News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by willcipriano on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:36AM (#37957608)
All it takes to get a protective order is a allegation.

It is a common tactic that women use in divorce to file false domestic abuse or child abuse claims. It's called a "silver bullet divorce". Unfortunately abuse of the legal system like this has made it necessary to be skeptical of claims of domestic abuse without evidence.

Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by jcranmer on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:47AM (#37957761)
Sure, there's actually a chasm of difference between a protective order and a full criminal conviction. That's enough to meet the falsehood requirement of defamation.

However, to demonstrate actual malice, you have to demonstrate that the defendant knew of just how different the two things were, which is frankly a pretty tall ask.

Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by FireBeyond on Friday October 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#37958046)
> However, to demonstrate actual malice, you have to demonstrate that the defendant knew of just how different the two things were, which is frankly a pretty tall ask

If I was a defendant in such a thing, I'd point to numerous cases where police departments have claimed, and courts have agreed, that police are not expected to be experts on the law.

"If law enforcement officers can be held by the court to not have to have a nuanced understanding of the law, how could I possibly?"

Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by kube-system on Friday October 20, 2023 @12:53PM (#37958553)
A comparison is not relevant. The threshold is whether or not the person making the claim knew, independent of anything anyone else in the world does or doesn't know, and the burden is on the other side to prove that they did.
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by FireBeyond on Friday October 20, 2023 @01:04PM (#37958682)
That's a little reductive. If that were so, there'd barely be a need for defense in our criminal system, just "Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you've heard the prosecution's case - do you believe they've established guilt?". Instead, regardless of the ostensible burden, statements like this by the defense work to erode any claims of "beyond reasonable doubt".
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by bb611 on Friday October 20, 2023 @01:35PM (#37959098)
You're conflating the civil and criminal judicial systems when the reality is they're quite separate, and defamation has its own special corner of the civil realm where plaintiffs have a very steep hill to climb.
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by mediasavvy on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:48AM (#37957774)
That isn’t necessary. Iowa has no-fault divorce.
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by salamanderss on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:53AM (#37957840)
They don't have no fault child custody though, which IMO is a most important part of the divorce. In practice by far the biggest money prize in a higher income divorce is a big child support award, and there you want to fault the spouse as much as possible to turn your kid into a cash cow to "maintain living standards" while in your disproportionate custody.
Re:Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False... by tyingq on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#37957794)
The protective order in this case is from a former girlfriend.