There are so many ways you could catch leakers of sensitive information this way. Look at how often government agencies react information in PDFs by writing black blocks over the text.
Note it could be used for authentication in the opposite direction, only accepting text with the unusual spaces in it.
So far as catching the indolent and the ignorant, making an example here or their works wonders.
Or copy the text using an OCR app.
In fact there is precedent for this. When I was at school a lot of kids would start writing an essay by copy and pasting the most relevant Wikipedia article into Microsoft Word, and then edit it to sound different, but this resulted in a subtle light-blue background being inserted into the resulting printed page, which made it very obvious that they had copied from Wikipedia. They quickly learnt that they had to paste it through Notepad or similar first to get rid of the background colour.
It's usually Ctrl-Shift-V to not include formatting (or get a menu of options, of which that's one), by the way.
I could hardly comprehend, at that time, how much this was preparation for a career in software development.
We're still in the early stages of it, but AI is and will continue to force us to re-explore our relationships with work, productivity, authenticity and what really matters to us about the "human element" in anything.
Come to think of it, the current socioeconomic equilibrium where students take out loans (or pull on their parents' purse strings) to fund their own education to provide more value to future employers than they ultimately get back seems woefully inefficient, not just for software engineering, but for most academic and industrial fields more generally.
Why not run application cycles or even scout students directly out of high school and enroll them in professional programs run by the organizations themselves in exchange for some number of months or years of discounted labor? Obviously, this isn't happening because it transfers risk from individuals to organizations, but it also seems obvious that, were it subsidized or enforced in some way (insurance?), it might lead to better, more equitable outcomes.
Has anyone else had similar thoughts? Or thoughts to the contrary?
This specific scheme is also not remotely novel; I once saw it implemented, something like six or eight years back, in an effort to quell leaks to an industry rag with a habit of posting paragraph-length excerpts verbatim. They also did this with some of the watermarked emails, having stripped the watermarking whitespace before publication.
This would be a glaring stylistic inconsistency in every text produced with a watermark. You could just as well implement a watermark by doing automated thesaurus replacements on certain of the words and using the index of the selected entry as a code.
A watermark that deeply unnerves everyone who reads the text can carry information, but it tends to render the tool itself unfit for purpose.
There was a story I remember hearing, I think from an older student during highschool or during college from another student's highschool, where some kid was cheating by copying a hand-written paper from another student, and the paper had two names on it. They had put their name in the corner then just blindly wrote all text on the other paper, including the other student's name.
The authors appear to be entirely aware that this sort of substitution can be trivially stripped out by normalizing down to a simplified character set ("The critical limitation of Whitemark is that it can be bypassed by replacing all whitespaces with the basic whitespace U+0020, then the validator can no longer detect the watermark"), but believe that it still has value because the typical student using an LLM to write their essay won't know anything about Unicode.
This seems a bit naive to me. Implementing the necessary "watermark remover" normalization as a simple webapp would be an easy afternoon project for most of us here, and if this approach reached any sort of widespread use there would be many such sites. Students who intend to cheat by using an LLM to write their essays are entirely capable of learning "there's some secret data hidden in the text so copy-paste it through this other site to strip that out before turning it in". Even without access to such a tool they could simply...retype the text themselves?
Arguably this still has some value. In most contexts there is minimal downside to watermarking the generated text in this way, and a slight possibility of catching some cases in which people lazily present LLM generated text as human written. However this might give people a misplaced belief that the absence of such a watermark means the text is authentically human authored, which might outweigh the benefits of catching the occasional lazy or ignorant user.