News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there such a thing as the perfect game? by glimshe on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @02:38PM (#37919582)
I find backgammon extremely boring despite being fun in theory. I'm not saying it's a bad game, but it doesn't do anything for me versus a decent RPG, even an old one.

So I think the answer, as Betteridge's law would predict, is no.

Re:Is there such a thing as the perfect game? by Buttons840 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @02:49PM (#37919753)
Good ol' Betteridge, destroying fun conversations everywhere.

(There's a place to choose words carefully. Talking about games doesn't have to be one of them.)

As for RPGs. They're just backgammon, with more pieces, a bigger board, and some art. But yeah, I probably like a good RPG better than backgammon as well. But no RPG has lasted 5,000 years like backgammon has, so which game is better?

Re:Is there such a thing as the perfect game? by glimshe on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:03PM (#37923689)
Better to whom? I prefer RPGs. My criticism was aimed at the concept of "perfect game", that's why even a great game like Ocarina of Time isn't an unanimity.

RPGs aren't just backgammon, there has been innovations in game mechanics and the understanding of fun in the last several decades. For instance, idle games would be thought impossible a while back, yet they are probably more popular than backgammon among the youth. Idle games are not backgammon, in many of them there isn't even a way to lose.