News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:55AM (#37926672)
Open source does not mean you can look at the source code. Open source is defined by the OSI.

If it is not using and OSI-approved license and claims to be open source it is open washing. Call it shared source or something else.

This is a long since settled debate.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by vasco on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:23AM (#37926827)
A judge saying something once in the history of the world doesn't make it so that you can force language on others. Most people that I've interacted that work in software refer to "source available" as open source in every day speech, and unless they were preparing legal documents that's what they'd say. If you include normal people that don't work in software, then even more likely the usage is the one you're complaining about. You sound like this: https://stallman-copypasta.github.io/
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by 6510 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @07:14AM (#37927115)
> Most people that I've interacted that work in software refer to "source available" as open source

Proprietary software and closed source refer to the same thing.

Most people you've interacted are wrong. sorry...

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by vasco on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @07:23AM (#37927183)
Luckily I didn't mention either "closed source" or "proprietary software" in my comment. I mentioned that people colloquially use "open source" to refer to any code base that has source available to read.

Maybe there's some hidden point you're trying to make by associating these concepts but it'd be easier if you said it plainly.

Other than that I think you find that people in real life don't tend to be exact in their use of language all the time, and calling understandable imprecisions "wrong" tends to decrease the number of friends you get.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @07:43AM (#37927312)
People distort words to the point of meaningless unless the use of those words are defended. "Open Source" is a term that is actively being defended.

The history of the term is very clear. The term was coined by Christine Peterson in a group session in 1998 with Todd Anderson, Larry Augustin, Jon Hall, Sam Ockman, Michael Tiemann, and Eric S. Raymond. Months later the OSI was created by the same people in order to manage that definition. There is nothing unclear here. "Open source" is defined by OSI and it has been defined by them from the very start.

If communities let others distort words, those words loose their meaning. As a well known example, the word "woke" which has long been abandoned by the community that coined it.

"Open source" is an actively defended term by the organisation that originally defined it and the community around them.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by vasco on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:01AM (#37927441)
Well if you're actively consciously defending it like that I can only wish you good luck. I guess if that's the goal comparing you to Stallman with GNU is more of a compliment than anything.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by xctr94 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @02:47PM (#37932955)
I’m not a fan of Stallman by any measure — his posture has often put people off some licenses and made GPL a bit problematic —, but even I think you’re engaging in unreasonable doublespeak.

The web is full of HTML, CSS, and JavaScript you can see the source for; and for which you can be sued by copying for your own commercial gain. By your definition, websites are open source; and yet, they are proprietary work. Something having its source open doesn’t make it Open Source.

This kind of doublespeak reeks of Reddit-grade corporate astroturfing.

The Open Source licenses are defined and protected in a certain way. You can’t just say “oh, me and my friends don’t think of it like that” and expect to be correct. I can’t build an app scamming people out of currency by abusing ISO 4217, and then excuse myself under “me and the people I know disagree with ISO”. OSI protects the licenses, the Vegan Society certifies what ‘vegan’ means, ISO does ISO things, and so on.

It’s okay to admit we’re wrong or ignorant, so I won’t pretend I’m an expert in this area. I also wouldn’t call anyone Stallman just because they are defending a term that deserves protection. “Source available” but not under the terms of an OSI license is NOT compliant with the term.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by 6510 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:49PM (#37936846)
> Maybe there's some hidden point you're trying to make by associating these concepts but it'd be easier if you said it plainly.

I'm sorry, I thought it was obvious.

As "proprietary software" and "closed source" refer to the same it wouldn't be logical to use the opposite "open source" to refer to "proprietary software".

People don't have to be exact in their language, the point is for the other to understand what you mean.

I consider it the most polite and the most constructive to use the definition from the believers themselves.

Academic, as in relating to education and scholarship. Anarchy, as in without Archons. Archons, as in leaders of ancient Greek city-states. Let the communist define what it is, let the socialist, let the Jew, let the ufologist etc

There is the Open Source Initiative, the page starts with what they consider Open Source. https://opensource.org/osd/

Besides practicality the website also states: Never use or register any trademarks that are confusingly similar to, or a play on, the OSI or OSI Logo. An example of unacceptable is given: "Open Source Project"

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by mx20 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @09:28AM (#37928355)
Normal people don't even know what to do with the code. If a project is source open or not is completely irrelevant to them. To them usually it's way more relevant that open source software can be picked up and further developed by any other software developer and that it's free.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @10:11AM (#37928947)
In this case, the licence they have chosen explicitly:

- only grants the right "to access and use the code solely for the purposes of review, compilation and non-commercial distribution."

- only grants the right "provide the code to anyone else and publish excerpts of it for the purposes of review, compilation and non-commercial distribution"

- "you are not entitled to use or do anything with the code for any commercial or other purpose, other than review, compilation and non-commercial distribution"

This breaks all 4 freedoms the free software definition and at least aspects 1,3,4 and 6 of the OSD.

From a legal POV, this project is unforkable. You are not allowed to modify this in any way (even just for your own use).

Furthermore, you are not even allowed to use this internally (unmodified and without ever distributing it). I am not even sure it is possible to legally be a user of the software for its intended purpose. The license states clearly that "other than review, compilation and non-commercial distribution" you "are not entitled to use or do anything" and that includes using the compiled result to watch videos. This is about as restrictive as the MS-RSL.

Basically, the only thing you can do with it is archive it and look at it.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Sytten on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:07AM (#37926743)
That is not a settled debate IMO, even Stallman said as much. Sure its not FOSS / FLOSS, but trying to push for a position where open source doesn't mean I can see the code is very much not agreed by everybody.

EDIT: See https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:17AM (#37926789)
Just like Microsofts opinion didn't matter whenever they tried to dilute the meaning of open source, and just like MongoDB's and others opinion didn't matter, your opinion doesn't matter. Microsoft is far more convincing than you and they did not win this argument.

Microsoft gave up and now only calls OSI-approved licenses open source.

Open Source means OSI-approved.

If you can read the source code but it's not OSI-approved, than it's source-available or shared source or something else.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:02AM (#37926708)
Yes, it does. It's the opposite of closed source, and the meaning is implied by the word open.

OSI isn't authoritative of the term.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:09AM (#37926757)
This debate has been had many many times before and you are simply wrong. Your effort is malicious.

Regardless of what other uses the word open has/had, "open source" was defined by OSI and they are authoritative over the term.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:21AM (#37926808)
Malicious is the attempt to restrict open source to floss and start a shitstorm about open source but not floss software, because it prevents transparency for software where floss isn't an option.

If I define climate neutral as climate positive, climate neutral doesn't become climate positive nor do I get authority of the term climate neutral.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:36AM (#37926900)
And yet that is absolutely the kind of bullshit you are pulling. Thank you for denouncing yourself.

Some terms were defined by a community and their use defended. Others were defined by a community, appropriated by others, distorted by others and subsequently abandoned by the original community. And yet others, were abandoned and then reclaimed by the original community.

"Open Source" is in the first category, defined by OSI and defended by the FLOSS community. It is actively being defended, and fish much bigger than you have failed to topple the community.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:48AM (#37926969)
"And yet that is absolutely the kind of bullshit you are pulling. "

Nope it's what you and OSI try to do.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by wokwokwok on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:20AM (#37926804)
I honestly don’t care if it is or not, but this has been discussed to death with regard to unreal and the consensus has been (from epic) to consistently refer to the source as “available on GitHub” not as “open source”, because that gives people an incorrect impression of the permissiveness of the license.

Is this a hill you really want to die on?

It doesn’t matter at all.

The “can see code” = “must be open source” argument is stupid because it’s entirely opinion based. You cannot be right about it.

It depends what you choose to define “open source” as. If you define it as some arbitrary thing (eg. I can read the source code) then of course you’re right. …but you can’t force other people to accept your arbitrary definition.

You can only have an opinion about it.

Same as anyone else.

Is it really worth the argument?

Source available is unambiguous, being explicit (“source can be download from GitHub”) I means you don’t have to waste your time on arguments like this for, what seems, truely trivial reasons.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:28AM (#37926847)
"because that gives people an incorrect impression of the permissiveness of the license"

How does it?

"Source available is unambiguous"

It's not, because it could be hidden behind a pay wall.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:43AM (#37926934)
If it's behind a pay wall it's not available, it's closed.

But you may call source-available software whatever you want, just not open source unless it's under and OSI-approved license.

You can use any words other than the phrase "open source" to be as unambiguous as you want.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by wokwokwok on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:46AM (#37926960)
I don’t understand.

If you feel it’s not explicit enough be more explicit (source is available from xxx of you login or whatever).

If you want a legal opinion, get a lawyer, that’s what they do.

If you just want to do what’s “normal”, take a successful project (eg. Unreal) and do what they do.

It seems like a total non issue.