Same. I've run my own experiment by paying for a couple months, then letting the subscription lapse, and repeating. I've been through 3 cycles. My conclusion is that if you don't pay, you don't exist. I'm currently not paying, and I don't see doing so any more. Even if I do pay, I have no desire -- and nothing particular to leverage -- to build a serious "presence," so I will always be just another nobody spitting in the wind.
My school teacher jokingly gave a small scenario, he said "Imagine you know everyone in the city, you have to say hi or atleast nod to everyone. Not doing it would be to acknowledge you don't care for them."
And this is something I see a lot. There are a ton of accounts that have less than 100 followers that only do substantive Tweets. And the people who keep rehashing the same clickbait have huge followings. Even most of the relatively substantive large accounts spend a ton of time rephrasing Tweets they’ve made before. A high volume mediocre account that games the system somewhat is going to be a lot bigger than an account that only Tweets/comments when they have something substantive to say, at least in my experience.
On the other hand, if zero people retweet your "substantive Tweet", maybe it's just not that interesting to anybody but you?
I really do not find this to be true. The high ones are from blue checks and overwhelming majority of them has no meaning. I do not even mean insulting or something I disagree with, they just don't say anything.
There are very few real responses now and majority of what I see excluding the above are knee jerks super short responses.
Also keep in mind that the more informative the submission, the longer people spend on the site, the less upvotes it gets because by the time they return it would have likely scrolled off the screen. Short, punchy things dominate
You want lots of people having a few followers rather than one person having millions.
Remember all those people who saw follower counts plummet as soon as Musk started doing his due diligence and looking into the bot situation?
What's that thing called? Is it The empty internet phenomenon? Where its all bots and you're the only human.
Not sure if that's because of some recent change.
Many people had the same experience also back a decade ago (and in between). Just because they adviced to "tweet often, comment often, follow accounts" it didn't mean this guaranteed followers, it was just the bare minimum required to be able to get any.
On platforms with much less users (like some "federated" replacements) this is often not the case - connections are more easily made there, but I'd say that's always the case when a social network is much smaller and people try to "build up" their circles (as opposed to when they're spoilled for choice).
I started a new account recently (hadn’t used my old one in years), and doing so now got me just about zero attention. I got zero followers from comments, posts I made, following others, etc. It was like shouting in an empty room. Of course, there were ways to “increase engagement” that I tried and they did increase my follower account - but to what end? At that point it just feels like a weird game where everyone is trying to scam each other.
I tried another social media app recently, and was surprised to find it was like how Twitter used to be. When I followed people, a bunch of people followed me back. A bunch of people reached out to me, so that even though I haven’t put _any_ effort into engagement so far, I’ve made a lot of connections. People there are one social media to be, well, social. On Twitter, it feels like a mercenary game of “What can this person do for me?”/“How can I trick this person into making them think I’ll make them rich/healthy/wealthy/successful.”