People are skeptical that introducing the regulatory threshold has anything to do with the increasing public safety or accountability, and instead lifts the ladder up to stop others (or open-source models) catching up. This is a pointless, self-destructive endeavour in either case, as no other country is going to comply with these regulations and if anything will view them as an opportunity to help companies local to their jurisdiction (or their national government) to catch up.
The other problem is that asking why software should be different if it can affect someone's life or livelihood is quite a broad ask. Do you mean self-driving cars? Medical scanners? Diagnostic tests? I would imagine most people agree with you that this should be regulated. If you mean "it threatens my job and therefore must be stopped" then: welcome to software, automating away other people's jobs is our bread and butter.
The religious conflicts? 80 years war?
The invention of copyright (which does still restrict the right to print, it's just enforced with after-the-event prosecution if you print the wrong stuff)?
The invention of the modern nation state?
Government cannot regulate it.
Entities operating SaaS are in a much greyer area.
The regulation in the article is about AIs giving assistance on producing weapons of mass destruction and mentions nuclear and biological. Yann LeCun posted this yesterday about the risk of runaway AIs that would decide to kill or enslave humans, but both arguments result in an oligopoly over AI:
> Altman, Hassabis, and Amodei are the ones doing massive corporate lobbying at the moment.
> They are the ones who are attempting to perform a regulatory capture of the AI industry.
> You, Geoff, and Yoshua are giving ammunition to those who are lobbying for a ban on open AI R&D.
> ...
> The alternative, which will *inevitably* happen if open source AI is regulated out of existence, is that a small number of companies from the West Coast of the US and China will control AI platform and hence control people's entire digital diet.
> What does that mean for democracy?
> What does that mean for cultural diversity?
Yoshua is Yoshua Bengio: «Yoshua Bengio: How Rogue AIs May Arise» https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36042126
LeCunn is replying to Max Tegmark: «Ask HN: What is the apocolyptic scenario for AI “breaking loose”?» https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35569306 «Max Tegmark: The Case for Halting AI Development | Lex Fridman Podcast #371» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcVfceTsD0A
- the government must regulate the internet to stop the spread of child pornography
- the government must regulate social media to stop calls for terrorism and genocide
- the government must regulate AI to stop it from developing bio weapons
...etc. It's always easiest to push regulation via these angles, but then that regulation covers 100% of the regulated subject, rather than the 0.01% of the "intended" subject
That's congress' job.
It's doing some guideline stuff and specifying how it's used internally in the government and by government funded entities.
We're still free to develop AI any way we chose.
For now.
Too many small players have made the jump to the big leagues already for those who don’t want competition.
If some people are going to have the tech it will create a different kind of balance.
Tough issue to navigate.
Precisely. And the same governments will make stealing your data and ip legal. I believe that’s how corruption works - pump money into politicians and they make laws that favour oligarchs.
"There are definitely large tech companies that would rather not have to try to compete with open source, so they're creating fear of AI leading to human extinction," he told the news outlet. "It's been a weapon for lobbyists to argue for legislation that would be very damaging to the open-source community."
https://www.businessinsider.com/andrew-ng-google-brain-big-t...
E.g. "What tests did you run? What results did you get? Where did you publish those results so they can be referenced?"
Unfortunately, this seems to be more targeted at banned topics.
No "How I make nukulear weapon?" is less interesting than "Oh, our tests didn't check whether output rental prices were different between protected classes."
Mandating open and verified test results would be an interesting, automatable, and useful regulation around ML models.
If there's only a few organisations that can create competitive AI no-one can compete with them if they turn out less than ideal.
Hate to be the nitpicker but "defensible moat" implies the moat itself is what needs protecting :)
That assumes the threat isn't complete annihilation of humanity, which is what's being claimed. That assumption is the weak link, and is what should be attacked.
Again, if we assume that AI poses an existential risk (and to be clear, I don't think it does), then it follows that we should regulate it analogously to the way in which we regulate weapons-grade plutonium.
Instead, existing AI companies are using the government to increase the threshold for newcomers to enter the field. A regulation for all AI companies to have a testing regime that requires a 20 headstrong team is easy to meet for incumbents, but impossible for newcomers.
Now, this is not to diminish that there are genuine risks in AI - but I'd argue that these will be exploited, if not by US companies, then by others. And the best weapon against AI might in fact be AI. So, pulling the ladder up behind the existing companies might turn out to be a major mistake.