News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by jakelazaroff on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:34AM (#38098726)
Is there a meaningful difference between recording "this IP address made a request on this date" and "this IP address made a request on this date after hovering their cursor over the page body"? How is your suggestion more acceptable than what the blog describes?
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by gizmo on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:49AM (#38098930)
Going out of your way to specifically track people who indicate they don't want to be tracked is worse.
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by vivekd on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:12PM (#38100374)
Google cloud and AWS VPS and many hosting services collect and provide this info by default. Chances are most websites do this including this one you are using now. HN does up bans meaning they must access visitor IP.

Why aren't people starting their protest against the website they're currently using instead of at OP.

Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by gizmo on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:43PM (#38100928)
We all know that tracking is ubiquitous on the web. This blogpost however discusses technology that specifically helps with tracking people who don't want to be tracked. I responded that an alternative approach is to just not. That's not hypocritical.
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by joshmanders on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:00PM (#38104111)
Again, you don't answer the question of what's the difference between a image pixel or javascript logging that you visited the site vs nginx/apache logging you visited the site?

You're upset that OP used an image or javascript instead of grepping `access.log` makes absolute no sense. The same data is shown there.

Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by gizmo on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:38PM (#38106359)
[delayed]
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by jakelazaroff on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:44PM (#38100964)
My point is that your `wc -l access.log` solution will also track people who send the Do Not Track header unless you specifically prevent it from doing so. In fact, you could implement the exact same system described in the blog post by replacing the Python code run on every request with an aggregation of the access log. So what is the pragmatic difference between the two?
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by an_ko on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:12PM (#38101396)
From a technical point of view: The difference is that a CSS `body:hover` request excludes naïve bots, but an access log includes them. So it's more useful for the maintainer.

From a privacy point of view: The difference is that human usage won't blend in with bot traffic quite as easily, so they give up an amount of anonymity that most would probably consider inconsequential.

From an ethical point of view: In a deontological model of ethics, making someone's computer act against their interests is wrong, even if that harm is marginal. In a utilitarian model of ethics, making someone's computer act in that way is good, if the resulting data causes more good than the intrusion causes harm.

Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by gizmo on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:47PM (#38106455)
Even the GDPR makes this distinction. Access logs (with IP addresses) are fine if you use them for technical purposes (monitor for 404, 500 errors) but if you use access logs for marketing purposes you need users to opt-in, because IP addresses are considered PII by law. And if you don't log IPs then you can't track uniques. Tracking and logging are not the same thing.
Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS by jakelazaroff on Thursday November 02, 2023 @09:06AM (#38112967)
May I remind you that your own suggested solution was using access logs for marketing purposes!