News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by oh_sigh on Thursday November 02, 2023 @07:40PM (#38121985)
Neither here nor there, but I just read an article today about how a bunch of birds are being renamed, because of 'harmful' views by Audobon et al

https://apnews.com/article/bird-renaming-american-ornitholog...

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by oooyay on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:59PM (#38122923)
John Audubon was a slaver outside of his contributions to birding. That's why all the "Audubon Societies" are changing their names. The rest of the birds are birds named after people and the general decree is to rename all birds named after people and never name things after people again. They'll all have descriptive names now.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by oh_sigh on Thursday November 02, 2023 @09:43PM (#38123301)
Neither here nor there, but my alma mater (TCNJ) renamed a building a few years ago - from "Loser Hall" to "Trenton Hall". Paul Loser was the superintendent of the Trenton school system in the early 20th century, and he was in support of segregation of black people into separate school systems. So, a reasonable renaming I think. But renaming it Trenton is itself problematic - Trenton is named after William Trent, a merchant who became one of the richest men in Philadelphia by trading, among other things, literal boatloads of slaves, which seems strictly worse than believing "merely" in segregation.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by bobthepanda on Thursday November 02, 2023 @09:58PM (#38123417)
I think the most silly version is that King County in Washington, named after a pro slavery vice president, was renamed… to King County, in honor of Martin Luther King Jr.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by selimthegrim on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:36PM (#38123745)
Wait until you hear about Judge Perez Drive in St. Bernard Parish, Louisiana.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by GauntletWizard on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:16PM (#38123573)
That's the least silly - it cost nothing in confusion and chaos, they slowly replaced the branding, and (almost, unless you really, really hate philanderers) everyone agrees the new subject was a great man.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by bobthepanda on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:40PM (#38132246)
Right, it’s a low-effort cop out without any actual hard work.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by kbelder on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:48AM (#38130553)
In a nearby city, we had a 'Dead Indian Highway'. It was eventually renamed to 'Dead Indian Memorial Highway'.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:08PM (#38123503)
> That's why all the "Audubon Societies" are changing their names.

According to the article, the National Audubon Society is keeping their name, which I think is probably for the best.

Renaming birds named after people is a good idea too, but it's nice to be able acknowledge that people can do amazing things that deserve recognition while also doing terrible things that should be condemned. The blanket painting of people as either heroes or villains is childish and doesn't reflect reality or the complex nature of what it is to be human.

Renaming the National Audubon Society would make about as much sense as renaming the Washington Monument. A history of slavery is something that has tainted the pasts of human civilizations all over the globe and continues to be a problem even today. In the US it's a very large and shameful part of our history, but I think it's probably better to face that openly rather than to try and sweep that shame under the rug by erasing anyone involved.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by chottocharaii on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:14PM (#38123551)
OTOH slavery is so morally abhorrent that it far outweighs any positive contributions a person might make in their lifetime. I think its good that society condemns it in the strongest possible manner, including by renaming
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:46PM (#38123822)
I can understand that others won't feel the same way I do.

Would you then support renaming the Washington monument? Removing any mention of his name from history books, or taking him off of our money? Should we take "Washington Crossing the Delaware" down from the walls of The Met and burn it?

I don't think that the bad things someone does should cause us to pretend that the good things never happened. We should see people for who they were, the good and the bad, even if in the end there was more of one than the other.

It might even be that the worst someone was, the more important it is that we shouldn't forget the good things. It helps remind us that everyone has the capacity for (and a history of) acts both good and evil and that even those who have done terrible things that could never be "made up for" (if that's ever even possible) are/were still capable of making the choice to do something wonderful.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by hooverd on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:27AM (#38124888)
Well, Washington was our first president, so he can get away with that. If chapters of the Audubon society want to rename themselves, I say let them. The living shouldn't be beholden to the dead. It's nothing but a name at this point Also he and Audubon weren't really known for upholding the cause of slavery. I think Mount Blue Sky (formerly Evans) is an example of something that ran the opposite direction. We all agreed it was better off not to commemorate a disgraced territorial governor.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:52AM (#38125029)
> I think Mount Blue Sky (formerly Evans) is an example of something that ran the opposite direction. We all agreed it was better off not to commemorate a disgraced territorial governor.

Yeah, I don't have any problem with that one either. I'm not even sure what, if any, connection he had to the mountain. It's not like John Evans was super into mountains and inspired generations of others to get really into the enjoyment/study/preservation of mountains. It's really not clear what naming it after him was for exactly.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by mrobins on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:05AM (#38127477)
Changing the name of a landmark or a species may require thoughtful consideration but not an organization. Companies change names all the time and a bad name drags an org doing good work down. Why should employees have to come to work in the name of someone who doesn’t deserve it in the light of history.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by GuardianCaveman on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:05PM (#38123946)
I mean, half the country thought it was fine so you can automatically remove monuments to anyone who lived in the south and some parts of the north from 1619 to 1865. And yes I know only a small percentage owned slaves but that's because they were expensive not because no one else wanted to.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:15PM (#38124013)
When it comes to monuments it's important to consider what it is they are honoring. We can keep monuments that celebrate the amazing acts of otherwise flawed people, but (as an example) I think that those monuments by the UDC which were created to glorify people because they fought for the right to keep slaves is something very different.

I'm not okay with the idea of destroying those kinds of statues and monuments, they are still artistic and cultural works after all, but they are probably best left to be displayed in civil war and civil rights museums where they can be contextualized appropriately.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by pbj1968 on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:24PM (#38124096)
You know what would be better than some mythical museum of context? Melting that garbage down into park benches or public toilets.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:00AM (#38124347)
> You know what would be better than some mythical museum of context? Melting that garbage down

Do you think civil war/rights museums are mythical? I promise you that there are several and if you've never seen one you should really make the time. I'll warn you though that they are filled with many things you'd find extremely distasteful which is exactly how they should be.

Ugly as it is, it's our history. A group of KKK loving racists put monuments of their heroes up all over the place including state capitol buildings and courthouses and some remained for over a century. That actually happened.

Current and future generations should be able to see those monuments with their own eyes, the same way that they should be able to visit Auschwitz or the Hiroshima Peace Memorial. We need to confront our history and learn from it, not just erase the parts that make us uncomfortable. It would be wrong to take away that opportunity by destroying all evidence of the shameful things in humanity's past.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by mensetmanusman on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:34PM (#38124151)
Renaming is probably counterproductive as many view erasing history with suspicion. We could more agree to actually fight slavery today, as there are more today than in years past.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by mistercheph on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:22AM (#38125539)
This will be said, and said rightly, about a great deal of the things that you and I do every single day without thought.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by deely3 on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:30AM (#38125584)
Private, for profit prisons?
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by barry-cotter on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:53PM (#38131476)
This is trolling, right? You think there’s a meaningful moral differences between whether the constituency for keeping more people locked up for longer are government employees or private sector companies?
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by silisili on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:52AM (#38125721)
Where is the line drawn? AFAICT we just outsourced slavery, which is equally abhorrent. We all own electronics, clothes, and other trinkets made under duress, and knowingly. Should we all be denigrated and forgotten for turning a blind eye?
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by autoexec on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:30AM (#38125956)
Yeah I can't imagine history is going to be very kind to us https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-57522186

Audubon was born into a world where slavery was considered a perfectly normal part of life and widely practiced. We don't have that excuse. We're supposed to know better than this. We just try to forget about the slaves that made our iphones and give a pass to the corporations responsible.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by bombcar on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:14AM (#38127557)
We do as all times do, glorify what we do, ignore the evil we do, and complain about those before us who did the evil we do not do.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by kergonath on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:55AM (#38127984)
It is “good that society condemns it in the strongest possible manner” and ideally never does it again. But the problem of this absolutist black-and-white view is that you’re missing a lot of details and nuance. Someone can be both good and bad, in fact all of us are. Everyone deserves to be commended for their good actions and vilified for their bad ones.

The other problem is when this all-or-nothing way of thinking escapes this kind of narrow case and seeps into the common public discourse, see the way politics are evolving in way too many western countries.

That said, renaming birds named after obscure figures is generally a good thing, descriptive names are more useful and don’t require knowledge of the historical background to make sense.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by mannyv on Thursday November 02, 2023 @10:19PM (#38123588)
Not all the audubon societies are changing.

IMO it's ridiculous. Why not change the name of the Democratic parry while they're at it? They were the party of slavers.

Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by hooverd on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:16AM (#38124820)
Well, the Democratic party isn't named after a particular person for one.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by Rebelgecko on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:59AM (#38125075)
Democratic is derived from the Greek "δῆμος", which was a term used to delineate free people from slaves
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by mjan22640 on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:40AM (#38125651)
Demos means people, while slaves in antiquity were not considered people but living tools.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by enw on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:43AM (#38128647)
It's ridiculous. If we measured all past without nuance and with the fleeting standards of some people of today, everything would be abhorrent. I'm sad to see this way of thinking permeate so deep in our culture.
Re:In 1886, the US Commissioned 7,500 Watercolor Paintings o... by kristopolous on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:14AM (#38125137)
It doesn't look like any of them were comically racist and were just named after questionable people.

I was hoping there'd be things so antiquated you'd have to look it up, eg: stereotypes about people from Dalmatia or Tyrol based on some scandal from 1832.