper length of spaces when delimiting keywords on the command line, or proper collation order to slow down my `git grep`, any more than I want to be bothered by variable width fonts when I'm writing code.
UTF-8 to compose user visible strings in GUI is a godsend, though.
Text is not written only to be read visually by a human on printed paper. Arguably, text today is almost never used that way. What actually matters to humans is that text can be copied and pasted and rendered unambiguously. The distinction between minus-dash, dash, en dash, em dash and minus is pointless. It is literally impossible to confuse one for the other in actual usage. Same for all the 14 technically different quotes in the English language. Literally pointless to anyone but typography geeks.
These typographic rules are vestigial. We have inherited them from a time when it made no sense to limit the number of different characters used in script and it made no sense either to make it easy for a reader to figure out which typesetting blocks the typesetter put on the machine. Both of these things are now very important.
Hyphens and em-dashes have literally opposite functions. Hyphens join words together, as in compound adjectives. Em-dashes separate clauses in a sentence. (And en-dashes are used for ranges.)
They're not extremely niche — they are common and mostly obvious.
> What actually matters to humans is that text can be copied and pasted and rendered unambiguously
Yes. What is ambiguous is the hyphen-minus. It literally combines two meanings in its name.
> These typographic rules are vestigial.
They are still widely used, and still function as intended, so they are not vestigial.
> We have inherited them from a time when it made no sense to limit the number of different characters used in script
I would argue the opposite: they declined in use only because of a (temporary) limit to the number of characters available on some technologies. Thanks to Unicode the limit is removed and their use is increasing again.
The different dashes have different uses and meanings, so it is appropriate that they have different glyphs. It is not nonsense.
Typography will continue to evolve over time. People seem to want more richness and complexity, not less. We've already moved beyond fixed-width fonts, even though that was all typewriters and early computers could do.