Physical library books are governed by the doctrine of first sale. That's why google has one of the largest (maybe excluding l-bg-n and IA) corpus of books on the internet. They might have the cleanest corpus of OCR'd book content of anyone, since IA uses commercial or open source OCR and that's it, while google for a long time used recaptcha to check OCR results.
For physical books, the cost per read of a library book is an order of magnitude smaller than the cost per read of privately purchased books. How can you tolerate the economic model of libraries when the net effect is a theft of maybe 80%-95% from the author and publisher? Libraries subsidize books that nobody wanted to read, but steal from authors and publishers whose books are read multiple times per physical copy.
Even libraries' onerous ebook licenses are not commercial retail ebook pricing. They're just close to it than publishers could ever manage with physical books, because there's no pesky right of first sale which allows libraries to lend physical books on their own terms to library patrons without getting permission or licensing from the publisher.
I would prefer to get away from OpenAI and Facebook and all the other people using potentially tainted sources like books3. The legal question there is not whether training was legal, but whether the acquisition of the training data was legal to begin with, and that's a straightforward copyright issue.
What is your position on Google using its corpus of books (legally acquired and possessed, as the content behind google books) to train a LLM? Do they need to acquire additional rights from copyright holders? Why, and under what legal theory?
First, there's this thing called a deposit library: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_deposit
Second: I, as a user of the service, who learns things, still pay nothing.
Should I be required to directly pay for the things I learned from, or is it sufficient that someone is? Because if the latter, then picking up a book from a normal (non-deposit) library, showing it to an OCR system, and having an AI learn from that, would involve just as much payment as I ever made to read a library book (with the possible exception of late return fines, I can't remember if I ever had any of those).
You: Yes, and you know how humans acquire works to learn from? They pay for it.
Them: False. Libraries exist. Borrowing books from neighborhood libraries or friends exists.
You: Libraries exist? Do you think books fly onto library shelves for free? As far as I know, someone bought them.
Them: then [pick] up a book from a normal ... library, [show] it to an OCR system, and [have] an AI learn from that
You: Everybody finds an edge case they can justify their entire worldview on.
However, it's not an edge case; it's a direct consequence of your argument. If humans learning from libraries rewards copyright holders because libraries paid for the books, then an AI training from libraries rewards copyright holders in exactly the same way since the libraries paid for the books.
>Until AGI arrives, or some other method of training LLMs from the ground up on sparse examples by incrementally building on structural knowledge of language.... training on ridiculous amounts of copyrighted content is required.
that's not my problem. Those AI model folk should just compensate the people they're using training data from, and they should ask for permission.
>You could train a LLM only on project gutenberg, and the LLM would churn out stilted English and the occasional iambic pentameter. That's great if you want works that seem like they were written over a century ago, but nearly useless otherwise.
Not my problem. Why are the problems of the wonderful AI developers suddenly human, global problems that we all have to find a way to fix?
If they want access to training data - they should pay for the privielige.