News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by fastball on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:11AM (#37926069)
Marc Andreessen having a biased worldview is completely irrelevant to the quality of his arguments or positions, yet the implication in the TC article is exactly that (that maybe you shouldn't take his opinions about economics and technology too seriously because he's a billionaire after all).

Filippo Tommaso Marinetti is more well known as the founder of the Futurist movement, which is presumably what Andreessen is referencing here. Implying (or outright stating) that Marinetti's ideas on Futurism can be safely ignored because he also has less palatable ideas re:Fascism is a textbook example of Ad Hominem.

Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by chx on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:05AM (#37926364)
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by true_religion on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @05:11AM (#37926398)
Marinetti even tried to have futurism declared the state art of Italy, which would in effect suppress all other art styles.

In this case it seems his views were intertwined, at least in practical application. So it’s relevant to discuss both at the same time.

Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by surgical_fire on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:17AM (#37926788)
> Implying (or outright stating) that Marinetti's ideas on Futurism can be safely ignored because he also has less palatable ideas re:Fascism is a textbook example of Ad Hominem.

Except it is not. Or you have no idea of what Ad Hominem arguments are - i.e.: You attack the person instead of the arguments.

In the case of Marinetti, both his positions regarding Futurism and Fascism are intrinsically connected, sharing a noticeable relationship within his world view. To ignore the "less palatable" portion of his worldview to make Futurism more palatable would be faulty reasoning.

Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by fastball on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:24AM (#37926829)
Attacking a person's worldview is in fact attacking the person, not the arguments. The arguments being inextricably linked in Marinetti's head does not impact their validity outside his head.
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:53AM (#37927892)
As others have pointed out, even the futurist manifesto is highly problematic. That's what's outside his head - his arguments. And it's arguments that Andreessen is endorsing. So no, this is not an ad hominem.
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by surgical_fire on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @09:28AM (#37928365)
Absolutely not, when we are discussing the philosophical basis of that worldview.

Those arguments are not simply "linked in Marinetti's head". they are parts of a broader ser of views that would organize the world in a certain manner.

This is brought up due to an apparent endorsement of the author to Marinetti's ideas. Commenters pointing that out is absolutely not an Ad Hominem when those very ideas are being discussed.

I don't remember if there's an informal fallacy of falsely claiming an informal fallacy, but calling this an Ad Hominem is a great example of such.

Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by fastball on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @09:40AM (#37928518)
[delayed]
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by chx on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @10:40AM (#37929370)
I am happy to repeat myself: "should give you a new angle to investigate this bullshit from".

That's not "ignore this".

Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by chx on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:03PM (#37936478)
To elaborate a little, this thinkpiece will likely influence way more people than it should therefore understanding how it covertly spreads fascist ideas is important. Ignoring it doesn't make it go away.
Re:When was the last time Marc Andreessen talked to a poor p... by chx on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @09:44AM (#37928562)
Once again: I have called for investigating the influence of fascist ideas on this manifesto because the manifesto itself names one of the architects of it a saint. It doesn't matter at all who wrote this, we are only looking at the manifesto.

On another hand, trying to paint futurism and fascism as completely separate falls flat because already the Futurist Manifesto contained some ideas from fascism and besides Marinetti, Carlo Carrà and many more also became an ardest supporter of fascism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fortunato_Depero notes

> In the 1930s and 40s Depero continued working, although due to futurism being linked with fascism, the movement started to wane

In https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futurism

> Many Italian Futurists supported Fascism [...] The Futurists' association with Fascism after its triumph in 1922 brought them official acceptance in Italy

It's not like I am trying to mash the two together only now, no, they were already together back then.