ta_vf7xjd34cc
You should read the Constitution before making random statements like these. The Parliament is supreme because every part of the Supreme Court (size, age of the judges etc) is in the hands of Parliament.
Unfortunately, like most countries including the United States, politicians prefer to use the Supreme Court to tackle knotty political issues. So, from the outside, it looks as if these courts are all powerful. Till someone proves that they are not. Like Indira Gandhi did during the Emergency.
The US has Marbury v. Madison. We have the Basic Structure Doctrine. The SCI invented a "Collegium" in the same way that they did the BSD. I am not going to go into whether these things are good or bad.
If the President asked the judges to go pound sand, there is nothing can can do about it except hold a press conference.
I consider the striking down of the NJAC to be illegitimate. If the government of the day had a backbone, every single judge would have been impeached.
Given that many small businesses often accept UPI payments in multiple names (husband, wife, mother etc), a small family can actually manage ₹1,500,000-3,000,000 in (legitimate) tax free income.
That is about $18-36,000.
Which is a lot in India.
Would dog-lovers take umbrage if their food orders are delivered from the same bag that also contains dog-meat? Would Jews and Muslims do that if their package was drenched with juices from an order for pork? The answer is obvious. When it comes to Hindus and Jains however, the argument is that their sentiments should not be respected because of "caste" or "purity."
However, I think that shelving the separate uniform colors idea is a good thing. In parts of the country, riders in green uniforms would be prime targets for hooligans of the jihadi-left variety.
Reclaiming your own temples, after giving the injured party land to rebuild their mosque, is not persecution in my book. I would argue that building a mosque after demolishing a temple at the place Hindus believe their Lord was born was a deliberate provocation, and the other party refusing to let it go for 500 years was persecution of Hindus and their faith.
No other mosque in Ayodhya was touched when this particular mosque was demolished three decades back. If Hindus were truly supremacist, every single one would have been.
> minority
There are more than 600,000 mosques in India and over 200 million Muslims. They are a second majority.
> When modern histories describe this period, this time when all the old religions died away and Christianity finally became pre-eminent, they tend to call it the “triumph of Christianity.” It is worth remembering, however, the original Roman meaning of the word “triumph.” A true Roman triumph wasn’t merely about the victory of the winner. It was about the total and utter subjugation of the loser. In a true Roman triumph the losing side was paraded through the capital while the winning side looked on at an enemy whose soldiers had been slain, whose possessions had been despoiled and whose leaders had been humiliated.
> A triumph was not merely a “victory.” It was an annihilation.
> ...
> For before it preserved, the Church destroyed. In a spasm of destruction never seen before—and one that appalled many non-Christians watching it—during the fourth and fifth centuries, the Christian Church demolished, vandalized and melted down a simply staggering quantity of art. Classical statues were knocked from their plinths, defaced, defiled and torn limb from limb. Temples were razed to their foundations and mutilated. A temple widely considered to be the most magnificent in the entire empire was leveled. Many of the Parthenon sculptures were attacked, faces were mutilated, hands and limbs were hacked off, and gods were decapitated. Some of the finest statues on the whole building were almost certainly smashed off then ground into rubble that was then used to build churches. Books—which were often stored in temples —suffered terribly. The remains of the greatest library in the ancient world, a library that had once held perhaps 700,000 volumes, were destroyed in this way by Christians. It was over a millennium before any other library would even come close to its holdings. Works by censured philosophers were forbidden and bonfires blazed across the empire as outlawed books went up in flames.
Unlike other henotheistic/polytheistic/pagan faiths that were erased from the face of the earth by Abrahamics, Hinduism is still around. Which means every mosque or church that was built on top of a demolished temple stands as a monument to colonization and conquest of a people and a festering wound on the face of the nation. The conquerors' own words and acts, such as leaving parts of the temple still standing as a deliberate insult to the conquered people, betray their intentions.[1]
The Ram temple in Ayodhya is built after demolishing one such mosque (known as Masjid-i-Janmasthan in the 18th/19th centuries, and Babri Masjid in the 20th) built on the ruins of a temple in the city where Lord Ram is believed to have been born in the Treta Yuga. There are an estimated 40,000 such mosque/church-over-temple structures all across India, about 2,000 of which were documented in a two-volume book written in the early 1990s.[2]
This is decolonization at work.
[1] The "Might of Islam" Mosque (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quwwat-ul-Islam_mosque)
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_Temples:_What_Happened_t...
You know just as well as I do that these positions are not those of two random writers, but that of the ideological Left in each country.[1][2][3] I have seen these discussed at length on tv, youtube and in print in both countries.
[1] https://www.npr.org/2021/06/10/1002594108/a-growing-number-o...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/12/us/politics/electoral-col...
[3] https://scroll.in/article/1049779/modis-new-parliament-could...
> The most obvious result of this scheme is that individual voters in small-population states tend to have more power in choosing the President than individual voters in high-population states, and that difference can skew an election.
The Indian Left:[1]
> enlarging the numbers of lawmakers in relation to population growth in a way penalizes those states that have achieved more in terms of slowing down their demographic growth
Completely inconsistent, self-serving arguments which basically want to change the electoral system because their side is losing.
[1] Equality or Fraternity? Challenges of India’s New Constituency Delimitation (https://thediplomat.com/2021/11/equality-or-fraternity-chall...)
When a group of Parsis landed in Gujarat (Western India), the local chieftain posed a question to the leader of the group in the form of a glass of milk. The leader responded by adding a spoon of sugar to the glass and stirring the contents. The answer was found to be acceptable and the Parsis, the tiniest of the minorities, continue to live and prosper in India to this day.
Would they have managed this if the leader had smashed the glass, danced on the fragments, and then taken a hammer to the face of the principal deity at the local temple?
Immigration wiped out Native American tribes, and many other peoples, because the people who immigrated were different and were in no mood to assimilate. Europe is facing this kind of immigration, not the Parsis.
A father who wonders if his daughter will be stabbed in school today may not vocalize such sentiment, but when the time to cast a vote comes, that vote will go to Geert Wilders.
"Allegedly."[1]
Western media has a basic competency/honesty problem when it comes to reporting on India. If you want to situate the October 7 terror attacks in Israel within a particular "context," maybe you should do the same when it comes to reporting on communal rioting in India.
[1] BBC admits to underreporting Rs 40 crore income tax in India (https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2023/jun/06/bbc-admi...)
Genocide is a tactic. Like nuking, flooding, fire bombing cities. Or beheading people. Or setting them afire. Or punishing entire tribes/clans for the crimes of one individual.
Universal morality does not exist. Whether something is "right" or "wrong" depends on the context in which it is used.
If the article were truly written by someone whose heart bleeds for those suffering from lead poisoning in the Indian subcontinent, they would restrict themselves to that single issue. These potshots at the leaders together with the emphasis on "foreign expertise" and ""effective NGOs" shows two things:
- the colonial supremacist mindset is alive and well. It is merely adopted a new form conducive to this era.
- NGO-fronted regime change operations are not doing so well in this part of the world.
> Most of these governments are corrupt to the bone.
As are most governments in the West. Lobbying and campaign contributions is bribery by another name.
Parts of every Western power center are for sale at the right price. That does not mean that it is acceptable for their enemies to initiate regime change operations in these places.
I can get behind the feeling of the word, but I absolutely hate this word as it has generally been used in the sense that everything modern (science, technology, people) is smarter/more advanced than anything that is old.
If something was produced as a result of a rational thought process (no ghosts, demons, Gods involved), I would be loathe to call it pseudoscience even if it didn't work most of the time. For e.g. building, clothing, weaponry that works in one climate/area may not work if you transplant it to another place on Earth. That does not mean that the techniques used are pseudoscientific in nature. They were the science of that place and time.
> If you visit a traditional doctor he feels your wrist for a while and is able to create diagnoses with that along with looking at you and talking.
A lot of traditional medicine practitioners today are probably quacks. It is possible that something of import was lost over hundreds of generations of knowledge transfer. As we have access to modern medicine that can quickly relieve symptoms, looking into what was lost might be considered to be a waste of time by some when an easier alternative is available.
The culture that gave the world Ayurveda and the Surya Siddhanta and the Nasadiya Sukta is very different from the ones which believe that God has said that the Earth is flat or ones where God's agents on Earth harassed/murdered scientists because their theories were in conflict with their interpretation of their belief[2][3]
The article has a table, if you can be bothered to read it.
> what the pharmacology / mechanism of action is
I too don't visit a doctor or believe in the efficacy of any modern medical treatment until someone on HN who has linked to an article/book on medicine lists out the complete treatment methodology for thousands of diseases after having proved to me that he has read all the relevant literature on the subject.
> As it stands now, it doesn't seem there are any legit usages.
Well, many governments in the Indian subcontinent and a lot of people in the subcontinent believe that there are. UG and PG courses in Ayurveda are offered and tens of thousands of students complete their education and practise in the field.[1]
[1] Under-Graduate Programme - Ayurvedacharya - BAMS (https://nia.nic.in/bams.html)
It does not come to my mind because the propaganda that Ayurveda is a pseudoscience has been so successfully drilled into me over the decades that I have never been to an Ayurvedic doctor nor do I know of anyone who has.
The article I linked to has a table with a few formulations, their doses and the disorders they are meant to treat, but I don't have first hand knowledge of any of them.
> this practice of eating lead and mercury
Are people popping aspirin pills referred to as ones eating Willow bark? People don't eat lead and mercury. They are part of some Ayurvedic drug formulations.
> Similar to strict religious teaches of what food to eat, Catholic, Jewish, Sattvic diet even.
Ayurveda is not a religious belief system as no Hindu deity has issued a commandment about not eating certain objects. For e.g. an observation that a diet heavy in pulses/legumes will cause bloat, gas and general intestinal discomfort is not a religious belief.
This is a question for those who are experts in the field of Rasa Shastra.[1][2] Just like questions regarding which poisons/toxins are injected into the human body as treatment, why, and for which illness are questions for experts in the appropriate specializations of modern medicine.
[1] A Text Book Of Rasa Shastra(Iatro-Chemistry And Ayurvedic Pharmaceutics) (https://chaukhamba.co.in/index.php?route=product/product&pro...)
[2] Introduction to ‘Rasashaastra’ the Iatrochemistry of Ayurveda (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3252715/)
Ayurveda is based on the evidence of its times. People who follow Ayurveda don't put random things into their mouth.
> In India you can still commonly buy traditional medicines which have heavy metals like lead and mercury as ingredients.
Modern medicine routinely uses deliberate exposure to radiation as well as injection of poisons and toxic chemicals into the body as treatment for various diseases.
Because it is.
The British Empire might have disappeared but a segment of the English elite continue to believe that the former colonies must be run based on ideas that emerge from their superior intellect.
This is why they stress "foreign expertise," "effective NGOs" etc. Most governments in Africa, Asia and South America must have first hand experience with why (and how) NGOs are funded in their countries by the West and why these NGOs always turn up at every major and minor protest against government policies. And when their funding sources are investigated by these governments, the bogey of "authoritarianism" and "freedom of expression" is invoked.
Forcing banks and digital wallet providers to provide users a prepaid card/digital balance in exchange for cash is a good alternative. This should be a part of the charter/license under which such organisations operate.
Well, the entire Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh was driven out of the region by Azerbaijan as the world watched in utter silence.
These things happen.
Morality and ethics are purely theoretical constructs that are meant to be used against your opponent in order to get them to back down. At least that is how they are normally employed in the real world.
Scammers, as a category, target everyone. You think Indians don't get conned into sharing their OTP/passwords or financial details?
> They are too short-sighted to not see that the "industry" is damaging India's global reputation
India has one of the lowest police officers to population ratios in the world. They are so swamped with day-to-day crimes and other nonsense and providing protection to events and politicians that India's "global reputation" is simply not on their radar.
You cannot buy a SIM for your phone or open a bank account without providing ten types of identity documents but these scammers seem to have an infinite supply of phone numbers and bank accounts. That is just the way things are.
Irreverence has been part of the El Reg reading experience since I can remember. Someone always complains about them writing about "boffins."
True.
However, forcing the invader's culture and practises on the conquered people and taking steps to replace the local language, culture, politico-legal systems and social structures is. Did or did China not do this to the people it conquered?
A Chinese emperor once famously said to the British: “Our celestial empire possesses all things in abundance and lacks no product within its borders. There is therefore no need to import the manufactures of barbarians in exchange for our own products.”[1]
Old civilizations are deeply connected to their geography, and once they settle down in a fertile area, they generally don't feel the need to colonize or fight people beyond their immediate neighbourhood. Barring a couple of exceptions, the Chinese and Indian experiences are very similar.
The only reason Europeans went out on their ships was to find a sea route to India after their traditional routes were blocked by the Turks and the Arabs.
[1] The Second Opium War (https://origins.osu.edu/read/second-opium-war)
Uncontrolled immigration without assimilation can have disastrous consequences. And assimilation is a polite way of saying "give up your culture and adopt ours."
Unfortunately, without assimilation, all the politics and problems of the homeland will follow the diaspora to the new host country. It has been seen time and time again:
- Italian and Irish emigration to the US
- Migration from the Indian subcontinent as well as Muslim countries of Africa and the Middle East into Europe and North America
If you cannot solve this but still want immigrants, the numbers have to be reduced massively and some kind of pause between waves will be required so that gradual assimilation can be achieved.
It will only work if there is laser-like focus on the primary organizational objective: letting artists make a living.
Falling of a cliff when blindly chasing growth is just one problem. In the current era, the probability that they will get involved in policing the politics of their members and issue statements on everything from the state of rain forests to Palestine is close to 1.0. The organization will thus be torn apart by internal rivalries.
"We, the undersigned student organizations, hold the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all the unfolding violence.
"Today's events did not occur in a vacuum. For the last two decades, millions of Palestinians in Gaza have been forced to live in an open-air prison. Israeli officials promise to "open the gates of hell," and the massacres in Gaza have already commenced. Palestinians in Gaza have no shelters for refuge and nowhere to escape. In the coming days, Palestinians will be forced to bear the full brunt of Israel's violence.
"The apartheid regime is the only one to blame. Israeli violence has structured every aspect of Palestinian existence for 75 years. From systematized land seizures to routine airstrikes, arbitrary detentios to military checkpoints, and enforced family separations to targeted killings, Palestinians have been forced to live in a state of death, both slow and sudden.
"Today, the Palestinian ordeal enters into uncharted territory. The coming days will require a firm stand against colonial retaliation. We call on the Harvard community to take action to stop the ongoing annihilation of Palestinians.[1][2]
> Some of the protests I've seen are things I'd rather not hear from anyone involved in the legal system.
These people are primarily religious/political activists. When some of them enter the legal system, that facet of their personality is going to overpower the rest.
[1] https://www.thecrimson.com/widget/2023/10/10/psc-statement/
[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20231017222129/https://www.pales...