News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by numbsafari on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:54AM (#37984414)
Just because it can’t scale, doesn’t mean it isn’t wrong.

There is no right to a scalable business model. If you can’t figure out how to do your business without doing it right, you shouldn’t be doing it.

Our local coal fired power plant has been yelling for decades that they can’t possibly make a profit and meet all the environmental obligations. Well… guess what.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by mszcz on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:02AM (#37984476)
> Just because it can’t scale, doesn’t mean it isn’t wrong.

That. I'm so tired of this excuse being used which basically amounts to complaining that you wouldn't been able to get so big and fat if you didn't break the rules.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by tap-snap-or-nap on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:11AM (#37984536)
Move fast, break things is basically don't get caught when you break social contracts and regulations.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Symmetry on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:36AM (#37984787)
That's true in principle, but in this case I think that the existence of search engines is a net social good and I think it would be a big loss for all of us if they disappeared. Not that the days of web rings and hand-curated website lists didn't have their own charm but I think that the net effect would be a huge increase in the power of walled gardens.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DannyBee on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:15AM (#37984585)
This is a fun quip, but are you literally suggesting that someone should have to read every webpage indexed by a search engine?

That is what the comment you are responding to suggests doesn't scale.

If so, that seems, way off the deep end to me, and you know, slightly different from your local coal plant killing everyone through pollution.

If not, what precisely is your okay (If non-scalable) solution to the problem presented here?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by arp242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:14AM (#37985145)
If I put something defamatory on my website I can get sued.

Why should it be different for Google?

"We cannot have someone response to every complaint!" – okay, I understand. Then maybe don't do whatever you're doing at all then if you can't handle the responsibility?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DannyBee on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:55AM (#38012275)
It isn't different.

Let's not change the subject - this isn't about responding to complaints - the suggestion here was basically that someone should have to review every single web page that gets indexed.

Either that's what we want or it isn't. Let's not change the subject because this is a line that might have to be drawn.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jeroenhd on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:09AM (#37985877)
If you can't build your product within the bounds of laws and morals, your product sucks or you don't have what it takes to build such a product.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DannyBee on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:56AM (#38012281)
This is again, a great quip, but let's go back to the literal concrete question i asked, to see what line is getting drawn here.

Should Google, or whoever, have to literally review every single page they index?

If yes, how do you expect that to work. If no, what is actually being suggested beyond the quips?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jeroenhd on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:24PM (#38016328)
To answer your question: no.

Google's attempt at a defence implied that they should have checked the pages. There is plenty of internet related law to protect internet companies from responsibility for user submitted content. You can make tons of applications for tons of businesses without breaking the law, and that includes building a search engine.

In this case, Google was notified about the slanderous content on their platform. From that moment they knew, or reasonably could've known if a human actually dealt with their legal notices, that the content was breaking the law. They did not remove the material and the case was brought to court, where Google stated that they were a mere subordinate distributor left in the dark.

If they can't operate their product without dealing with legal complaints, then yes, they should hire more people or reduce the ways their search engine can break the law.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by numbsafari on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:14AM (#37985947)
It's not just a fun quip: it's a moral principle that I really think more people in our industry should come around to.

What we do has consequences. Often times, profound consequences on vast numbers of lives. We have a responsibility, as individual contributors, managers, leaders, and "founders", for the outcomes of our work.

If Google is as smart as they'd like us all to believe, they can find a way to make their business work. Sure, the margins might not be quite as fantastic, but society doesn't owe them maximum return to its own detriment.

It's not my job to solve Google's scalability problems, that's their job. It's my job to hold them just as accountable as my local coal power plant for the choices they make. If Google wants me to love their brand, and support their work, then they should stop being a social and intellectual polluter. It's a lot easier to see and sense the danger of toxic fumes from a power plant than to see and sense the toxic danger of massive social media and tech companies, but they are no less real and no less lethal.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DannyBee on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:54AM (#38012265)
"It's not just a fun quip: it's a moral principle that I really think more people in our industry should come around to."

Which i actually buy into, and have lived for many years, but it also just seems a bit silly applied to this case.

The usual answer is "it's not my job", which you use here.

That's great - throwing rocks from the sidelines is real easy, but it's not clear exactly what you want to happen, so let's instead actually be clear and concrete about that.

So again, concretely: Is your suggestion that someone should review every single web page crawled by a search engine, Google or anyone else?

If not, can we move past the silly quips and try to get to a better place constructively?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by MichaelZuo on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:01AM (#37984472)
That would also imply that there is no right for individuals to have a productive life with plenty of free time per day.

Since burdensome, long-lasting, legally required procedures can also be imposed by a court on an individual.

Seems like a slippery slope to be honest.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by bluGill on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:19AM (#37984615)
There is no right to that. Things that make it impossible should be looked on with suspicion, but the right does not exist.

If you were willing to live like 1930 you could have plenty of free time, but 1930 means electric was a luxury most people didn't have.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by MichaelZuo on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:39AM (#37985443)
Well if there is no right for individuals to have a productive life with plenty of free time per day than a huge number of HN comments on topics such as politics, housing, social welfare systems, healthcare, transportation, etc... are close to meaningless.

Which doesn't seem like an appealing proposition to accept.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by numbsafari on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:56AM (#37985703)
I think your calculation is wrong.

There are plenty of things you can do in life that are productive and provide you with leisure time that don’t also mean you can destroy the lives of others.

You might as well argue for slave labor. Because that’s certainly one way to be productive and have a lot of leisure time. But it’s wrong. None of this exists in a vacuum. Why should other people suffer so you can have free time?

Find a better way.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by MichaelZuo on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:05AM (#37985830)
Have you gotten confused about the topic?

The court can already do this if the ruling holds which is why we are discussing it in the first place. Your phrasing it as if it's up to individual members of society to decide to impose on each other. If you think this is relevant, can you describe how?

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by jeroenhd on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:07AM (#37985851)
There are specific laws indirectly governing work-life balance, such as maximum hours worked consecutively, certain contract stupilations being null and voice because of general law, regulations regarding sick pay, and protections against discrimination, but I don't think there are many countries that explicitly state the right to a productive life with free time.

Rights to housing, welfare, and healthcare are generally handled independently. I'm not sure if there is a "right to transportation". Most rights originate from a basic "right to a happy life" ideal, but are split up and spelt out in particular sub-rights that are easier to enforce in court.

Article 8 of the ECHR and similar human rights conventions seem to come close, but that's mostly used against governments and laws.

I don't think it's a bad idea to introduce such a right, but it needs to be carefully worded or it will cause a lot of trouble.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by bluGill on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:15AM (#37985962)
Yes, everyone wants a better life for themselves and they don't want to consider all the trade offs of consequences of that. In particular they often want to force their own ideals on someone else.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by ballballball on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:15AM (#37984579)
Ahhh... The old "corporations are people" equivocation.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by pmontra on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:24AM (#37984659)
We had a post about that a few months ago

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36732729

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by true_religion on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:04AM (#37985052)
In the US, corporations have the same rights as people because they are collectively made up from people.

In the EU, corporations have fewer rights than the individuals that collectively make them up.

In other countries, different rules apply de jure or de facto.

People’s main complaint about corporations is that no one personally gets hit with a civil charge and civil charges never seem to change the behavior of corporations.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by omnimus on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:18AM (#37984604)
No? Because corporations/companies are not individuals? (no matter how they sometimes try to be)