News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by clnq on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:21PM (#37989528)
Wow, this is a very good news article. I miss when news online was so short and to the point. And what I miss even more is news articles covering both sides of the story. I would expect that The Register or similar sites would not have quoted "We have not confirmed any illegal activities at this point" with this headline.

I feel informed after reading this, not emotionally swayed in some direction.

Just look at this article about refugees - just facts, no opinions inserted - https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2023/10/2f5fe6c44464-refu.... Let's contrast this with a more Western approach to presenting an article about figures related to refugees - https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/9/29/more-than-2500-dead....

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by maven29 on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:01PM (#37990085)
Taking boiler-plate legalese at face-value isn't sustainable. It's just as bad for signal-to-noise ratio as autoplaying video ads.

"We have not confirmed any illegal activities at this point" with this headline." doesn't imply anything of substance at this stage of the process.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by clnq on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:02PM (#37990100)
What would you want it to imply? This is simply a fact. I think it is a problem if a news outlet tries to imply something by selecting facts to paint a certain picture. This is the opposite of that. The facts that the outlet knows are the facts that it states.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by Belopolye on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#37990344)
Given that the Japanese legal system is notorious for only proceeding with charges when the police/prosecutors feel they have an open and shut case (99.8% conviction rate, if I remember), I think they have more to go off of in this case then they’re revealing now. Admittedly this isn’t a normal criminal case, but I’d still expect to see a similar situation here.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by dotnet00 on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:25PM (#37991073)
I think that's more of a criminal case thing, while this is a civil matter.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by Zarathustra30 on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:17PM (#37990273)
It does, actually. It implies the process has just started, which is pretty substantive.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by yieldcrv on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:38PM (#37990508)
I just dont see the deterrent here

I dont see any reason to ever have antitrust related legal counsel in advance

I get the idea of not doing anticompetitive things and hoping the market chooses you, but actually analyzing every possible market share increasing action doesnt seem worth it incomparison to just fighting the regulator later

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by akira2501 on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:17PM (#37990979)
> but actually analyzing every possible market share increasing action doesnt seem worth it

That's sort of fundamental to how markets work. If you're not willing to do this, the government should not be willing to grant you license to operate.

> incomparison to just fighting the regulator later

Yea, don't worry about morality if it gets in the way of money. Laws don't apply if you have enough cash. The long term outcomes of allowing this to continue, I'm sure, will be great for everyone involved.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by nathias on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:22PM (#37991037)
you are right, there should be prison punishments for the managerial class, otherwise its just an added cost of business
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by justinclift on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:11PM (#37991643)
"Bob, we need you to take the fall for us and go to prison for 10 years. We'll look after your family meanwhile, and pay you handsomely for your time."

Plenty of other organisations (of various sorts) are ok with that. Theres no reason Google and similar wouldn't figure out something along the same lines.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by hyeonwho22 on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:35PM (#37991898)
Under the Sherman Act, the criminal penalty for conspiracy to monopolize is up to 10 years in prison or $10M for individuals, and up to $100M for a business, OR up to twice the monetary benefits to conspirators OR up to twice the money lost by victims, if those amounts are over $100M.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by tpmx on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:31PM (#37991154)
It's pretty clear that Alphabet/Google needs to be broken up into at least four separate parts:

1) Search and ads

2) Media (Youtube)

3) Cloud services

4) Mobile OS (Android)

Next: A certain fruit company.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by my12parsecs on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:34PM (#37991201)
Japan is also trying to take a stab at Apple with app store anti trust stuff, but I wonder how these things will play out. Will they just pay some fine and continue to go about their day or will some big change happen, even just for the Japanese market?

I seriously doubt the Japanese government having any power when it comes to opening up the app/play store, or enforcing something of that scale. Europe has been whining a lot, but I don't think there's anything radical being done yet.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by Vespasian on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:48PM (#37991376)
It's all but certain that the App store will be opened up to the degree the DMA demands, when it demands it.

The act will only fully come into force next year and until then nothing needs to be done (besides measures like reporting users to determine who is even affected).

I'm sure the Apple PR team is still debating whether they hide the changes in a font size 1 footnote or whether this will be a "bold decision taken by Apple".

And the jury is yet out how much malicious compliance, that will result in a second round of legislative action and some court cases, they will use.

But rest assured, something is going to happen.

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by mike10921 on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:59PM (#37991504)
The usual movie: Google pushes its monopoly with shenanigans, they get sued, and if they lose they pay a random fine that is a drop in the ocean. Nothing changes and shenanigans continue.
Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by jaflo on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:01PM (#37991528)
The article mentions that Google "is suspected of making the device makers feature its search application and Google Chrome browser app by default and specifying where those apps should appear on the device screens in exchange for allowing them access to the "Google Play" app store"

Is there more information on this anywhere or are the requirements for Google Play certification confidential?

Re:Google faces antitrust probe in Japan for pushing search ... by g_p on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:33PM (#37992529)
Some versions of the Mobile Apps Distribution Agreement (MADA) have found their way into being accessible through previous lawsuits.

The versions available are almost 10 years old now (e.g. https://www.vox.com/2014/5/3/11626422/a-look-at-googles-not-...), but more may become available in future given the increase in court cases like this.