News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by teleforce on Friday October 27, 2023 @10:38PM (#38046571)
Guess which building first demolished to the ground by Israel military in Gaza at the beginning of the conflict? No price of getting the right answer, it's the Watan Tower building that hosted most of Gaza Internet Sevice Provider (ISP) companies Paltel and Jawwal and their infrastructure. It was also a hub for several international media outlets, including the Associated Press and Al Jazeera [1],[2],[3]. We are somewhow supposed to believe by Israel propaganda that the demolition of the Watan building is necessary to cripple the resistance but in war truth is always the first casualty that further leads to countless human casualties.

[1] Israels warns Palestinians on Facebook but Israel bombing decimated Gaza Internet Access:

https://theintercept.com/2023/10/12/israel-gaza-internet-acc...

[2] #KeepItOn: Telecommunications Blackout In The Gaza Strip Is An Attack On Human Rights:

https://m.scoop.co.nz/stories/WO2310/S00117/keepiton-telecom...

[3] Destruction of Watan Tower: A Blow to Press Freedom or a Military Necessity?

https://bnn.network/world/palestine/destruction-of-watan-tow...

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Friday October 27, 2023 @10:45PM (#38046607)
It also included offices for the Hamas and was a symbol of its power. That was the main motivation for removing it.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by teleforce on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:17PM (#38046789)
It seems that some people easily believe in Israel propaganda without digging the actual reasons, and how can the people know the actual reasons when the facts are all buried together with the rubbles of communication infrastructure and the main offices of reporting news agencies. It is part of international laws and basic human rights that during the war you cannot demolish communication infrastructure, churches, mosques, hospitals, news agency offices, schools, civilian homes, etc. As demonsrated in this war, the first casualty is the truth that paved the way to countless atrocities.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:28PM (#38046844)
All of those things were bombed by other western democracies in past wars.

Maybe Israel lied about this, I don't know. But I do know the Hamas lied about many things. Just now a Hamas representative was interviewed by the BBC claiming they didn't kidnap or target civilians... Wow. The audacity of the lie is staggering.

The symbolic nature of the building doesn't appear to be a lie. Since there were many offices in the building it would make sense the Hamas has some offices there. I don't see that as a huge lie.

> during the war you cannot demolish communication infrastructure, churches, mosques, hospitals, news agency offices, schools, civilian homes, etc. As demonsrated in this war, the first casualty is the truth that paved the way to countless atrocities.

It's very evident that you didn't say synagogues... I'm guessing I know where you're coming from to this debate...

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bawolff on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:29PM (#38046852)
> It is part of international laws and basic human rights that during the war you cannot demolish communication infrastructure, churches, mosques, hospitals, news agency offices, schools, civilian homes, etc.

Umm you can if they are being used for military purposes.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by archagon on Saturday October 28, 2023 @03:08PM (#38052515)
If an entire city is held hostage by a terrorist ruling party, does that mean that you have carte blanche to raze the city and displace or eliminate its civilian population?
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by pxc on Saturday October 28, 2023 @08:59PM (#38054915)
A terrorist ruling party that your intelligence agencies funded and armed, early on, and which your ruling party has 'propped up'¹ for decades as both a way to have a convenient enemy and to divide the Palestinian people so as to make impossible the 'two-state solution' that your government is nominally committed to, at that.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @11:03PM (#38055528)
Israel is far from blameless in the rise of Hamas. Especially Benjamin Netanyahu who as an Israeli I would love to see go to trial for supporting Hamas (in addition to his other ongoing corruption charges).

Still, there are levels of blame and the current situation. The Palestinians in Gaza are held hostage by an evil organization that keeps escalating and using ceasefires to increase armaments. I would love it if Netanyahu would be out of office right now and someone "competent" were running things. But this is the position we're at.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bawolff on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:38PM (#38055429)
> If an entire city is held hostage by a terrorist ruling party

Many governments are dictatorships or autocratic. Some are democratic. I dont think it matters. You have the same responsibility to civilians regardless of the form of government.

> carte blanche to raze the city

Generally not. But you can certainly destroy buildings used for military purposes. Where this conflict falls on this scale is pretty unclear thus far.

> eliminate its civilian population

Definitely not. Israel has not done this.

> displace ... its civilian population?

Maybe. There are certain circumstances under the geneva convention where this is allowed, and it seems likely the criteria was met in this conflict. You of course have to let them back once the fighting has subsided.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lots2learn on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:38PM (#38060833)
If you agree that you have to let them back as per Geneva, then the solution is obvious: let the 7million refugees back to the lands they were ethnically cleansed from in 1948 and onwards.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bawolff on Monday October 30, 2023 @12:11AM (#38065585)
I generally agree that for refugees this actually happened to (not their descendents), allowing them back (or compensating them for lost property) is a reasonable request (assuming they are willing to live in peace with their new neighbours). However i think it should apply to all refugees from that conflict including jews who were displaced of which there were a significant number of from what i understand. I can't support anything that is a rule for one side if it isn't applied to the other equally.

For cases where the original person is now dead (1948 was 75 years ago), i think its reasonable that that person's descendents should split appropriate compensation.

What im getting at here is - if someone was driven out and owned a 1 bedroom apartment, they are only owed a 1 bedroom apartment. If they had 50 grandchildren they are still owed only the single apartment not 50 apartments, one for each heir.

The other big issue is this was 75 years ago. Much of this property probably doesn't exist anymore. I think due to pure practicality, cash compensation would have to be the way to address this issue.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lots2learn on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:26AM (#38099534)
Which Jews within Israel were displaced in the conflict? Rather, it was a net gain for the Jews in Israel. People, including Golda Meir the first prime minister, simply moved into existing homes of people who had to flee because of the murderous Zionist mobs and pogroms. Compensating refugees and descendants doesn't solve the problem that they don't have legal status in the land they were born in / driven from. They must be let back to their native land. Israel uses this same logic - although spanning 2k years and reliant on mythology as proof - to let any Jew from anywhere in the world immigrate and gain citizenship in Israel. So if you're committed to being equitable to both sides, why aren't Palestinians given the same right of return to their homeland?
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by victorbjorklund on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:07AM (#38048329)
It is 100% legal to bomb targets that have dual use (both civilian and military). That is why it is 100% legal for Ukraine to bomb the kerch bridge. It is a bridge used by both civilians and military.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by hypefi on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:46AM (#38048753)
Are you kidding me? are you comparing a bridge with a hospital full of people, doctors and patients
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:58PM (#38055509)
Israel didn't bomb a hospital, that was a misfire of their missile. Israel showed that a different hospital is actually used as a base of operations for the Hamas because they know Israel won't bomb it.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bluish29 on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:13PM (#38046771)
Any solid evidence?
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:29PM (#38046851)
Only what Israeli press published at the time. I doubt they would pick that as their first major target if it didn't have some connection to the Hamas.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bluish29 on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:34PM (#38046882)
So you don't have a solid evidence that you can share and instead relying on "They wouldn't pick that as first major target if it wasn't " as some sort of evidence that you felt is enough to repeat the claim without even mentioning that there is no evidence available?

I don't think you are being honest here.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:40PM (#38046908)
I can probably find the Israeli paper article from the first day of the war but you said you won't believe it anyway. So what's the point?

What evidence do you have that the Israeli intelligence was wrong in this case?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bluish29 on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:46PM (#38046950)
When people are asking for evidence. They are asking about hard evidence that prove the claim. The claim here that it was bombed because it contains hamas offices used for military purposes and this is why isreal bombed. Well isreal by your say have some evidence that it was the case. Did they provide this evidence?

The evidence here is not a press release of isreali government/military saying that they destroyed it because it was being used by hamas for military purposes. They can say whatever they want and you can do, but without providing evidence this becomes a lie.

Note that I am here talking about very specific case and claim. If you want to say hamas lie too that's fine but completely irrelevant in our context here.

We are talking about this specific claim and this specific claims because I don't want this to go in general direction.

And the burden of proof is on you not you. You claimed something and you should provide the evidence. Don't try to tweak things by redirecting the question

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:52PM (#38046975)
Again. I don't have that but you don't have the counter evidence that it didn't exist. Show me evidence of any bombing from any western country in any campaign ever...

I get that Israel should be held to a higher standard than the Hamas. But your specific attitude makes no sense. Intelligence information is internal, wartime bombings target decisions are privileged information.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bluish29 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @12:05AM (#38047036)
> I don't have that but you don't have the counter evidence that it didn't exist

This is not the problem, people who claim something have to provide the evidence if asked, you don't respond to them by re-directing the question and ask them for counter-proof. At least in the normal world. I don't know about you.

> I get that Israel should be held to a higher standard than the Hamas

Providing evidence to claims is now a higher standard? man you live in a wild world.

> But your specific attitude makes no sense. Intelligence information is internal, wartime bombings target decisions are privileged information

So they can attack and kill anyone and claim they were military targets, and when asked for evidence then they will not provide because it is internal? Do you know what claims without evidence can be considered, yes propaganda like the one you tried to spread in this comment which is our discussion context.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @12:11AM (#38047063)
> This is not the problem, people who claim something have to provide the evidence if asked

No we don't. However, I did provide evidence which you choose to ignore. You also claim that the army would bomb a place for no real reason which just doesn't make sense. Especially for the first target in a campaign. It's you who should provide evidence, not me.

> > But your specific attitude makes no sense. Intelligence information is internal, wartime bombings target decisions are privileged information > > So they can attack and kill anyone and claim they were military targets, and when asked for evidence then they will not provide because it is internal?

Nonsense. This is an attack on a building. Bombing is a coarse instrument and the IDF holds regular briefings where they provide evidence.

All the papers spent a day claiming Israel bombed a hospital killing 500 people. Total lie and the Hamas knew it when they came out with it. The IDF gathers and provides evidence for relevant situations (e.g. the Hospital bombing). It is accountable unlike the Hamas which is not.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by bluish29 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @12:48AM (#38047229)
> No we don't

Thank you, that was the answer that you should just say from the beginning.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:13AM (#38069689)
> Providing evidence to claims is now a higher standard? man you live in a wild world.

Yep, that's the world we live in. Politicians, corporations, journalists frequently don't. Even "scientists" from time to time fake data & results. Military at least have a valid reason for not publicizing intel, specially in times of war.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Sunday October 29, 2023 @11:36PM (#38065401)
[delayed]
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by kingofpandora on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:57PM (#38046998)
Remember that an advisor to Natanyahu tweeted that the Al-Arabi Hospital was bombed by Israel because it was being used by Hamas.

No, I'm not saying that the hospital was actually bombed by Israel; I'm saying that everything that Israel bombs is labelled with the "used by Hamas" tag as justification for what this really is.

No one actually believes that all or even most of the buildings destroyed in this campaign was "used by Hamas" if you are being honest with yourself. It's obviously collective punishment and revenge with a little bit of show ("we dropped leaflets" or "we sent warnings by SMS") for those who need it in order to go to bed at night.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @12:02AM (#38047027)
I wouldn't count on anything coming from the circle of Netanyahu. He is the absolute worse. But Israeli mainstream press is generally better sourced.

Notice that Israel also used phone tracking to check that civilian population moved away from the target. No county that ran a campaign of this type in the past used such an approach to avoid civilian casualties.

I think the bombings are very problematic. But from current reports it seems the ground invasion will be worse in terms of casualties (on all fronts). So it seems like a lesser evil when a building goes down.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by kingofpandora on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:19AM (#38048135)
> I wouldn't count on anything coming from the circle of Netanyahu.

It's not about whether I trust them or not (I don't!). It's that everyone is following the same playbook. Israel can do whatever it wants and blame Palestinians with impunity.

Every teenager shot on the street is a militant. Every house that is flattened was used by terrorists. Every journalist that was dies while working was actually killed by the Palestinians themselves.

The power imbalance is not just military in nature. Israel has command of the message as well and the is frighteningly effective because it's just plausible enough.

>Notice that Israel also used phone tracking to check that civilian population moved away from the target. No county that ran a campaign of this type in the past used such an approach to avoid civilian casualties.

What about all the people who can't charge their phones because Israel only allowed 4 hours of electricity per day before the most recent campaign? Or whose phones were lost when their homes were destroyed?

This is a great example. The IDF can make claims about how they "avoid civilian casualties" but why do you believe that it's anything more than for show?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:44AM (#38048230)
> > I wouldn't count on anything coming from the circle of Netanyahu.

> It's not about whether I trust them or not. It's that everyone is following the same playbook. Every teenager shot on the street is a militant; every house that is flattened was used by terrorists; everyone who has any criticism whatsoever is an antisemite.

I was specifically indicating that my information came from a reputable paper. Not from an a*hole on Twitter. Social media is full of nonsense and terrible people, I don't take part in that.

There is a lot of rage there and a lot of grandstanding.

> What about all the people who can't charge their phones because Israel only allowed 4 hours of electricity per day before the most recent campaign? Or whose phones were destroyed when their homes were destroyed?

This works based on numbers. There are still enough mobile phones to get a sense of movement patterns and target areas that are mostly empty. The army demoed the system to foreign press where areas are marked on a map indicating "safe to bomb" areas. It isn't a perfect system by any stretch but it's the best that can be done in this situation.

I wish there was a way to resolve this without violence. I don't think even the heads of Hamas should be killed. I hope they can be captured and would stand trial if possible. No one should die, especially not the many civilians that are there. But there's absolutely no choice. Every time the Hamas was given leeway it used it for attacks.

Israel released 1000 prisoners, many of them terrorists with blood on their hands as part of a trade a few years back. Most of those terrorists took part in the October 7th attack. They can't help themselves, they are religious fanatics. They are clever enough to manipulate the sentiments we liberals have. Our knee-jerk reaction is to stop violence and they appeal to that. They even manufacture violence against their own people for that purpose.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by hunta2097 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:59AM (#38048519)
As an atheist, it seems like there is plenty of fanaticism on both sides.

Its impossible to "pick a side" in this conflict, there are good people and a*holes in both countries.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by dragonwriter on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:06AM (#38048558)
> Its impossible to "pick a side" in this conflict, there are good people and a*holes in both countries.

And, on both sides, its the a*holes (a mild term for people who have engineered decades of war crimes and/or crimes against humanity, including waging war against or actively using inflammatory language to incite the murder of less extreme voices on, nominally, the same side for being less disinclined toward peace) running the war machine and state or state-like apparatus while the good people are trying not to get killed.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:03AM (#38048543)
I'm an atheist too. That is a false equivalency.

Guess which country is the 4th or 5th most secular country in the world... It might surprise you: Israel. Yep.

That's thanks to the "Jews" who are jews in creed, not religion. Israel has its fanatics for sure and they gained more power in the last election. But it isn't controlled by its fanatics by any stretch of the imagination.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by mping on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:12AM (#38048891)
Don't have a horse in the race. Isn't Israeli constitution specifically about the Jewish people, as a ethnic, religious group? I read it discriminates against interfaith marriages, etc
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:23AM (#38048949)
Israel doesn't have a constitution. There's the declaration of independence which does explicitly say the Jewish People. But the interpretation of that is varied. The closest thing Israel has to a founding father (who died before the country was formed) is Hertzel and he called it "state of the Jews". Many make a strong distinction between that and "Jewish state" as American TV anchors like to say (that's like nails on a blackboard for me).

Israel doesn't have civil unions. It only has religious marriage any religion is OK but the religions do discriminate. This is both problematic and a blessing. I'm not married to my spouse because I'm an atheist, but Israel has a "known in public" status which gives us the same rights (and some obligations) as married people. That means Gay and inter-religion couples can enjoy all the rights.

Another option some people take is to fly to nearby cypress to have a civil union which is recognized in Israeli courts.

About the broader question. Yes, there are religious elements in the government that have been pushing the secular envelope. This creates a lot of friction within Israeli society. E.g. there's a law against pastries in passover which is just the dumbest thing ever... Unenforceable and just stupid. There's also regulations prohibiting Jews from working on a Sabath (supposedly as a labor protection). Notice that both laws mostly affect people who are listed as "Jews" even if they are secular.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lots2learn on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:31PM (#38060768)
The laws discriminate against non-jews. Below is a list which includes things like restricting who can emigrate or gain residency, who land can be distributed or leased to, restricting commemoration of ethnic cleansing that the state was founded on, etc.

https://www.adalah.org/en/law/index

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by hunta2097 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:47AM (#38049764)
I think we need a different word for "ethnically Jewish" and "belief in the faith of Judaism", the confusion between the people and the faith causes problems.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by tzs on Saturday October 28, 2023 @11:50AM (#38050750)
>> Notice that Israel also used phone tracking to check that civilian population moved away from the target. No county that ran a campaign of this type in the past used such an approach to avoid civilian casualties.

> What about all the people who can't charge their phones because Israel only allowed 4 hours of electricity per day before the most recent campaign? Or whose phones were lost when their homes were destroyed?

If they were trying to answer the question "how many people are in this area?" it could make a big difference, but to answer the question "what fraction of people who were here have recently left this area?" sampling just people with powered on phones just be enough to figure it out, assuming Israel has decent statisticians to analyze the data.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by edanm on Saturday October 28, 2023 @03:18AM (#38047869)
> No one actually believes that all or even most of the buildings destroyed in this campaign was "used by Hamas" if you are being honest with yourself. It's obviously collective punishment and revenge with a little bit of show ("we dropped leaflets" or "we sent warnings by SMS") for those who need it in order to go to bed at night.

Sorry, no. I don't believe that.

Granted, I'm Israeli, and have far more trust in the Israeli public and soldiers than most people in the world. But it really is true that Hamas uses human shields. It really is true that they place bases in places like hospitals.

And it also is really true that many, hopefully most Israelis, wouldn't comply with an order to bomb a building only to kill civilians with no military value.

I understand why that might be a statement that outsiders wouldn't trust. And I'm sure there have been plenty of mistakes and even many times where people did do the wrong thing, like in every conflict in the world. I just don't think that as a matter of policy, Israel is bombing buildings with no military reason.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by kingofpandora on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:21AM (#38048143)
So you look at the aerial and satellite photography and you really believe that every last building was justifiably destroyed as a legitimate military target?

If that's the case, then the government propaganda has done its job. There's nothing more to say.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by true_religion on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:35AM (#38048194)
[delayed]
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:53AM (#38056608)
> But it really is true that Hamas uses human shields. It really is true that they place bases in places like hospitals.

Then don't fucking bomb it. You're defending war crimes and terrorism.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by edanm on Sunday October 29, 2023 @07:19AM (#38057481)
> Then don't fucking bomb it. You're defending war crimes and terrorism.

1. It's not a war crime. If one side places their militants in a hospital, the hospital is no longer afforded protection. If anyone is commiting war crimes, it's Hamas, by placing their HQ in a hospital.

2. As much as I'd love to not bomb anybody, they are actively at this moment shooting rockets at me. What exactly should I do? Just wait until they inevitably manage to kill me?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:14AM (#38057832)
2. Who are "they" shooting rockets at you? The children you're killing? The civilians in a hospital getting treatment form previous bombings?

I stand by my statement. You're defending war crimes and terrorism. It's what it is, no matter how justified you believe it is to kill these innocent people.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by edanm on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:21AM (#38057880)
> Who are "they" shooting rockets at you? The children you're killing? The civilians in a hospital getting treatment form previous bombings?

The Hamas militants that are using hospitals as a base of operations.

If you honestly want to discuss this, then here's my suggestion - let's set aside the factual question for a second. If it's true that Hamas is firing rockets from within hospitals and/or using hospitals as a base of operations, would you then consider it justified to attack back?

If yes, then we just have the factual matter of whether it's true or not and we can check that.

If no, then my followup question is - so what should we do? What other option is there if someone is firing rockets at you right now, if you refuse to fire back? I'm asking in all sincerity, I'm literally running to a bomb shelter multiple times a day as rockets are fired at me, is there something you think is ok for my government to do to try and defend me?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:48AM (#38058080)
What your government could do? Perhaps stop the occupation and killings of Palestinians. I think you would find that the innocent people being killed by your bombs don't really want to fight, they just want to live their life in peace. I can't fathom how you can justify bombing thousands of children just because some operation is carried out from somewhere in the city. I mean, what is it now, 3000 children in a matter of days being killed by Israel? But sure, killing them is probably "defending you"..
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:24PM (#38065031)
Perhaps Hamas could stop using their own population as human shields, vacate from hospitals, let Palestinians leave the north of Gaza and release the hostages. But they will never do that. They will keep using Palestinians as meat shield and their deaths as propaganda, diverting humanitarian aid to fund terrorism, using women as terrorist bombers, telling children to thrown rocks (which are deadly) at IDF soldiers so they as "martyrs" and sabotaging any possibility of peace because peace is an existential threat for Hamas.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:34AM (#38069291)
Then I resort to my original comment: Then just not fucking bomb the children. Their blood is on Israeli hands just as much as Hamas, don't try to weasel out of it.

That you're comparing children throwing rocks to using advanced military equipment to bomb them back says a lot about your values. As if doing the first in any way excuses doing the second.. A child being told to throw rocks doesn't know any better, and doesn't deserve to die for it. Holy crap some of you are out of touch with humanity.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @05:14PM (#38075954)
So what do you suggest? That Israelis do nothing? It doesn't matter if it's a huge rock to the head or a laser beam as both are lethal. Unless you have a realistic suggestion of the IDF should do differently you're just being a coward, signaling virtue without having to be virtuous from the comfort of your home.

> Then just not fucking bomb the children.

Do you think the IDF is purposefully looking for children to bomb so they can look bad? Hamas use children as human shield and their deaths as propaganda.

Do you want to help Palestinian children? Condemn Hamas for using children as shield. Condemn Iran & Russia for funding Hamas. Condemn Qatar for giving asylum to Hamas leaders. Stop romanticizing "Palestinian resistance" (evil adults sending children to stupid deaths).

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:05PM (#38076596)
I've condemned Hamas multiple times in these comments. But not once have I seen you condemn IDFs killing innocent children. I've actually mostly seen you defend it. Which to me is sickening. I'm not gonna reply to you anymore, as I don't want to engage with terrorist sympathizers.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:10PM (#38078663)
> I'm not gonna reply to you anymore.

It's for the best if all you have to contribute are personal attacks and non-sensical accusations.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by srazzaque on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:50AM (#38126083)
I'll preface this with the fact that I appreciate the opportunity for discourse without degenerating to our base/tribal/Neanderthal brains. And, also, a chance to converse with someone outside my own echo chambers. Most of my circle is non-Israeli, and non-Jewish.

> I'm literally running to a bomb shelter multiple times a day as rockets are fired at me

I'm sorry to hear this. This must be a terrible way to live, constantly in mortal fear of attacks from the other side. I will be the first to admit that I cannot relate to this, I've always lived in peaceful/stable environments (touch wood).

Can I pose a completely hypothetical counter-question, based on your own question with one variable changed: If it were somehow true that Hamas was firing rockets from _within Tel Aviv_ hospitals and/or using _Tel Aviv_ hospitals as a base of operations, would you consider it justified for the IDF to bomb that hospital?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by edanm on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:27AM (#38128407)
> I'm sorry to hear this. This must be a terrible way to live, constantly in mortal fear of attacks from the other side. I will be the first to admit that I cannot relate to this, I've always lived in peaceful/stable environments (touch wood).

Thank you. I will say that there are people in much worse situations, we still feel relatively normal, except for running to bomb shelters a few times a day and except for the worry that worse is coming. But we're in the center. Many Israelis have had to evacuate their homes and probably won't be back for months.

And of course, the Palestinians in Gaza have it much worse than us, even on a good day.

> Can I pose a completely hypothetical counter-question, based on your own question with one variable changed: If it were somehow true that Hamas was firing rockets from _within Tel Aviv_ hospitals and/or using _Tel Aviv_ hospitals as a base of operations, would you consider it justified for the IDF to bomb that hospital?

An interesting question. I suggest you think about it the same way as what would happen if bank robbers took over a bank in New York, and were firing rockets at the population - would you consider bombing the bank justified? If it were the only way to prevent mass casualties outside the bank, then yes, I think it would be (and would be effectively what the police/army would do.)

But here's what makes this situation unrealistic/different: If Hamas had taken over a hospital in Tel Aviv, the hospital wouldn't continue to operate like normal. The people in the hospital would either evacuate, or would fight Hamas. If Hamas somehow managed to take over the hospital anyway, we'd be talking about a hostage situation where Hamas had a hospital-full of hostages. Then probably what would actually happen is we'd send in soldiers and/or police to try to root them out by force.

If they were somehow holed up in there, and were actively firing rockets that were killing people, then I assume there'd be some determination of whether the army/police were able to remove them quickly, before the death/damage from their rockets proves too much. If not, then for sure there'd be a discussion of whether bombing the hospital is the right choice, though it would have to be a pretty extreme situation (since ground troops probably would be able to get in, and the hostage casualties would be far too high in directly bombing it.)

The difference with the situation in Gaza is obvious IMIO. Whereas in a hospital inside Tel Aviv, Hamas is surrounded by an endless amount of Israeli ground forces that have access to it, inside Gaza that's not the case. I imagine this is actually one of the reasons for the large bombing campaign - to prepare the way for ground forces to invade, so that among other things we can surround any building with troops.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by srazzaque on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:10AM (#38176321)
Interesting analysis.

I think it suffices to say that quite a bit of thought and justification would precede striking a hospital in all of these scenarios. I do hope that this level of thought and consideration is standard operating procedure in the retaliations right now. Mainly to restore some morcel of faith I have in humanity. But I, and those disconnected from internal Israeli military comms (ie most of us) can't be sure.

The political optics/rhetoric aside, the images that I see of wounded children are heartbreaking. The recounts I've read about what happened on October 7th are horrifying. If the stats are accurate, they are depressing as hell. This war has amassed almost a fifth of the total civilian death toll of the 20-year long US War in Afghanistan. In. One. Month.

Collectively I think we can agree that this needs to stop. I hope it stops. But given the track record of skirmishes and hostilities in the region, I'm losing faith.

If the statistics of civilian and children deaths are even 50% accurate, even if Israel succeeds in destroying Hamas, I fear the collateral damage and the cost of human life will just create a future generation of armed boys who all lost their parents in air strikeS in October 2023. They might just call themselves something different.

And so the cycle continues.

I know many people on both sides alike want peace. But it will take a truly superhuman person to walk across that border and say "I forgive you."

When that day comes, a person who's death would be mourned by both sides, we may have some hope.

Until such a day, stay safe. I'll go give my kids a hug now.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by absrd on Monday October 30, 2023 @07:31PM (#38077442)
What could possibly ground your faith in the Israeli government, given the intelligence failure of massive proportions we all witnessed on 10/7? How can you believe that the same government which failed to foresee a massive Hamas offensive on its own border just weeks ago, is now suddenly aware of the exact positions of underground Hamas bases deep within the Gaza strip, and is even privy to phone calls between Hamas operatives?

That's also not to mention the many times Israel has been caught lying to cover its own military actions. You only have to look as far back as the targeted killing of Shireen Abu Akleh

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by stjohnswarts on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:18PM (#38054386)
I believe that 99% of what they're bombing are known or very probably Hamas hot spots. They have no reason to kill regular Palestinians, but they are at war, and war is pretty fkng ugly. They have sat back for decades while Hamas lobbed rockets at them and then turn around and massacre 1400 people as if they were nothing. No I think this is pent-up and they are on a mission to end Hamas with prejudice, they are not on a mission to kill innocent people, but I have no doubt that Hamas will put innocent people between them and Israeli bombs.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by pxc on Saturday October 28, 2023 @08:52PM (#38054884)
> They have sat back for decades

7x as many Palestinians have been killed in this conflict than Israelis. And on average, in the West Bank alone, Israel kills a Palestinian every day.

Moreover, to 'sit back' as an occupied in a situation founded on mass expulsion, in which settlers actively continue illegal territorial expansion is an act of real, profound, material violence.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by kingofpandora on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:31PM (#38055402)
It's obviously your choice to believe this despite all the evidence to the contrary.

For me it just underlines how people need a flimsy excuse so they don't have to openly support killing civilians.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:57AM (#38056623)
You've got this completely wrong. It's basically the opposite.

The Hamas terrorist attacks were the pent up thing. Israel's retaliation is war crimes, terrorism and absolutely inexcusable.

Don't blame the deaths of Palestinian children on Hamas. If Israel didn't want to kill innocents, they could just not bomb them for fucks sake.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:46PM (#38065153)
What they are supposed to do? To just do nothing and let terrorists grow stronger and do what they want?

> Israel's retaliation is war crimes, terrorism.

You're wrong but if you repeat it a thousand times maybe it will become truth. A war crime is using civilians as human shield. Terrorism is indiscriminately launching rockets at civilians areas, of which ~30% hits Gaza. Terrorism is killing civilians purposefully in barbaric ways to send a message and incite fear. Hamas and Iran are the architects of what is happening today in Gaza.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Monday October 30, 2023 @02:54AM (#38066436)
I don't support Hamas. They're terrorists as well. But there is no good/bad side here. Don't use one side being bad to excuse the atrocities done by the other side. It's sickening how you and others excuse the killings of thousand of innocent children just because those bombs might also kill a few from Hamas.

All you wrote about war crimes is exactly what Isreal does as well. If you can't see that, you should think hard about what propaganda you're listening to.

But maybe it's a coping mechanism? Because acknowledging the truth about the amount of innocents being killed would be unpleasant?

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:03AM (#38069591)
You attempted to create a false symmetry while appealing to emotion. And didn't answer my questions.

> you should think hard about what propaganda you're listening to.

I listen to both. It's just that Israel at least say some truth (that can be independently verified) while Hamas only lies and play victim.

> But maybe it's a coping mechanism?

I'm far from these events. Maybe you are the one coping and avoid unpleasant facts.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by matsemann on Monday October 30, 2023 @03:01PM (#38074113)
You're the one trying to create a false symmetry, by saying one either has to support Hamas or Israel. But no, I don't. One can condemn both. What I support is the innocent civilians and kids.

There is no way to support Israels bombings, killings thousands of innocent children, no matter how it's framed. If you do, you might as well spell it straight out instead of hiding behind weak arguments: you support the killing of children.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @04:07PM (#38075000)
Signaling virtue isn't the same as being virtuous.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by justnotworthit on Saturday October 28, 2023 @03:01PM (#38052454)
We can now say cutting off the internet is their goal:

The minister of communications has said Israel will “use all means at its disposal to fight” the use of Elon Musk’s Starlink to support connectivity for aid groups in Gaza.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by justnotworthit on Saturday October 28, 2023 @03:01PM (#38052462)
We can now say cutting off the internet is their goal:

Israeli official says will fight Starlink’s deployment in Gaza

The minister of communications has said Israel will “use all means at its disposal to fight” the use of Elon Musk’s Starlink to support connectivity for aid groups in Gaza.

Posting on X, Shlomo Khari said if the Starlink satellite internet is deployed “Hamas will use it for terrorist activities”.

“There is no doubt about it, we know it, and Musk knows it,” he wrote.

“Perhaps Musk would be willing to condition it with the release of our abducted babies, sons, daughters, elderly people,” he wrote.

Musk had made the offer to use Starlink in Gaza earlier today, although further details have yet to emerge.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @11:05PM (#38055538)
Notice that it's the goal only on the moment of the armed invasion which happened only yesterday. The line goes through Israel and it could have cut that on day one.

Cutting communications before an invasion is pretty basic military strategy. Unfortunately, it also cuts civilian population off but as we asserted... The Hamas is embedded in civilian population and uses them as human shields. It steals fuel destined for hospitals and has made itself rich over the backs of the Palestinian people.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by stjohnswarts on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:14PM (#38054363)
I mean their main objective is to decimate Hamas as an entity in Gaza, they know they'll never get all of them but destroying all their infrastructure and weapons (and other) caches along with their leadership is critical. I'm sure they know they'll never end the movement,but they can destroy nearly all their large scale capabilities.
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Saturday October 28, 2023 @11:10PM (#38055551)
There is a way to end the movement and that was what Rabin tried to do in 1992. The Oslo accord was about making peace with the more moderate PLO. The idea was that the Palestinian people themselves would reject the doctrine of the Hamas and get rid of it.

Personally I think it could have worked given time and more intelligence work but now it will be much harder. The Hamas controlled the school system in Gaza. I just watched a video of a bunch of kids, no older than mine. Cute as pie, telling the camera how horrible the Jews are and that they want to drive a car into them when they grow up. That nothing is more holy than to be a martyr for god. Pretty fucked up stuff.

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by lobocinza on Monday October 30, 2023 @04:11PM (#38075062)
Generations entirely brainwashed into Jihad. Have you seen "Tomorrow's Pioneers"?
Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by invalidname on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:20PM (#38079865)
It's on my Netflix queue :-(

It's pretty tragic.

Reference for people reading this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomorrow%27s_Pioneers

Re:The destruction of Gaza's internet is complete by culi on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:13AM (#38055952)
Even before the full invasion, Israel's (illegal) blockade on Gaza made it so that _on average_ there was 11 hours of blackouts each day. The world has _already_ not been able to know what's happening in Gaza. Not to mention the fact that Israel (again, illegally) destroyed their seaport and airport and built a border completely surrounding Gaza and blocked movement across it