News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by koen31 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:16AM (#37926109)
As one of the devs of the project, I will try to answer your questions as much as possible.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by philipwhiuk on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:42AM (#37926226)
Given YouTube's business model is reliant on ads and serving a stream of multiple videos how long do you seriously expect to remain unblocked?
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by yieldcrv on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:29AM (#37926171)
on occasion I like to watch the creator's simulcast, but different angles

like, the Youtube/Twitch feed be their main content with a camera directly on the creator with them superimposed on a screen recording, and the TikTok feed might be a different angle. But the comments and interactions are wildly different. The main purpose is to funnel towards either one, or yet another platform for payment, but this can be entertaining on its own to watch both.

does your app solve anything for that use case, or have any aspirations to? I think its useful to just be able to follow someone around, I have always contended that social graphs are easily exportable and the platform doesn't matter and I'd like to see social graphs as a first class citizen as opposed to being happenstance behind social media company's newfangled platforms.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by koen31 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:36AM (#37926192)
The first step (which is now already working) is that creators can create a polycentric identity and link their platforms together using the Harbor app.

If you are then subscribed to their YouTube channel, you will also see content they post on any other platform like Patreon, etc.

You subscribe to the creator, not the platform identity.

We cannot easily provide social graphs for platforms we cannot control. However, we also offer the option to make Polycentric comments where you as the commenter own your comment, rather than the platform owning the comment.

Polycentric is an open protocol https://docs.polycentric.io/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLoCtRzTkJQ&t=0s and you are free to create any social graph you might want to.

I hope this answers your question sufficiently.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by moonleay on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:48AM (#37926257)
Will there be support for streaming videos from Piped instances?
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by koen31 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:55AM (#37926306)
The plugin is not in the pipeline right now. However, anybody can make a plugin (see https://gitlab.futo.org/videostreaming/plugins for examples). We will also publish more docs soon to help people get started (heres a small getting started doc https://gitlab.futo.org/videostreaming/grayjay/-/blob/master...).

Perhaps in the future once we have a bit more time we can spend more time adding platforms.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by zakki on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:26AM (#37926484)
What is the license for the plugin?
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Timshel on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:50AM (#37926980)
All plugins appear to be under AGPL v3 cf: https://gitlab.futo.org/videostreaming/plugins/youtube/-/blo...
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by TT-392 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:54AM (#37926299)
How does the app get the youtube videos, and their info. Is it scraping, like newpipe. Using official api's, maybe something closer to what youtube vanced did?

Would it just stop working when WEI is implemented?

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:05AM (#37926367)
Please tell Louis he is damaging the project by calling it open source when it is not.

If you want to be Free Libre Open Source Software then use an OSI and FSF approved licence.

If you want to protect your brand from people cloning your app, do like Mozilla and use a trademark + MPL.

If you don't want to be open source don't call it open source, it's shared source or something else.

I told him and he did not seem to consider it a big deal.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:53AM (#37926651)
He called it open source, not floss, didn't he?

It's not shared source, since anyone is able to inspect the source code, not just a subset of people

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:04AM (#37926718)
This is a settled debate. You will not convince anyone to use your definitions. We had this debate when MongoDB switched, when CockroachDB switched and for many others. And nothing has changed.

Open source means OSI-approved licence and that will not change.

This is shared source or source-available, not open source.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:07AM (#37926746)
You aren't authorative for the term either.

And, obviously, thanks to your comments, the debate doesn't seem to be settled.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by jillesvangurp on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:22AM (#37926816)
The debate only exists in the heads of apologists for shared source. The OSI definition exists to remove the need for a debate. It's either OSS or it isn't per their definition.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by tcfhgj on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:29AM (#37926859)
Interesting rejection of reality
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by mx20 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @09:53AM (#37928695)
Why do non programmers know about open source if it doesn't concern them? They don't have any benefit from an source open application besides maybe theoretically better security audits. I would arue is because people expect that you can pick it up and change the code, so it can be forked and continued in the future and also because it's usually free.

It's also not the only deceptive Adventisten. He also claimed that you can use it how you want the only use case they want prevent is injecting ads into their app. But that could be better solved with a trademark.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by yreg on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:08PM (#37935437)
Doesn't seem like this is a settled debate at all.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by pbasista on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @01:28PM (#37931879)
> calling it open source when it is not

At first please define "open source".

1. Do you use this term as an alias for "The Open Source Definition" [0] as presented by the Open Source Initiative? In such case, the Grayjay project's license seems to not meet this definition.

2. Do you use it in a more general sense to mean any software whose source code is publicly available? In such case, the Grayjay project fully meets this definition.

[0] https://opensource.org/osd/

I would be very cautious to assume that the term "open source" must always and in all contexts be interpreted as having the meaning described by the definition 1.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by dre_bot on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:10PM (#37936543)
Christ, no one goddamn cares if it's open source or not! It's an app sourly needed right now.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by alexvoda on Thursday October 19, 2023 @04:24AM (#37940047)
Your statement is obliviously false. People care about different things.

Some people do not care about using pirated versions of Office.

Some people care very much about whether software is or isn't open source especially when it is claimed to be but isn't.

Being open source means that if FUTO goes bankrupt or is purchased or abandons GrayJay due to unprofitability or decides to pivot and become anti-user or etc. etc., then the app can be forked.

The current licences is so stupid that not only does it not allow forking, it actually does not allow using the app for it's intended purpose. This is egregious open-washing.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Lycake on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:14AM (#37926413)
Can't install, only ever get "Problem parsing the package" with the universal and the specific apk. What is the minimum required Android version? I'm still on 9
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by koen31 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:21AM (#37926458)
We are minimal SDK 29 right now (https://developer.android.com/tools/releases/platforms) we will look into lowering the requirement to Android 9, there seem to be quite a lot of requests for that.
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Lycake on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:31AM (#37926518)
Thank you. Not really surprising to see a lot of those request. A lot of the audience is coming from Louis at the moment. Seeing his ongoing fight for right to repair, I'd expect there to be a lot of people with older phones with older android versions
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by IYasha on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @10:17AM (#37929034)
So, I'm out of luck with by Android 5 and 8? :((((((
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Lycake on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:20AM (#37926454)
Some creators have already branched out and are posting some of their content to multiple platforms (maybe with different titles/thumbnails targeted for the specific platform). That would show up in my feed multiple times and I would have to click on each to find out I've already watched it. Do you try to deal with that in any way?
Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by koen31 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:53AM (#37926650)
Creators can create a polycentric identity and link their platforms together using the Harbor app. If you are then subscribed to their YouTube channel, you will also see content they post on any other platform like Patreon, etc.

You subscribe to the creator, not the platform identity.

There are also very simple dedup algorithms to try and deduplicate your feed. However, they can probably still be improved.

Re:Grayjay – Follow Creators Not Platforms by Sytten on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:23AM (#37926469)
For the plugin I would add an API to let the developer define user settings. For example look at what Xtra (https://github.com/crackededed/Xtra) offers for twitch. The most important is to be able to set a proxy to retrieve the feed in countries without ads and even bypass country geo-locks for content. Now I would probably not ship this in the official plugin, but my point is that you need to be able to expose those settings in the plugin.