News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by ben_w on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @11:28AM (#38086330)
> Libraries exist? Do you think books fly onto library shelves for free? As far as I know, someone bought them. Your neighbour or friend also bought the stuff. I suspect you're not being straight here, I just have to ignore this whole line of reasoning since it seems so absurd.

First, there's this thing called a deposit library: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_deposit

Second: I, as a user of the service, who learns things, still pay nothing.

Should I be required to directly pay for the things I learned from, or is it sufficient that someone is? Because if the latter, then picking up a book from a normal (non-deposit) library, showing it to an OCR system, and having an AI learn from that, would involve just as much payment as I ever made to read a library book (with the possible exception of late return fines, I can't remember if I ever had any of those).

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by kranke155 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:15PM (#38087148)
Everybody finds an edge case they can justify their entire worldview on. It's fascinating.
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by ben_w on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:31PM (#38087430)
Is it fascinating? Seems pretty obvious to me, you've got things that are good and things that are bad and you want to find the dividing line between them, why pick something central to either group that doesn't illuminate the boundary between them?
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by biot on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:59PM (#38092540)
Recapping the conversation:

You: Yes, and you know how humans acquire works to learn from? They pay for it.

Them: False. Libraries exist. Borrowing books from neighborhood libraries or friends exists.

You: Libraries exist? Do you think books fly onto library shelves for free? As far as I know, someone bought them.

Them: then [pick] up a book from a normal ... library, [show] it to an OCR system, and [have] an AI learn from that

You: Everybody finds an edge case they can justify their entire worldview on.

However, it's not an edge case; it's a direct consequence of your argument. If humans learning from libraries rewards copyright holders because libraries paid for the books, then an AI training from libraries rewards copyright holders in exactly the same way since the libraries paid for the books.