Re:Hyphens, minus, and dashes in Debian man pages
by perilunar on Friday November 03, 2023 @10:00AM
(#38128872)
> Using 5 technically different extremely similar glyphs for 4 extremely niche corner cases of typography is nonsense.
They're not extremely niche — they are common and mostly obvious.
> What actually matters to humans is that text can be copied and pasted and rendered unambiguously
Yes. What is ambiguous is the hyphen-minus. It literally combines two meanings in its name.
> These typographic rules are vestigial.
They are still widely used, and still function as intended, so they are not vestigial.
> We have inherited them from a time when it made no sense to limit the number of different characters used in script
I would argue the opposite: they declined in use only because of a (temporary) limit to the number of characters available on some technologies. Thanks to Unicode the limit is removed and their use is increasing again.
Re:Hyphens, minus, and dashes in Debian man pages
by perilunar on Friday November 03, 2023 @10:16AM
(#38129098)
I would also point out that in addition to the different dashes, there are (and with good reason) different hyphens. The hyphen-minus is too overloaded.
They're not extremely niche — they are common and mostly obvious.
> What actually matters to humans is that text can be copied and pasted and rendered unambiguously
Yes. What is ambiguous is the hyphen-minus. It literally combines two meanings in its name.
> These typographic rules are vestigial.
They are still widely used, and still function as intended, so they are not vestigial.
> We have inherited them from a time when it made no sense to limit the number of different characters used in script
I would argue the opposite: they declined in use only because of a (temporary) limit to the number of characters available on some technologies. Thanks to Unicode the limit is removed and their use is increasing again.