That being said, I live in a pretty population dense area and my largest cost by far is dedicated home office space. It would be nice for my company to pay for that but it would have also been nice for them to pay for gas for my commute when I had one.
I think CA is likely overplaying their hand. They are not the place of choice for many remote employees (because of taxes) and are trying hard to not be the place of choice for remote companies.
Good riddance. We need the space more than we need the tax revenue. (no offense intended, the housing situation is just dire and I’ll use any excuse to convince people to move out cause so few actually people want to)
Housing should not be an investment, period.
I'm simply saying those who were stuck buying at inflated prices might be opposed to that.
My home is paid off and I got it for half of it's market value. I have no skin in the game either way as I'd never sell.
They never said that.
> I'm simply saying those who were stuck buying at inflated prices might be opposed to that.
No, you were calling someone "myopic or selfish" because they suggested ways more people might be able to afford housing.
> My home is paid off and I got it for half of it's market value. I have no skin in the game either way as I'd never sell.
You're being myopic or selfish, neither is fair to your neighbors (who can't afford housing due to market dynamics and bad policies).
What exactly are you even proposing? You want the government to mandate cheaper land, construction material, and builder wages? To lower taxes on all of the above? People who think there is some simple solution "duh just build more houses!" are extremely myopic. Again it's not my problem, I'm not against building more houses and I also get NIMBY because "affordable" or government subsidized housing has a direct correlation to crime rates, lowering property values, and lowering the quality of schools.
California stands alone as one of the top 5 or 6 biggest economies in the world. The 2008 GFC was a blip in our housing market even when the economy turned upside down. My city experienced less than 18 months of flat real estate prices before growing out of control again.
Forcing companies to pay their fair share isn't going to destroy the housing market. That's just laughable.
So if I invent an awesome new car, it's selfish because it's destroying the value of your beater? If I invent a new GPU that costs 1/10 the price of existing ones, it's selfish because your computer is now worthless on the secondary market?
Homes are to LIVE in, I consider them consumables just like cars, just on the order of ~a lifetime instead of ~10 years. I don't give a flying f about neighbors' house or car values, I just care that I have a comfortable roof to live under and that I can afford it.
I know boomers treat houses as investment assets. I don't. They're shitty return and high-maintainence as an investment. But I'd like to have my own so I can modify the hell out of it to my liking.
If you want an affordable home move somewhere affordable. You can't legislate affordable housing for yourself without introducing problems for everyone else. Someone just living in a home they bought is not actively preventing you from affording one, at least, they're the last people you should blame (even after yourself).
That's the exact issue. They aren't.
But none of this has to do with small startups
While they're all good ideas, I don't think they'll totally solve the issues of affordability here.
But again, I don't know what any of this has to do with small startups suffering from the main topic. Paying some 4k more per employee isn't a singular gatekeeper, it's a deal breaker for those who already are on thr fence.
The reality is that California is so economically powerful that any corporation that leaves is almost certainly going to have to register as a foreign business and pay the franchise tax on all revenue earned in California anyway (the minimum cutoff is $500k or 25% of total revenue, whichever is lowest). The employees who stay in California are still going to pay income tax which makes up the bulk of state revenues. Everyone is still going to be paying sales tax on goods purchased from California vendors, the largest source after income tax.
Corporate taxes contribute less than 15% of California's budget so it's a reverse catch 22: either they're so small that the threats to leave are empty (DO IT!), or they're so big that they can't afford not to pay California taxes regardless of where they are. Like I said, either way the FTB will get the bulk of its cut.
This is probably the best equivalent comparison I've seen in the thread. Paying commute costs vs paying home office costs.
I still did 3/5 days remote.
How so? Are you arguing that the IRS 65.5 cents per mile doesn't appropriately compensate for costs?
So this is nothing. Employers will not flinch at this.
Does CA require the reimbursement of commuting costs? If not, is it not fair to view this new requirement as a backdoor way to increase return-to-office pressure?
It doesn't matter if both parties are informed, the balance of power is what matters. It doesn't matter how well informed you are if your other option is starvation.
Everyone, and I mean everyone I've ever met that makes this argument is coming from a position of power themselves. They some rare ability in a labor constrained market and want to generalized their situation to everyone without realizing the massive abuses that already occurred that mandated these rules in the first place.
The solution is a social safety net, not minimum wage and not both.
Say you work 100% remote, 8 hours a day. That's 2080 work hours a year, out of 8760 hours.
That means you need to be connected to internet, have electricity, etc. 23.74% of the time - let's round that up to 24%
Say a worker pays $600 / year for internet, $2400 for electricity / year, and - dunno - $1500 for your cellphone / year.
So that's $4500 / year, and your employer must cover approximately $1080 of that. If the company has 1000 employees, that's a million in extra costs.
Doesn't really sound like it is going to break the bank, especially not if your employer is also able to cut previous office-related costs.
Also, employers would probably start to offer a bit lower salaries to the workers that don't live in very high cost of living areas...if you pay 1000 employers on average $100k / year, that's a minimum $100m in annual salary expenses. If employees are willing to take a $99k salary for guaranteed 100% remote work, with the above expenses covered, then those costs are offset for the employer...