There are some quirks to it (ie Mint only lets you export up to 10K transactions at a time) but there are work-arounds to it. You can sign-up, link your accounts, then import from Mint to fill in the missing history. If you hit any issues, just Contact Support from within the app and our Customer Support team will work with you to get it sorted out.
Mobile first ones are nifty (used copilot for a bit), mainly for on the fly category updating, but after budgeting with Monarch on the web for a year and change now I don't think I can go back to a primarily app based one. Much easier to sit down once a week and crank through / review everything on web interface.
Thanks for the great work you and the Monarch team are doing, it's helped my wife and I save a lot of cash since we started using it
I still think YNAB is invaluable for people that have to really tightly manage money to make sure they have enough cash on hand at the end of the month to pay rent, for example. But now that I'm in a position where I have a little more cushion, I've grown tired of the constant queue of transactions to approve and the general micromanagement in YNAB
I just can't wrap my head around the Goals feature. I've noticed the following:
1. Monarch expects specific accounts to be used for specific Goals, for example, a savings account for a vacation fund.
2. A transaction can only be associated with a goal if it is from the account attached to the goal.
I actually completely agree with Monarch on this. If you're using a savings account for your vacation fund and you buy plane tickets with checking, you should have to transfer money to match. In YNAB you don't have to. I choose to regularly create transfers so my account balances match the category balance in YNAB, but YNAB doesn't require me to.
However, this completely breaks down with:
3. Some account types don't support transactions. Retirement accounts show your portfolio but not transactions.
So if I have a Goal to contribute $100 to an IRA every month, and I debit $100 from my checking to transfer it to the IRA, it's impossible to mark this Goal as complete because there is no corresponding credit of $100 in the IRA. The balance of the portfolio increases but that doesn't matter.
It is sad, but is it sad enough that if a large co offers to buy your company and make you very wealthy, you're going to decline?
Sorry for the cynicism but this cycle of adopting a software tool only for that to be bought out and subsequently shut down is getting pretty old. I'm sure Mint's initial sales pitch was also about passionate founders who cared about their customers. This is probably the nature of companies--no one will care as much about a product as much as the people who first created it, but the cycle seems so much faster with software.
This behavior has fully converted me from "optimistic early adopter" to "late majority" on the Adopter Categories chart. I honestly don't trust any startup's products anymore, because of the real risk that they're going to cash in their chips and let the product die, probably when it's least convenient for me the customer. To be fair, I don't trust a lot of bigger companies too--there is at least one example of a BigTech company notorious for trying things and then shutting them down within a years or months!
Hadn't seen it put so clearly but yeah same. Not even limited to tech unfortunately, same issue with TV Shows. Why watch Season 1 set up a bunch of cool premises if there's not gonna be any pay-off?
Mint partially supported this but QuickBooks did it better.
https://help.monarchmoney.com/hc/en-us/articles/360048393372...
I had always hoped Intuit planned on adding Quickbooks features into Mint, but they never did.
A financial info aggregator is the one place where I would appreciate NOT having my data and behavior exfiltrated to third parties.
I'm only blocking 27 things with most of them being Split.io (for A/B testing I presume) Sprig, Stripe and Sentry.
Those aren't really third-party trackers (even though I am blocking most of them) in the marketing sense..
There's some analytics from Tiktok, Clarity, Reddit and Spotify(??), which make sense to block but don't feel that intrusive if they're tracking inbound referrals.
I don't even see 50 other things that I could be blocking.
Not arguing the point here, just wondering what I'm missing since I try to keep pretty extensive block lists myself.
My lists are:
- uBlock
- EasyList
- EasyPrivacy
- Online Malicious URL Blocklist
- Peter Lowe’s Ad and tracking server list
- uBlock filters – Annoyances
- AdGuard Annoyances filter
- pl: Oficjalne Polskie Filtry
> There's some analytics from Tiktok, Clarity, Reddit and SpotifyYeah, if my bank started embedding those on their account page, I would GTFO.
This is completely inexcusable from a fintech company. It shows me, as a potential customer, that they're not serious - either they're trying to get acquihired or they have no idea about privacy.
This is pretty standard stuff, and while I'm not a fan of trackers and I personally block them, I don't resent companies that want to understand their traffic and prospects.
As a business you want to know which paid channels are working and where your traffic is coming from.
A question for you then, if this is "completely inexcusable": How else do you propose that companies monitor their sales and marketing efforts?
I would bet that the JS is an implementation shortcut, and a way for the analytics service to avoid doing customer-side implementation support. Keep things as simple as possible (which is a reasonable business goal).
Plus it means that the service you're using can refactor or change around how they handle things and you don't need to be updating your code all the time?
But the tradeoff is that you end up in this situation where people ask "why do you need to load a JS file from a third party?"
By simply asking users how and where they found out about a service? Sure there is a possibility that some users might not respond truthfully (or at all), but I believe that the quality of data collected in this (respectful) way still trumps that of data snitched from unsuspecting users but skewed by those who use adblockers (not unlikely in the case of a fintech service because of expected higher user awareness of privacy concerns).
That doesn't feel like a great user experience. As a user, I would just button past that pop-up or form.
The goal with these kinds of analytics is not to get referral information from only users who sign up, but for anyone who lands on the page - maybe just to read about you at first - so you have a sense of where they came from and how your marketing spend is doing.
Most paid traffic doesn't convert. If you want to know how much of it is converting, you need to also know how much didn't convert.
There are several ways:
- Have a specific URL for each entry into the sales funnel - you see this on YouTube with things like "go to blahblahblah.com/witty-tag to sign up and get my discount"
- Look at the referrer URL if you don't want separate incoming links per entry
- Ask for a referral code when someone is creating their account - this allows you to track entry from people referred into the product
- Have a field on the signup page where you ask this question instead of invading the user's privacy to get it
There are many ways that don't involve sticking a ton of trackers on a signup page, a page that by definition, all of your users must go through at least once and part of the face of your company. To me, it's not a good look that these trackers are there and invasive.This is my fear for any finapp I try now, as I was on Mint, and now left. At what point will Monarch be acquired and/or begin to sell me things I don't want to increase profits?
What financial service, new or old, doesn't do this already?
90% of the communication from my bank is them trying to push additional services on me. It's never about what's good for me, it's what's good for them.
In this space we've seen companies come and go and the ones that stay have a business model that works every day. That means providing a great service, charging people reasonably prices for the product and avoiding selling data or advertising. Mint was never sustainable, but the founders did well to sell it to Intuit when they did.
Pocketsmith uses Google Analytics and Mixpanel, and that's it - no remarketing and fully GDPR complaint. The company is strong in UK, Australia and New Zealand, with decent US support too. But I'd be interested to see what others see.
I'm the minor investor.
1. Have you got an import function if we have csv or in other formats?
2. My only issue with Lunchmoney is my connections are often broken. They use Plaid. Is this one of those things where if they have a problem, you also will? Or does your implementation of plaid integration affect stability?
Disclaimer: I'm one of the co-founders of Monarch Money, a (paid) competitor to Mint founded by the original PM on Mint.com. I had written a HackerNews front-pager a couple years ago about why Revenue Model is More Important Than Culture [0], and my co-founder wrote some thoughts about why Mint ended up going this route.
Since this announcement, we've seen an unprecedented influx of "Mint refugees" moving over. I think a lot of Mint folks have felt like the product has been neglected for years, but it was free and they often had years of history in the product. This was kind of a forcing function for them.
0: https://somehowmanage.com/2020/09/20/revenue-model-not-cultu... 1: https://www.monarchmoney.com/blog/mint-shutting-down