News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by IanCal on Sunday October 22, 2023 @07:39AM (#37974509)
This may be controversial but YouTube ads are surely ones that meet all the reasonable criteria.

They're not a surprise, you know it's an ad supported business. They're served from YouTube so it's not random companies tracking you while you use a different service. And you can get rid of them by paying for the service.

What's the proposed alternative where you contribute for the service? Just paywall the whole thing?

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by orangepanda on Sunday October 22, 2023 @07:52AM (#37974574)
> And you can get rid of them by paying for the service.

Get rid of _some_ of them

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by 2devnull on Sunday October 22, 2023 @10:02AM (#37975466)
Get rid of _some_ of them for now

It only has to be relatively less ad laden than the free version. Whenever ads get cranked up on the “free” normal person YouTube, they’ll get cranked up on sucker pay-pig YouTube in direct proportion. If anything, they have less concern about the small fraction who (amazingly) pay them for what they’re doing.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by gray_-_wolf on Sunday October 22, 2023 @07:52AM (#37974575)
Probably an unpopular opinion, but I just do not want to have a "business" relationship with google. I would not mind paying for youtube, if it was a separate company. But google does not need my money, and any money the get are used to actively making the world worse (WEI, SEO spam, Search getting worse, ...).

On a separate note, there are reports of people getting their whole google account locked for payment issues, expired cards and such. There is no way to reach a human there, and I really do not want to risk loosing my account I use on my phone as well (android :/) just because some bot decides it does not like me.

Would be fine if I could just have a separate youtube account, but no, that would make tracking harder...

Aaaand there still will be ads inside the videos (sponsored segments), and product placement.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by ssl232 on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:07AM (#37974648)
I wouldn't mind paying for YouTube if its subscription cost was anywhere close to reasonable.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by bad_user on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:24AM (#37975147)
I'm paying $8.30 / month for the Family option. That's like 2 or 3 coffees. In other countries this is more expensive, but it's adjusted for local buying power.

Both you and the parent simply come up with reasons to avoid paying, getting the service for free.

No matter how you look at it, what you're doing is immoral, because if everyone did it, YouTube would be permanently paywalled and placed under DRM. You're a privileged individual that prefers to be subsidized by those that pay or that watch ads.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#37975225)
> That's like 2 or 3 coffees

Expensive coffee at Starbucks which I would never buy. With $10 I can buy coffee for 3 months. It’s way too expensive for me.

I also consider every form of advertising to be brainwashing. Last but not least, I watch 1 YouTube video per month, so you would have to adapt your scenario for me to be interested in a subscription.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by guraf on Sunday October 22, 2023 @01:22PM (#37977271)
Oh fuck off, you can't buy 90 coffees for $10 unless you drink it black and you buy bargain bin stuff.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by i8comments on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:37AM (#37975245)
A coffee costs 30 cents.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by franczesko on Sunday October 22, 2023 @11:53AM (#37976441)
There's nothing immoral about blocking ads. Avoiding paying taxes might be, yet Google does it anyway.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by bad_user on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:39AM (#37984253)
Blocking ads is morally OK only as long as that's the only way to consume that content, and as long as you're not trying to block anti-ad-block warnings.

If there's a reasonably priced subscription available (or another business model), and if the publisher doesn't want your eyeballs while you have an adblocker active, there's no argument you can make for the morality of adblocking. It's your computer, you can be selective about what you execute on it, but the publisher should also be free to reject your visit.

Blocking YouTube's adblock detection legitimizes all the changes that Google is making in Chrome, being why we can't have nice things. And it's similar to extensions designed to workaround paywalls, or software piracy. Sooner or later adblocking will become illegal.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by wintermutestwin on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:51AM (#37975360)
I wouldn't mind paying for youtube if I wasn't already paying for it because they are stealing my data.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by izacus on Sunday October 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#37975533)
Noone is stealing anything from you, you just made this up to feel better about your freeloading.

If you gave a shit, you wouldn't use YouTube.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by anothernewdude on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:10AM (#37974661)
Blocking functionality, playing audio that is not kid friendly and wasting my time are all not reasonable.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by franczesko on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:10AM (#37974662)
The alternative might be Google paying their fair share of taxes. I might consider supporting their product then. Ad blocking is not as severe as tax avoidance though.

I have no sympathy for the service. If it's not profitable, Google can cover it from their other revenue streams with ease.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by dewey on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:15AM (#37974701)
That sounds like one of these reasons that people come up with to justify their unwillingness to pay.

Are you also boycotting every other large company that uses the tax system in a legal way that you don't agree with? I'm all for big companies paying their fair share, but I'm not blaming the company, I'm blaming the people in charge who don't close these loopholes. Same issue as with Ireland in the EU, undercutting all the other EU countries with tax rates.

One option if you want to fight back in the exact same way: Sign up for YouTube Premium through a cheaper country and pay $2/month instead of 15.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by meindnoch on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:18AM (#37974712)
They game our tax system, we game their ad system. It works both ways.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by franczesko on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:47AM (#37974896)
Ad blocking is not illegal. If I can do it, as Google does with taxes, I see no reason why I shouldn't.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by logifail on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:54AM (#37974952)
> Are you also boycotting every other large company that uses the tax system in a legal way that you don't agree with?

Umm, where possible why wouldn't one choose to avoid giving your money to companies that behave in ways you object to?

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by dewey on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:05AM (#37975026)
Voting with your wallet is always the best, my point was that most (all?) big companies will use the tax system in a way to give them the best outcome that's possible through legal means.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by logifail on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:30AM (#37975194)
> most (all?) big companies will use the tax system in a way to give them the best outcome that's possible through legal means

Not every company feels the need to set up their corporate structures to revolve around Luxembourg (or whatever the regional equivalent is in your part of the globe).

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by izacus on Sunday October 22, 2023 @10:11AM (#37975544)
The mental contortions freeloaders do to feel better about themselves are always fascinating to watch on HackerNews.

Somehow it seems really hard for people here to be honest with themselves and admit that they really just want YT for free and someone else (Google) to shoulder the cost. And they also whant to rant at Google while they pay for their services. :)

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by wahnfrieden on Sunday October 22, 2023 @12:00PM (#37976514)
When Google receives tax breaks from the US, it is another form of welfare “freeloading”. A tax break is indistinguishable from a handout except by name.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by guraf on Sunday October 22, 2023 @01:25PM (#37977307)
When wahnfrieden receives ad-free video from YouTube, it is another form of welfare "freeloading". An adblocker is indifferent from a handout except by name.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by hendersoon on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:15AM (#37974702)
I am not responsible for sustaining Google's monetization. There is no such social contract. If their business model isn't sustainable, they should find a new one. That's their problem, not mine.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by IanCal on Sunday October 22, 2023 @10:40AM (#37975766)
You're not, and they're not responsible for delivering you video if you don't want to pay them or watch ads. I'm not sure what's contradictory here.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by tomjakubowski on Sunday October 22, 2023 @03:45PM (#37978433)
I think GP is just responding to your comment's premise that they have to propose any alternative, or that they have to "contribute" to YouTube in some way.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by pravus on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:21AM (#37974724)
I currently pay $5/month to the Kevin Richardson channel as a member and have been a member since inception for over 4 years now. When I went to the members section of YouTube to view my members-only videos I received the blocking message and was denied access to the video player. This is in addition to other wildlife charities for which I send monthly donations directly.

I use uBlock Origin on YouTube specifically to work around many UI issues related to their recommendations and player. I will not turn it off. One example is that they will not honor my closed-caption settings on all videos so I have a filter rule to remove the call to the captions URL to eliminate them. That's one of countless issues.

They are now denying me access to a service for which I do actually pay for. I consider that to be illegal.

My proposal is simple:

    * Give me an option to pay for what I use.  I do not want music, 99.9% of live streams, news, or tons of the other content they try to force on me for money-making purposes.
    * Make the price reasonable.  The videos I watch are primarily educational lectures.  This really shouldn't cost much more than the price of disk storage and network egress (both of which are cheap at scale).
    * Give me a recommendations and preference system that actually work.  I spend more time curating my list of videos than watching anything meaningful to my interests.  At one point I was watching 2 luthiery channels and "guitar necks" came up as a category.  What the ever living fuck?  Related yes, but not quite the topic I really want to focus on.  I would remind people that this is a multi-billion dollar company with PhDs that has changed the face of AI and hyper-scale computing as we know it.
    * In general, operate like a long-running business... offer good value to your paying customers.  Now that the customers are not advertisers, Google will need to rethink their sales strategies.  They have not yet convinced me.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by causality0 on Sunday October 22, 2023 @08:29AM (#37974764)
I spent years having to click "No, I do not consent to creating a Google+ profile" every time I used YouTube so I refuse to give them money on principle.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by kmbfjr on Sunday October 22, 2023 @09:03AM (#37975012)
Paying for the service replicates the cable TV industry. In order to get what I want and support, I end up supporting what I don’t want and don’t want to support.

I am under ZERO obligation to watch advertising, that is the risk the industry takes. The ad industry has long ago tipped the scales in the trade of attention for content and now they resort to shaming the viewers into compliance.

Everyone supporting the adblock countermeasures are hypocrites; as if they never went to the bathroom during a TV show commercial break.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by Ylpertnodi on Sunday October 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#37975539)
>They're not a surprise.

Ha! Try getting 10 minutes into this example and not bring surprised by a fucking pasta ad. https://

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by 13415 on Sunday October 22, 2023 @11:40AM (#37976319)
Ads are very surprising to people who have been using ad blockers for decades. The web experience is totally different. On a side note, I stopped watching TV in the 90s and turned to "internet only" because ads were too annoying. It's weird that companies advertising with Google think people like me could potentially buy something based on ads.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by etedor on Sunday October 22, 2023 @01:28PM (#37977335)
They are a surprise. They’re variable length and appear at random moments. Their volume can greatly differ from the content you are watching. No thanks.

The proposed alternative is Google can continue to bankroll it. They are not hurting for money.

Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by IanCal on Sunday October 22, 2023 @02:33PM (#37977869)
Your proposed alternative is that it's simply run at a loss? I don't think that's a particularly reasonable business proposal.
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by etedor on Sunday October 22, 2023 @02:55PM (#37978038)
What makes you think Google is running at a loss?
Re:Adblock Plus and (A Little) More by missedthecue on Sunday October 22, 2023 @07:14PM (#37979933)
He's talking about YouTube. If no one watches ads or pays for premium, how will YouTube make money?