The HTTP protocol, HTML and vanilla JS are not "the OS layer", and yes, it's part of your job as a web developer to at least understand the basics of them. There are many so-called "frontend devs" nowadays who literally only know React, and if you asked them to create a basic webpage where clicking a button changes some text in an element without React, they'd be completely lost.
Usually the problem with this kind of developer is not just that they don't know, it's that they don't care. They WILL inevitably run into problems that require this basic knowledge to solve because the frameworks can only hold your hand so far, and instead of trying to figure out what's going on under the hood that's causing their issue, they will instead shrug and go "it's not part of my job" and just write a bunch of garbage spaghetti code in an attempt to work around the issue.
Pretty much anyone who has been around long enough has met someone with years and years of experience doing exactly one thing, whether that's WordPress or java CRUD or something else where they have blindingly obvious gaps in their knowledge that someone with their experience shouldn't.
The lack of deep knowledge isn't limited to a single field.
This is an entirely new business domain, it’s not really trying to be the same.
No wonder a lot of modern software is terrible.
To be fair, the last time I "opened up" a computer and changed its RAM was about 10-12 years ago, and since that time I've only worked on a Mac Mini and on a laptop meant that "opening up" computers became a thing of the past.
People here have way too much confidence in their interview questions being a good signal for experience. It’s pretty wild.
You are proving my point. You should care.
My point is that your question is some esoteric gotcha party question that may as well be out of Trivial Pursuit. But you’re treating it like anyone who doesn’t care is just being a bad engineer. There are countless ways engineers spend their time, and choosing what to work on is the most important choice of their careers. It’s on you to justify the claim that knowing the difference between a JS form submit vs browser submit matters at all, let alone that it’s a distinction that comes up in day to day life.
For you that would be trying to work in ML not understanding any of the theory or how it works, but having used OpenCV with some premade models a few times.
For a frontend web developer who, as a large part of their role, will need to communicate with backend systems… that’s not understanding how their FE web application actually communicates with BE systems.
And from experience… yes, this is very common. And it has a noticeable impact on their effectiveness. Trying to debug why some interaction between your application and the BE application isn’t working while thinking the dev tools network inspector is just black magic and nonsense makes your job substantially more difficult.
This does make these people bad engineers. They are not able to understand and solve a huge class of the problems that they face day-to-day and instead (in my experience) often fall back on “just try a bunch of different things until something works for reasons I don’t understand” which is a poor way to approach work and leads to overly complex, buggy, brittle systems.
I think you do. GP just phrased it oddly.
The distinction is between a traditional HTML form and browser page load, vs XMLHttpRequest.
Ultimately it's all HTTP though and on that level, there is no difference whatsoever.
I've started nearly every position in my career in a different domain without prior knowledge, including workflows, protocols and the languages that implement them. I may be an extreme case, but we exist and your process inherently excludes us. I've worked in robotics, consumer electronics, healthcare, fintech (not even in that order, although that probably would have made more sense.) I've delivered in each domain as well as my expert colleagues. But if you asked me to implement a LLM, I'd shug and tell you I don't know how, but I _would_ explain my process for HOW I would learn to.
(Edit: typo)
I do get your point but depends on the role you are hiring for. I have had candidates get upset at me (for example: bootcampers) because they couldn't explain how to submit a basic HTML form but wanted me to look at their github "portfolio" that was done during the bootcamp with React/Express Code and what not. Their title was "Front end React Developer". That is a problem and I usually wouldn't hire those people.
For example, I would take a react developer with obvious gaps and a strong willingness to learn on my back-end services team over a passable back-end dev who was set in their ways (unwilling/uneager to learn new tech, entrenched opinions stated as fact, etc.)
Naturally, my approach is not a one size fits all situation and a great deal depends on org structure and mentorship opportunities being in place for it to work. The benefit being you avoid monoculture "silos", and have more cross collaboration and transfer opportunities between teams (some may call this "full stack", I wouldn't)
Several high performers on my team are "self-taught", work comfortably across several languages today and can pickup new tech easily. They came in knowing their "one stack" at the time. If they were "bootcampers" or not seems irrelevant and somewhat reductive/offensive.
That said, if the candidate in question shows _no_ understanding of their problem domain, can't reason their way out of a paper bag, and get visibility upset from questions when you try and tease that out, that is a certainly a red flag in my book.
With respect to your example given, however, it could be argued that http details because of the abstractions in place inherent in react, aren't critical domain knowledge for what is essentially a UX dev. If they can ship an experience your users enjoy more than the candidate that can recite the HTTP 1.1 RFC and cannot, then what have you gained in hiring the latter other than maintaining a culture of pedantry?
TL;DR it comes down to how much risk your team is willing to take on, as there's always risk inherent in hiring ANY candidate, including those that don't already check all your boxes in regards to tech know-how. I'm merely stating that by overlooking candidates that don't fit your self-imposed mold, you're likely missing opportunities for rewards that can pay dividends when it does work.
Sure, a frontend dev who strictly works on that won’t know much about, say, the OS layer. But they don’t have to, it’s not part of their job in any way.
There is no shortage of young people that work on areas that makes them require deep knowledge of many different layers of the stack, it is simply not necessary for every IT-related job. But one can absolutely pick it up if they want to.