News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lawlessone on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:40AM (#38099764)
I agree with some of what the author says. Especially about how cashless means i can't just give a homeless person spare change.

But having worked at a cash register at for a period in my life theres a lot of good reasons businesses do this.

Stores dealing in cash need a float at the register. Where I was that was 500 euro. That's 500 euro in coins and lower value notes that has to be at every register so that anyone that pays in cash can be given the correct change.

A large store near me has about 20 registers, that during very busy periods could all be open. So to guarantee they can accept cash on a busy day like that means having 10 grand to just park in these registers.

That's 10k that's vulnerable to theft either from employees or robbers.

Security vans have to be hired to take the days takings to a bank and bring lower denominations to the store to fill these floats.

When someone finishes a shift they have to spend time what they have, that doesn't take long but it's another cost for the company.

It also means insurance costs are higher.

The guy only accepting card payments from his horsebox converted to a coffee shop doesn't worry about any of this.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by boomchinolo78 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:51AM (#38099981)
Card is a permanent %2+ tax, how does it compare?
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by dghlsakjg on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:59AM (#38100138)
See my sibling comment, but it is hard to quantify how much cash costs because a lot of the costs are indirect or infrequent capital costs. Things like employee time, and money handling equipment. It will also vary enormously based on the scale and nature of the business.

A small coffee shop can get by with a $129 cash drawer hooked up to an iPad and a manager spending a few hours per week counting money and visiting the bank. A large store like Walmart can easily spend $100k+ on all of the equipment for cash handling in addition to having to contract with an armored car company.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by jfengel on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:09PM (#38104267)
Note that "a few hours per week" for the manager costs perhaps $30/hour total compensation. That's more than the price of that drawer, every week.

Over a year, it's perhaps 4 hours/week x $30/hour x 52 weeks/year, which comes to over $6,000. That's real money for a small coffee shop.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by dghlsakjg on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:52AM (#38099987)
I think a lot of people miss out on how expensive cash is. I worked as a cashier at a store, and at a bank branch that mostly dealt with commercial customers, and there are a LOT of indirect costs associated with cash.

With digital payments you see exactly how much the payments cost. Swipe fee + processing fee, and it isn't fun as a business owner to see ~3% of your money going to a bank.

With cash, it takes some effort to tally the costs. Cash handling equipment: POS, safes, bill counters for larger merchants, etc... Then you have to add the amount of time your employees spend on cash: counting drawers at the start, counting drawers at the end, managers counting money into and out of the safe, managers taking cash to the bank, or hiring a service to do that, cash goes missing through malice and negligence, etc...

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lawlessone on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:07PM (#38100287)
Dealing with it a register was a pain to say the least. You'll constantly have people demanding change in particular notes etc.

You often have to watch out for people insisting they handed you a 50 so they can scam you into more change. Or get chewed out by someone for the wrong change when really they just dropped the note on the way back to their car. None of that can happen with a card.

The card payments are nearly atomic, you paid or you didn't. In a year doing the work I only once had someone claim a card payment took the wrong amount and it was a very dubious claim.

For cash i'd often I'd have to call a manager to request more cash for the float. Because the older customer base would spend their morning queueing outside at an ATM the buy the smallest cheapest thing to get change, which they only needed to pay another businesses that only dealt in cash.

It goes without saying my views are biased from dealing with cash paying people.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by aleph_minus_one on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:33PM (#38100749)
> I think a lot of people miss out on how expensive cash is. I worked as a cashier at a store, and at a bank branch that mostly dealt with commercial customers, and there are a LOT of indirect costs associated with cash.

Then powerful trade organizations should lobby for introducing a system of digital payments that offers at least the same level of anonymity as cash.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by dghlsakjg on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:20PM (#38101524)
Why would they lobby for that?

Merchants don't particularly care about the anonymity of cash. Most merchants are rather fond of collecting data about their customers.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by fwungy on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:35PM (#38103690)
Then they can't resell your data.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by mensetmanusman on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:17AM (#38128272)
Governments won’t let it happen. Cash is the only solution.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by mattmaroon on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:07PM (#38101327)
I’ve had a theory for many years that incorrect decisions are often made simply because the cost or benefit of one option is tangible and that of another aren’t.

For instance employers underpay employees because the cost of paying your employees more is easy to calculate but the cost of not doing so (turnover, etc.) is real but hard to determine.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by dghlsakjg on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:18PM (#38101490)
Another one in the same vein is bad hiring processes. It is somewhat easy to tell when you hired the wrong person. It is close to impossible to know if you passed on the right person.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by mattmaroon on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @02:11PM (#38102389)
Yeah that’s why everyone in software just says “no false positives”. I don’t think they really do anything differently, but they think they do.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by bwanab on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:16PM (#38101455)
And yet, there are lots of businesses that give a discount for cash specifically because of that 3% fee. Yes, I know the standard trope is that it's so they can avoid taxes and in some cases that's surely true. But, for many, if not most businesses, there are way too many paper trails for the IRS (or whatever the taxman is called in your country) to follow that would make that difficult to pull off at any worthwhile scale.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by dghlsakjg on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:41PM (#38101895)
If I had to guess why some businesses do this I would speculate on two things:

1. Like I said, there are a lot of indirect costs with cash, and a lot of businesses are just bad at calculating these things (a surprising number of business owners are REALLY bad with money and valuing time). For example, an owner managed business might not value or care about the owner having to count and make trips to the bank.

2. Something in the nature of the business favors cash. For example, if your average transaction value is < $5 and you are running a hundred + swipes per day the fixed swipe fees of $.10-$.30 are going to HURT (think convenience store). Another example might be low/no margin stuff like gasoline, gas is the loss leader for stations hoping you'll buy a snack with a huge margin, so they offer a cash discount since it is cheaper for them AND you have to go into the store, which increases the chance of an impulse buy.

Someone with average transaction value of > $100 who only runs ten transactions a day isn't that worried about losing a dollar to swipe fees in exchange for not having to keep thousands on premise at the end of the day (think car mechanic).

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by creer on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:51PM (#38105024)
One is the cost they are used to (the cost of managing cash), the other is the new outrageous cost (card processing fees, cost of the machines, etc)
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by JohnFen on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:42PM (#38103810)
> I think a lot of people miss out on how expensive cash is.

If the expense is that big of a problem, then stores could put in a surcharge for using cash. I'd pay it. It would be well worth it to avoid having to use cards.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by idopmstuff on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#38105201)
This would almost certainly cause a substantial public backlash that would outweigh the benefit.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by petre on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:10PM (#38104290)
It' s the cost of doing business. With cashless you need a POS, digital infrastructure, the bank takes a cut, Visa takes a cut, no cell service or too many people on a cell means not doing business, doubled payments mean headaches for both cashiers and customers.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by hndamien on Thursday November 02, 2023 @03:00PM (#38118403)
I would settle for accepting Monero in lieu of accepting cash payments.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by ARandumGuy on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:55AM (#38100060)
These are all very good reasons why a business may not want to accept cash. Cash adds a lot of overhead and security risks that can completely negate any savings gained by not having to pay credit card fees.

The problem is that if enough businesses stop accepting cash, then it becomes nigh impossible to participate in society if you can only pay in cash. Which can be a big problem in the US, where not everyone has access to credit cards or free checking accounts.

This is why I support regulation that requires businesses to accept cash. Yes, it adds overhead. But it also means the most vulnerable in our society are actually able to buy things.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by cbdumas on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:38PM (#38100855)
An alternative might be regulation ensuring people have access to banking services, either privately or by the government offering these services directly
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lawlessone on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:31PM (#38101710)
I'm biased here, but a basic electronic income seems like a solution to me.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by ta_vf7xjd34cc on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:07PM (#38101330)
> But it also means the most vulnerable in our society are actually able to buy things.

Forcing banks and digital wallet providers to provide users a prepaid card/digital balance in exchange for cash is a good alternative. This should be a part of the charter/license under which such organisations operate.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by JohnFen on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:47PM (#38103874)
That doesn't address the issue of all the tracking and data collection that comes with using cards, though. That crap is why I prefer to use cash.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by ale42 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:57AM (#38100082)
All this about the costs of dealing with cash are true. But they're especially true for the big players.

I've seen several shops (including small coffee and ice cream places) telling people more or less openly that they prefer cash. Because card companies take a margin on every transaction, and don't allow them to charge more to compensate. Some try to go around the other way (offering e.g. a 5% discount to people paying cash - I had this at a restaurant). The problem is that the big ones can negotiate lower transaction fees with the card companies...

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lawlessone on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:14PM (#38100412)
I suspect some of it's a tax thing as it's a lot harder to hide income when all your transactions are digital.

hypocrisy on my part but I have probably benefitted from paying cash for handiwork done that was only cheap because the person might not have paid tax.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by ale42 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:57PM (#38105103)
If you get paid cash and give a receipt/cash ticket, I'm not sure you can avoid declaring that revenue to the tax authorities. It's enough that one of your customers uses that ticket to deduce it as a professional expense from their own tax declaration to get potentially caught.

I was hearing that all the time before card payments were a common thing (i.e. in the '80s, writing from Europe), "didn't get a receipt... they want to avoid taxes"

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lucubratory on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:44PM (#38108366)
I mean yeah, if you give out a receipt as any sort of tradesman you're probably going to have to report that income or risk tax evasion prosecution. I have personally never had a tradesman give me a receipt, always cash-in-hand, for anything at home. Work expenses a receipt is required though, and those I pay with card anyway.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by creer on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:14PM (#38105371)
I don't know about that. I mean there are not many places (at least around here) that don't use cash registers. Nothing eliminates fraud but just because it's cash doesn't make it obvious or foolproof.

At the same time, we often hear of ludicrous ways to try and beat the tax authority. I'm sure people try often enough.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by c22 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:58AM (#38100107)
There are huge risks to operating any sort of physical retail establishment, well beyond managing the change in the tills. This doesn't mean the world would be better served if all retail happened online. The risks are worth the rewards.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lawlessone on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:23PM (#38100574)
>well beyond managing the change in the tills.

It's not small change though.

Shop lifters are an issue but weight limits the value of what they could steal. The shop doesn't have to pay for an armored truck to deliver the milk, a regular truck works fine because we don't have armed milk robbers.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by c22 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:36PM (#38100812)
There are risks in physical retail far beyond managing the shoplifting problem as well. In fact, theft of all sorts is only a small portion of the risk-pie here.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by OfSanguineFire on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:21PM (#38100529)
> cashless means i can't just give a homeless person spare change.

You could, if there were just more uptake of digital payments by individuals. In China, beggars asking to be paid via app has been a thing for years now. There are beggars in parts of sub-Saharan Africa who use the local very developed mobile-payments infrastructure.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by AlanYx on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:06PM (#38104222)
>In China, beggars asking to be paid via app has been a thing for years now.

This is true -- street beggars in China typically have printed and laminated QR codes to make contributions easier.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by pengaru on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:34PM (#38101763)
Here in the US most of the stores with that many cashiers are grocery stores and have become increasingly automated via "self checkout", and they're still perfectly capable of accepting cash - it's like an ATM machine, and far more challenging to rob with a gun.

The locale I've most encountered the cashless shift has been Santa Monica, not at the grocery stores with tons of cashiers, but at small restaurants and such where they've embraced cashless and in many cases menu-less as well. It's outright hostile to find yourself socializing there without a phone and just a wad of cash. And it should be made illegal IMNSHO, as these are public spaces operating with a business license discriminating against those without credit cards and/or smartphones. This is private members-only club levels of B.S. Portland is another locale I've been affected by this BTW.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by creer on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:55PM (#38105075)
The costs are just one side of it. A good reason to accept both cash and cards is that customers like that. No doubt it would be cheaper to stock only one brand of cereals and yet nobody does that.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by idopmstuff on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:01PM (#38105162)
If this is the argument, though, then it's a good one to let the market sort out. If customers have a strong enough preference for cash that it outweighs the costs, businesses can figure this out and accept cash.

Different stores can have different options in terms of how they handle cash. Costco only has one kind of toilet paper. Target has 10. There are pluses and minuses that they can weigh themselves.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by creer on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#38105236)
It's one argument but yes and no.

I was thinking it's one argument for the store that has the OPTION to go cashless and might not - just so as to serve more customers.

But the store is not deciding on its own. For example if costs are pushed by outside forces too far one way or the other. Say, if the tax authority makes it hell to accept cash. Well then the store does not really have the option. The decision has been made for them.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Thursday November 02, 2023 @08:35AM (#38112628)
Fine, so why they won't let us pay with anonymous cards? All the benefit of cashless without surrendering your privacy roghts. But no, they insist that every card be registered, identity scrupulously verified. Because terrorism, think of the children and what not.