News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by xnx on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:23PM (#38076792)
Amazing willingness on Apple's part to switch architectures significantly 4 times and leave behind so much code. I know Apple has done some clever stuff with translation and emulation, but this is so different than the Microsoft Windows approach to backward compatibility where you can upgrade from Windows 1.0 all the way to Windows 11: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nW4rk3gFOxM
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by HappyDaoDude on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:36PM (#38076905)
You could not critic either direction too heavily. Do you want a fresh technology base or legacy support? There is no wrong answer.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by MBCook on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:27PM (#38077412)
Also they’re in very different positions.

Apple made perfectly good choices but history did not come out in their favor. So they had to keep switching and 3rd parties had to follow (if they wanted to stay on the Mac).

Microsoft ended up on what became the dominant CPU that just happened to continue to rocket up in performance for decades. So although Windows is capable of running on other processors, it was never much of a market and most of the software never came along.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Clamchop on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:56PM (#38079677)
I wouldn't say it just happened to be. There's been an orgy of synergies mostly but far from exclusively with Windows that put or has kept x86 at a crossroads of cost, performance, platform openness, and compatibility across vendors and iterations.

I have a hard time imagining what it would look like if MS put all of their weight into an arch transition, but I have a hunch it would come with the most ridiculous compatibility layer we've seen so far.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by MBCook on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:29AM (#38080313)
You’re right. Intel had the money to push the performance on their chips because of all the sales to DOS/Windows users. Still neither company knew which platform was going to be dominant when they started.

We don’t know if Motorola could have done what Intel did given similar resources. Maybe they could have.

I fear MS will continue to struggle with ARM. The problem with Microsoft is they just don’t control enough big applications. There are just way too many little programs out there that people depend on.

Each time Apple moved the performance difference was enough to cover the cost. Plus it was clear you HAD to switch if you wanted to stick with the Mac.

PC users aren’t going to lose Intel, it will still be a choice. No one can beat Intel’s best on desktop. Unless they can convince Nvidia and AMD to come along with native drivers games will suck. Anything else that doesn’t move will depend on a very high speed emulation layer.

Unless battery life can win the day, it’s gonna be a tough fight. And you know Intel is not going to go down easy.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by Clamchop on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:05AM (#38081167)
> Stil neither company knew which platform was going to be dominant when they started.

I figure they usually weren't thinking about it that way yet. A lot of what came later was unprecedented.

> There are just vway too many little programs out there that people depend on.

Hence the outrageous compatibility layer. I wouldn't put it past Microsoft to make a try at driver compatibility.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:32PM (#38076873)
The big difference is that Apple has, throughout most of its, been vertically integrated in a way where they control the whole stack. MS on the other hand has to deal with a bazillion IHVs that are lazy as all heck about updating their drivers.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by lotsofpulp on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:17PM (#38077317)
I feel like Microsoft chooses to deal with a bazillion IHVs. Surely they have and had the resources to go vertical, but they do not seem to want to get their hands as dirty as Apple’s in hardware business.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by The_Colonel on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:39PM (#38077535)
They choose to do this, because they understand this relative openness and dedication to backwards compatibility is their major selling point for many well paying (institutional) customers.

Yes, they could choose to go the Apple way, but ... they would likely lose the customers mentioned above, and would likely still not be as good as Apple in Apple's game.

Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by katbyte on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:35PM (#38077495)
surprisingly thou they have made some rather good hardware over the years
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by The_Colonel on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:35PM (#38077497)
The drivers are the smaller problem IMHO. Companies use 20 years old software which is a) difficult to port to a different arch b) is no longer developed c) the source code is lost.
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by solardev on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:45PM (#38077618)
I guess this is part of why Windows has so much enterprise popularity, and why Apple keeps shedding macOS developers (especially for games).
Re:Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages by cmg on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:41PM (#38079005)
With the right hardware combinations, the only break you'd theoretically have in the System/MacOS/macOS history from 1984's System 1 to 2023's macOS Sonoma 14.1 is from MacOS 9 to MacOS X 10.0. OS X was actually a completely new operating system and oftentimes you had both OSes side-by-side on the same disk to either dual boot or to run OS 9 stuff in Classic mode under OS X.

(With full disk encryption, T2 chips and other various low-level hardware changes this might not actually be feasible under Apple Silicon chips, but at least through the Intel days you could have upgraded a system with hardware changes in the same way.)