News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by bloopernova on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#38027785)
Used to play D&D with that crew. I wonder if I can still make Rob mad by mentioning Spike Stones? (My druid threw some down at entirely the wrong time and lost us the battle)

Slashdot at the time of the Netscape open source announcement was a fantastic place, it felt like the future was going to be great in 1998. I still miss the metamoderation and I'd like to see it implemented in more places.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by OfSanguineFire on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:24PM (#38027871)
I miss the troll culture that Slashdot had, people put a lot of work into crafting elaborate jokes. Many Slashdot regulars intentionally browsed at -1 so that, on slow news days, they could read some of the inventive troll posts: Netcraft is Dying, Penisbird Enterprises, Batman Touched my Junk, etc. HN does have good discussion, but the culture here is not welcoming of jokes, and when those jokes get modded down, dead, or flagged, the controls for people to view them regardless are less convenient than Slashdot’s were.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by hi_again_dang on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:29PM (#38027958)
Yeah, this is my experience with HN as well, but I think it’s a byproduct of muppets taking themselves too seriously and the general movement of how overly sensitive, and easily offendable people in general have become.

If you can’t take the piss, don’t swing your dick around the place.

You’re all fags. Except for some of you, you’re cool.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by TheRealDunkirk on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:38PM (#38028089)
"Fuck you, fuck you, fuck you, you're cool, and fuck you, I'm out!"
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by abalashov on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:16PM (#38028680)
I lament the humourlessness of HN 99% of the time, but the disproportionately important 1% counterpoint is that this can easily set off an irrecoverable death spiral.

Consider why HN is a higher-quality forum than Reddit for most purposes; Reddit has been overrun with trolls, neckbeards and just very "online" personalities, but the wrong kind of "online". More 4chan, less "News for Nerds, Stuff that Matters".

I don't know if one remembers Kuro5hin, the "un-Slashdot" alternative of the very early 2000s. I still have motor memory for the domain in my fingers, evidently. Something like this happened there.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by spookthesunset on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:36PM (#38030703)
K5 was one of the few sites where I’d actually pay attention to the username of the poster. On sites like this one, it’s me writing to an anonymous, random person.

I think this is because k5 had diaries. It build a community of people who knew each other to some extent.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by abalashov on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:19PM (#38031192)
It did. And I miss it! It was certainly an interesting, and sadly forgotten, time in Internet history.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by bloopernova on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:27PM (#38027918)
I miss the old school trolls where entertainment was as much a goal as annoyance.

Elaborate castles in the clouds of unbelievable yarns, like an episode of Would I Lie To You?

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by ChainOfFools on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:53PM (#38029224)
Yeah. unfortunately the word trolling sometime over the past 15 years started to merge with what was customarily referred to as griefing or flame bait or flaming itself. The crucial quality that a troll is best executed with as much subtlety as possible so as not to be detected by the intended target (but amusingly obvious to everyone else) was completely lost in the mainstreaming of the word.

Now it's used mainly as something like "being a dick online" or even without the online part, as if English (and every other language) didn't have enough slang for this behavior already.

I submit that what has happened to the word trolling should be exhibit A in the counter argument against the claim that language evolves over time, or at least challenge the idea that evolves is analogous to "improves" or "becomes better suited to its purpose."

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by rendall on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:31PM (#38029805)
> The crucial quality that a troll is best executed with as much subtlety as possible so as not to be detected by the intended target

Yeah.. noo. Who told you this? This is wrong on so many levels it is hard to know where to begin.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by ChainOfFools on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:40PM (#38029949)
Even the gnaa and the penis bird and all that sort of thing, although typically labeled -1, troll by slashdot's moderation system (because that's the best fitting option in the list - the obvious absurdity ruling out using "flamebait" instead), were really not getting at the original (and semantically unique) sense of the term [0] as it existed during the Usenet days when it first appeared.

http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/T/troll.html

"The well-constructed troll is a post that induces lots of newbies and flamers to make themselves look even more clueless than they already do, while subtly conveying to the more savvy and experienced that it is in fact a deliberate troll. If you don't fall for the joke, you get to be in on it."

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by rendall on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:51PM (#38030102)
I think for me the turning point as an inveterate troll was learning about seriously sociopathic nihilistic groups like Queer [n-word] for Satan who would no-kidding bully and doxx vulnerable people. My attempting to get a rise out of the clueless was nothing compared to that kind of monstrousness.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by ChainOfFools on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:21PM (#38030491)
I think I may have given a late estimate for the turning point of the word troll, because even by the time slashdot came around and usenet had already gone into steep decline, the usage has started to shift away from "trolling-as-in-fishing-technique" craftwork and toward "trolling-as-in-attention-seeking-monster's-petty-sadism."

The former requires ever greater refinement to improve upon, while the latter requires merely ever increasing tolerance for banal cruelty, leading to the situation you described.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by sangnoir on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:19PM (#38030461)
There are no distinct boundaries between griefing, trolling and flamebaiting. I'd argue the groups with intentionally offensive names are griefers by default. Is intentionally triggering a negative reaction in someone for lulz using an off-topic comment and claiming "it's just a joke, bro" trolling, flamebaiting or griefing? Depends who you ask, but I'm glad none of the overt versions of the three are welcome on HN.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by tivert on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:02PM (#38030261)
>> The crucial quality that a troll is best executed with as much subtlety as possible so as not to be detected by the intended target

> Yeah.. noo. Who told you this? This is wrong on so many levels it is hard to know where to begin.

It's literally the classic definition of an internet troll. The whole point was to subtly push other people's buttons to get them to do something interesting.

See this semi-famous example: https://gwern.net/doc/cs/2001-12-02-treginaldgibbons-isyours.... It can and did trigger a lot of geeks' impulse to pedantically correct others, be opinionated (e.g. AOL hate), and defend their hobbies against what they perceived as cultural hostility.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by rendall on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:13PM (#38030404)
> It's literally the classic definition of an internet troll.

Yeah, nah. Maybe for boomers? Are you "silent generation"?

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by tivert on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:22PM (#38030497)
> Yeah, nah. Maybe for boomers? Are you "silent generation"?

Nice troll.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by ChainOfFools on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:32PM (#38030643)
"uhm, akshally... that is flamebait. HAND" -B1FF
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by gilmore606 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:42PM (#38033068)
gr8 b8 m8 :)
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by bloopernova on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:02PM (#38030994)
Nicely done, I completely fell for it.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by kbelder on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:23PM (#38031245)
You got me.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by gopher_space on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:15PM (#38032391)
The concept of 'troll' moved from "like a fisherman" to "like under a bridge".
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by fsloth on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:22PM (#38028759)
Counterpoint - strong prank and joke culture can quickly turn to a closed subculture that is offputting to otherwise superb contributors. I really enjoy HN due to the generally lukewarm and civilized discussion the rules promote. I love jokes and filthy humour, but gladly seek them elsewhere.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by OfSanguineFire on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:49PM (#38029158)
Absolutely nothing wrong with closed subcultures. The need to draw as large an audience as possible in order to satisfy investors, is part of why discussion on sites like Reddit is so flawed.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by fsloth on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:48PM (#38030061)
Totally agree. I was not pitching for large audience, the dryness creates a specific exclusivity in itself. HN subculture is focused on conrete subjects with world class subject experts occasionally pitching in.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by fragmede on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:16PM (#38030433)
Tons of things wrong with closed subcultures. Do we only want to hear from TechBros about the latest fad, currently how awesome LLMs are, with no dissenting opinion to provide any sort of debate? I, for one, welcome our large audience, because this place has more posts than Slashdot, has wireless, and isn't lame(most of the time).
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by marginalia_nu on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:26PM (#38030566)
This would be bad if these closed subcultures were the only cultures to exist.

But that would be a self-contradiction, by the virtue of being closed, there are people who are not part of them, so they cannot be the only culture.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by CodeWriter23 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:56PM (#38030181)
Elitism is a disease we should not cater to in any circumstance.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by kbelder on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:21PM (#38031217)
Don't worry, most aren't.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by gopher_space on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:12PM (#38032360)
I've never figured out what people mean by the tech elite. Internally I only see regular rich people and folks who find blinking lights fascinating. Using interest in a subject as a barrier to entry seems like a fairly straightforward noise filter.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by zem on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:04PM (#38029409)
I still remember the wikipedia article on "slashdot trolling phenomena" (yes, it was its own page, not a subsection of the slashdot page!) describing the gnaa as "organised coalition of slashdot trolls". for some reason, at the time I thought that was the funniest phrase I'd ever seen on wikipedia.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by tivert on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:46PM (#38030801)
For reference: https://web.archive.org/web/20061013102144/http://en.wikiped...

Wikipedia used to be much more fun.

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by pohl on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:50PM (#38030093)
I feel like I remember good old days before the troll culture arrived. I had a 3-digit id, and remember users like Meeept (no offense, whoever you were) being the beginning of the decline. Maybe it's just rose-colored glasses on my part, though.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by frou_dh on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:01PM (#38030250)
That makes me think of Reddit where many submissions that ask the audience a question need to have the comment sort order changed to "controversial" to read something interesting.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by fragmede on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:19PM (#38030458)
Ah yes, who can forget the quality curious engaging debate, such as first post!1, hot grits and the GNAA. What wonderful life they brought the place. To your point though, the tools available with reason- based pointing, and meta moderation, were far superior than later forums have.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by OfSanguineFire on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:07PM (#38031053)
Communities of people who spend their time together in quality intellectual discussion, like researchers, might still head for the pub, organize barbecues, or go fishing where they just want to blow off steam and make jokes, and among their own people where they can base those jokes on nerdy shared lore. There’s room for both serious things and frivolous things in life.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by mrbuttons454 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:21PM (#38030490)
frost pist
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by CoastalCoder on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:14PM (#38028659)
I have been curious of one could add /. 's meta-moderation and/or reason-for-vote scheme to HN, without losing the things that make HN unusually good.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by OfSanguineFire on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:33PM (#38028904)
Slashdot’s own code was open-sourced for other websites to build on top of. When HN was founded, it could have even used Slashdot’s own system of moderation directly. However, HN is part of Y Combinator, and the latter undoubtedly wants to protect its brand. Discussion on such corporate-owned websites naturally always entails more severe moderation than on hobbyist communities or ones run by a small business.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by dfxm12 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:35PM (#38028937)
I'd prefer a vote or post scheme, maybe at the thread level. I like that at least you can't downvote people who respond to you.
Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by ip_addr on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:01PM (#38029344)
One of my favorite documentaries covers this moment inside Netscape.

Code Rush https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Q7FTjhvZ7Y

Re:Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda – Hacker History Podcast by nullhole on Thursday October 26, 2023 @11:52PM (#38034502)
Thanks for the reference, I've never seen it but it's quite good. I haven't seen anything quite like it, at least for the time-and-place.

It makes me see the downside of wfh..