News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by happytiger on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @08:56AM (#37914205)
This is, and the article points it out, the direct result of an excess number of managers and the explosion of management after the pandemic.

Silicon Valley was amazing because you could actually DO things and make an impact, but too much hiring added useless layers to the system. American management theory always tries to do this every tech cycle. That doesn’t work well with technical craft.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ot1138 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:09AM (#37914398)
Not only an excess number of managers, but an excess number of poorly performing and poorly trained engineers.

2018-2022 was peak shit eating time for managers. I had to put up with no end of candidates who couldn't pass even the easiest technical exams (and we intentionally made them easy to weed out only the pretenders). Candidates would ghost interviews and after receiving an offer, would lean on it for a higher salary for anyone else. They wanted $250-300k with just five years experience. It was the frothiest and least professional recruiting environment I had seen in 35 years.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:24AM (#37914641)
I seriously struggle to tell the difference between certain types of low quality candidates during interviews and people that just bounce around looking for the next shiny thing. I say this as a manager/developer/founder that comes from a very hands on background.

The obvious low quality candidate that is east to spot is the person that cannot answer the first question i always ask (write me a function, in any language, that takes an array of ints and returns the sum - half don’t ever pass this question the other 25% fail to consider or be able to discuss what might go wrong at runtime), the majority though sound very smart, can code, but put into a team just want to fixate on issues that serve zero value to the end user.

Oh and i should add, when you tell certain developer personas things like: youre not here to decide what problems to solve, youre here to solve the problems the product team wants solved (they think about this all day, let them do their jobs) they get all upset and moody. I always encourage other devs to speak up about solutions and opportunity but we need to let each player in the team do their position, if we try do it all then this stops being a team.

This to me feels like the reason we have a billion js frameworks and why no one wants to hand roll an api, but would rather fight with Apollo for hours. Being a developer has turned into a pseudo academic task, but with no interest in the process behind research.

It’s such a shitfest out there, and frankly, I’m pretty over managing these folks. I’ve been doing contract work for about 12 months now and it’s been a fresh experience that I’m hoping continues for a while to come.

Plug: if i sound like the kind of person you want helping with something feel free to ping me.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by xyzzy_plugh on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:38AM (#37914863)
I understand what you mean, and after several tours of duty across FAANGs and startups I think the bouncing-around tends to me less of an individual characteristic and more of a symptom of organizational dysfunction.

For startups, the landscape within a given role tends to vary drastically year over year. Some folks like being employee #10 but don't want to hang around past employee #20. Other folks like being employee #1000 but out of 2000 or 3000 feel overwhelmed. Organizations these days hire, especially where employment is at-will, with the expectation that their staff are fungible (they're not) and can be rearranged at the drop of a hat (which happens often).

One project can be a blast, and if the next one isn't then the grass is indeed often greener on the other side -- at least in our industry.

Some of my best hires have been folks who have never stuck around at previous places for more than 6-9 months over the course of several years. On the whole, it's all a total crapshoot.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:43AM (#37914916)
Your last sentence for me is it: total crapshoot.

Agreed, it’s so hard to tell. I try hire more for personality and general intelligence and assume we can teach process and new tools.

Historically I’ve attempted to tell developers what you said upfront, that some projects will suck but I’ll do my best to make sure you’re not always on the sucky work. I think managers often forget that cycling people in and out of fun roles is important for retention, just as is pay etc.

There is some value in expectation setting around “I’m not going to abandon you in the shit forever, but at times you’ll be in the shit and so will i, and i appreciate you sticking with me and will do everything i can to reward that”

Ted Lasso kinda stuff…but it’s not all worthless even if it doesn’t work 100% of the time.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by xyzzy_plugh on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:35AM (#37915770)
I have definitely noticed that fewer and fewer managers are fostering that type of relationship with their team. Seems like managers are doing the same, and hopping from ship to ship.

I've recently seen some managers totally throw folks under the bus -- otherwise very good folks too.

But otherwise I agree. The market has been quick to hire and fire which makes building and retaining talent difficult. The instability of the last several years has really left things in a seemingly universal bad state.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:49AM (#37916011)
That’s a good point. I guess this is just how it goes right now. I’ve found that retaining members on a team is the best hack for high performance. You need management bought into paying them well and giving you some autonomy around HR processes and what you work on, but if you can do it i believe the returns are real.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by happytiger on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:46AM (#37914976)
That is some deeply targeted recruiting my friend. ;)
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:48AM (#37915004)
Lol, yeah honestly wasn’t the plan but adding the plug felt like an opportune moment.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by uoaei on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:47AM (#37914983)
If I can be blunt, you sound like the kind of person who manages purely top-down and makes what could be an interesting and engaging workplace into corporate drudgery.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:49AM (#37915026)
And that’s kind of the point right? I mean, it’s very hard to be that honest and reflective with one’s self but everyone has their preferences of style, engagement tactics etc, and it’s very hard to get right.

I truly hope your impression isn’t reality but all i can say is in certain settings it’s worked great, in others it’s been meh. I’m subject to the same issues we all experience here.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by uoaei on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:57AM (#37915131)
I appreciate your candor and self-reflection. I want to encourage more of it.

I'm curious what you mean -- worked great for what aspect? Short-term bottom-line targets for the company at the expense of workers, or long-term culture-supported productivity ones that benefit both company and worker?

I suppose if you have a team of people who treat work as "doing homework for the rest of your life" (and quite a few SWEs never grow out of this mindset) then you can help them stunt their growth and extract whatever you want out of them for the company's sake. It's been my experience that typically the real movers and shakers need more than that to thrive, and they need to feel like they're thriving to stick around. I worked too long in a dessicated environment because the people who were insightful and good at their jobs were told to shut up and grind. They left for places where they could have more agency and feel like part of a team that values their input.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:10AM (#37915328)
All good, i try not take things too seriously. Appreciate your bluntness and curiosity.

Most of my career has been with early stage tech but I’ve also been in companies of thousands. I think I’m best cast in teams of 5-20 and I’ve found I’ve done well building good culture around working within the limits of what the business needs (realistic costing, time estimates, alignment to product vision) while finding ways to intertwine the quality developers want to see in their own work with the objectives of product and the leadership team.

I think to try put it in simpler terms, the best people want an environment where they can do their best work. The question i encourage people to ask themselves is if they actually know what that environment looks like? Often they have an idea of what’s worked best so far, but not what is optimal. I like having discussions around that as you can go from there to a) learn from their perspective and see if you can include part of that in the environment you’re presently operating under and b) determine if that’s a good near team goal or long term goal for the current environment and set realistic expectations with that individual as to not “bait and switch” them. I really see little point wasting someone’s time with promises of utopia when you’ve got a team that just isn’t working…that’ll end predictably.

I’ve said before my best skill has been building small teams of very bright people, retaining them and out performing larger teams. It’s pretty trivial to out perform larger teams if you can retain people, but to retain them they need to like what they’re doing and how they’re doing it.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by uoaei on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @01:51PM (#37918856)
I understand better, thanks. Initially I was reacting pretty strongly based on past traumatic managers but your approach centers the people you manage which sounds like a decent compromise between what the company needs and what the worker wants.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:48PM (#37924345)
Thanks for asking! Honestly I’m sure I’ve been that bad manager plenty of times, no one improves without making plenty of mistakes, unfortunately.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by art-not on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:18AM (#37915470)
I've found more and more recently that a lot of things I've thought to be a universally incorrect option often can work with the right person behind it. I don't think it's entirely hard to believe someone can executed a top-down management style well
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:26AM (#37915630)
Love this. So relatable. Keep this attitude please, and use it beyond your work life.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by myaccountonhn on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:43AM (#37926933)
I've worked in both, top-down and bottom-up + as a manager. I think both have their merits, and different people want/need different styles. For me, it was fun to be able to drive my own backlog, do my own discoveries, talk with stakeholders and feel like I really owned the product as well.

Now I work as an IC again at a more top-down place where I work fully remote and only 4 days a week. It's honestly quite nice to not have to talk to anyone and just wake up at 6am, have my task assigned, get it done and then go focus on my hobby projects/go hiking/exercise/spend time with my girlfriend. I don't have to be online 24/7 and I have maybe 2-3 meetings a week. The org sets the direction and we decide how to implement it. It works for me because in many ways I drive the requirements by telling the org what I need to execute properly. I can also still drive infrastructure improvements, and the org. is mature enough to prioritize them. I still grow, just in a different direction than I did as a manager. I get the chance to really focus on the technical parts of a solution.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by uoaei on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @11:46AM (#37930367)
> The org sets the direction and we decide how to implement it.

This is key.

"Good" managers can manage the expectations of the org to enforce this kind of relationship if the org wants to be pushy or micromanage-y. They insulate their team to create a real sense of agency and ownership. It's nice that your org makes your manager's job easy in this regard.

"Bad" managers are the opposite, they just dump the poorly-defined, poorly-justified demands onto their ICs. When they can't figure out why things aren't going well, they call for many hours of meetings with their ICs to hash out in detail how the implementation should proceed, which typically ends up being nothing more than the manager trying different ways of convincing their ICs to do it the way they already imagine it should go.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by floor2 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:00AM (#37915174)
> youre not here to decide what problems to solve, youre here to solve the problems the product team wants solved they get all upset and moody

Please be very up front that you hold this view when recruiting, it will be better for everyone. This may need to be an "agree to disagree" situation, but my experience goes completely the opposite direction of what you're suggesting here.

One of the biggest dysfunctions in tech over the last decade has been the rise of the product role and re-subjugation of engineers. We've recreated all the dysfunctions of the "pointy haired boss" just now with a PM title instead.

The 90s had the trope of incompetent business/managerial class folks being in charge and engineers being expected to do as they were told. Then in the 00s/10s there was a renaissance as engineer-founder companies (Google, Facebook, etc) elevated the status of developers and gave them increased autonomy and influence. This period saw technical innovation, business growth and increased wellness for employees.

In the past few years, the people who couldn't thrive as developers realized they could rebrand themselves as product managers and do all the fun parts of making things while leaving the difficult implementation work to developers. Unsurprisingly, the outcome is worse business behavior, worse customer experience, and burnt out developers who don't want to just be a cog in a machine building someone else's idea.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by happytiger on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:14AM (#37915412)
This is exactly correct. We have seen “market maturity” which basically means “tech companies are now run on modern management theory” and that theory, frankly, is wrong.

Open doors, frank discussions, flat hierarchy, hacking culture, planning at the edge, and personal relationships all took a dive. Performance plans, recruiters, mid-level managers, central planning and product management overuse exploded.

Somewhere around 2014-2017 working in a tech company started to be indistinguishable from working in any other Enterprise.

Now a lot of that seems to be the result of all the pioneers leaving the industry and the settlers arriving. There was a point around 2012-13 where Ivy League grads stopped going to McKinsey and started going to the valley, and they brought all their management theory with them.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by jjav on Saturday October 21, 2023 @02:12AM (#37964499)
> Somewhere around 2014-2017 working in a tech company started to be indistinguishable from working in any other Enterprise.

That's because the definition changed. Silicon Valley used to be tech companies, that meant companies whose product was tech.

That's no longer the case. The so-called tech companies do not sell technology anymore. Sure they use tech internally, but that's every enterprise ever. So working at them is indeed just a boring non-tech enterprise job.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:16AM (#37915439)
I have said similar things to a few replies but i really think it’s less simple and there being one way that works.

I’m sure the agree to disagree works sometimes but my experience is we need to trust people to do their job, and if we cannot, we need to move on without them.

This isn’t to say we will disagree and not find a way to live with it. I more mean, the ideal outcome is that the mind of developers and product staff are tightly aligned. If they’re not, that’s going to be a constant source of friction that’ll slow down everything about product development.

I personally believe (and maybe bias is showing now) that a lot of the best ideas come out of the people closest to the code. It’s often easy to spot opportunity as a developer, but we need to not discount the work good product people out into user research and market research.

Neither alone is sufficient, but the teams have to work together to get the idealized outcomes.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ryandrake on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @01:01PM (#37918083)
>> youre not here to decide what problems to solve, youre here to solve the problems the product team wants solved they get all upset and moody

> Please be very up front that you hold this view when recruiting, it will be better for everyone. This may need to be an "agree to disagree" situation, but my experience goes completely the opposite direction of what you're suggesting here.

Also, there are both types of companies out there! There are places where "engineering" means "implement what the Product Manager dreams up" and other places where it means "you define the product and implementation." Find the company that works best for your expectations. Some people like having a PM do all the ideation and just sit back and program what's in the requirements doc. Others feel put in a box in that environment. Both types of companies exist.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by verelo on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:45PM (#37924336)
I beg to differ, well, at least i beg to add a 3rd option. I like to subscribe to the thinking that the PM owns the decision but the best outcomes are made when they work closely with, and often take a lot of input from, the developers.

At the end of the day the reason i say i like this model is because i want ownership from a product group, and likewise no development team wants PMs prescribing to them how to structured the database or what language to choose. So ultimately, this division of responsibility is kind of a logical divide, to ensure we see where each other operates and let the developers have input but also their own area of ownership without taking away the ownership the product people bring to the table.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by jjav on Saturday October 21, 2023 @02:09AM (#37964483)
> One of the biggest dysfunctions in tech over the last decade has been the rise of the product role and re-subjugation of engineers.

This is absolutely correct. Although your timeline is a bit off.

In the 80s and 90s there was no such thing as a product manager. At least, I never met or heard of one. If any existed, they were rare as hens teeth.

Engineering was driven by engineering. Thus craftsmanship mattered and it was a very fulfilling job. Engineers were expected to define the product and had the authority and responsibility to do it.

The PMs started to appear in the 00s and spread like wildfire in the 2010s. Now they almost outnumber engineering. Engineers own nothing and are expected to like it.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by eddtries on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:19AM (#37914559)
This, I swear I had people interviewing for senior roles who couldn't FizzBuzz. I don't give LeetCode challenges to people but I do give them the first Project Euler problem which is summing ints that are divisible by 3 or 5 with the incredibly complex edge case of only adding numbers divisible by both values, aka 15, once. There was someone who applied who was really struggling so I hinted at modulo, then they mentioned they didn't really like to use if/else branches to avoid complex code.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by geodel on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:47AM (#37914988)
> with the incredibly complex edge case of only adding numbers divisible by both values, aka 15

Ah I love it, you are pushing them to reach peak human potential.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by corimaith on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:38AM (#37915819)
As a new grad who's currrently in the job market I have to say my experience is contrary to this. Pretty much every OA I've received from companies including non-tech companies like big banks are all asking pretty complex stuff such as writing a LRU Cache, Dynamic Progamming, etc. Most of these questions I would have had no idea how to do in the time allocated if I hadn't studied their specific patterns beforehand. Expectations are sky high, and it's only getting worse as time passes on.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by eddtries on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:49AM (#37916007)
I had to face that grind when I was younger too, but I swore I'd never ask a question someone shouldn't be able to work out on the spot under the stress of an interview. My strategy is to take that question and expand on it in a fun way - touching different topics the candidate feels comfortable with. Make it concurrent? Solve it in the type system with Peano numbers? Etc... To me, tech is fun and I try to make the interview and fun and interactive as possible! But it does also help keep people out who literally can't code, which somehow still pass previous rounds.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by op00to on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:22AM (#37914614)
Allow me to play the tiniest violin for you. Funny how the tables have turned and you don't seem to mention the absolute unprofessionalism coming from recruiters who offer jobs and rescind them after candidates relocate, perform layoffs to pad the bottom line, and ghost the everliving fuck out of candidates like it's their job.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by j45 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:29AM (#37914736)
The only such thing as job security is the job security that one creates for themselves.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by happytiger on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:51AM (#37915047)
There is no job security even then. Only wealth frees you.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by j45 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @04:02PM (#37920772)
Yup, starting with earnings/revenue as a person or saas and ultimately what you keep/save
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by j45 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @04:04PM (#37920791)
Downvotes are welcome but lots of research out there.

Financial literacy opens up more than one way for something to be true.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ot1138 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @05:07PM (#37921575)
I've never once heard of a recruiter rescinding an offer after a relocation. Not once in 35 years.

Recruiters also don't dictate layoffs. This is a function of Finance and layoffs are a part of life.

And it is extremely rare for a recruiter to ghost a candidate. I don't recall ever hearing this happen, though I imagine it's possible under rare circumstances.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ravenstine on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:00AM (#37915173)
I agree that it comes down to both poor management and poorly performing/trained engineers, but I've also seen a TON of dysfunction created by engineers that are perceived as competent. I'm not sure whether you might have actually been referring to that, but I'll continue assuming I'm referring to something slightly different.

At nearly every company I've worked for, there's usually an "inner-circle" of highly regarded staff engineers whom are considered to be always correct by both management while the rest of engineering are treated by both groups as peons. On first glance, this might seem like a normal dynamic that occurs in any hierarchy based on competency and experience. Indeed, some people will be given more say than others because reasons. That's okay. What's not okay is when the gap between the inner-circle and the peons is so hollowed out that there's virtually no power structure to keep the inner-circle in check. I've seen this first-hand and second-hand when a company chooses its inner-circle based on a combination of nepotism, whomever has been around the longest, and whether an engineer has some kind of name for themselves outside of the company. It's not that these factors can't or shouldn't be a part of the equation, but they lead to rampancy when competency isn't thoroughly checked. Just because a person is vouched for doesn't mean they should be handed the "key to the city", and neither does whether the person stuck around and managed to survive every layoff, or whether they have a well-known blog or are considered a guru in some web framework. By that "key", I mean the metaphorical one they are given that allows them to dictate every level of engineering process, which sometimes goes as far as forcing every engineer to use the same IDE. Maybe they can have that key once they've proven themselves at the present company, but not merely because someone has an existing opinion about them. When a company gives their inner-circle way too much power and makes the rest of their engineers peons, this is where developer experience can decline and the amount of wasted resources increases.

Most of the problems I've seen that make work a nightmare for engineers isn't even caused by management. Management notoriously asks unrealistic things of engineers, and this is a pain to deal with, but I've hardly ever seen this impossible to work with; it's the nature of the beast for engineers, more or less. The breakdown in engineer performance, from what I've seen, comes from the amount of bullshit that inner-circles add to the engineering process in order to solve problems. What the "staff" engineers whom are part of these inner-circles often fail to consider is that every link you add to the chain adds a new opportunity for the chain to break. This is engineering 101, but too many engineers with godlike clout either fail to consider it or pretend that it's not a problem. Maybe it's cognitive dissonance, or maybe it's ego. The rationalization is usually the idea that all of these checks and "standards" will protect the codebase in some way.

Whatever the case, what we get are these humongous toolchains just to build a fucking JavaScript application that runs in a browser. What we get are CI tasks that randomly break because someone believed that a bajillion tests relying on third party services would reduce the amount of bugs. What we get are tests that run incredibly slow and are unpredictable. What we get is outdated documentation because someone in the inner-circle thought it was a great idea to host the documentation as a full website, and of course only they have the knowledge and ability to deploy that thing. What we get are engineers frequently making "mistakes" and holding up code review because there's constantly new "best practices" being silently handed down by inner-circle engineers who want to write code and can't be bothered communicating effectively. What we get are so many lint rules, checks, and pre-commit hooks frequently added and modified that the engineers outside the inner-circle are afforded no creativity and must spend extra time fixing errors that aren't even real errors with the code, but are errors based on someone's opinion.

Ultimately, more time is spent fixing self-inflicted issues and far less time delivering value to customers. And software isn't even better today. I've spotted more glaring problems with both websites and native apps in 2023 than any other year prior. The quality of our output is a joke, but the world has accepted that all software is broken.

The best thing tech companies can do is to break up their inner-circles of genius engineers, separate the wheat from the chaff, hire staff engineers who are averse to adding complexity, and give power back to the rest of their engineers. Engineering shouldn't be a combination of bureaucracy and implementing demands in the form of code; engineering should be about working on real problems. As an example, frequently baffling your engineers with uninformative errors caused by a custom in-house syntax transpiler that only one or two people seem to understand is not solving a real problem. That's called bullshit.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by moandcompany on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:22AM (#37915558)
What you call bullshit, they call job security :)
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by JKCalhoun on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:02AM (#37914289)
From my experience that started long before the pandemic.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by davidivadavid on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:38AM (#37914859)
Hacker News really is like clockwork. Random "tech" industry problem? Gotta be "managers" or "designers." Engineers can do no wrong.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by stuff4ben on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:40AM (#37914880)
Engineers do the work to make the magic happen. Too much middle management adds fat and gets in the way of work getting done. I say this as a GenXer who has been on both sides and is currently an engineer again. I have no beef with designers.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by robertakarobin on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:46AM (#37914973)
They're not mutually exclusive. Plenty of managers have engineering backgrounds. What is generally mutually exclusive is managers and individual contributors. It may be that if individual contributors did all the decision-making then the outcome would be different; it may be that it would be exactly the same. We can't really know, for the same reason we can't know how society would be different if we elected "normal people" to Congress instead of "politicians."
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by happytiger on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @10:05AM (#37915244)
Engineers do plenty wrong. But they typically don’t lead the effort, they implement the ideas and plans of designers and managers. So tradition in society is to put the burden of success or failure at the feet of those who do the planning.

If you have someone buying the wrong seeds or not ordering fertilizer on time, it makes all the work on the farm a failure.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by gargs on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:05AM (#37914337)
I have to wonder how much of this middle management heavy organizational structure was introduced by cultures that place undue significance to 'becoming a manager' in computing success in profession.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by Zetobal on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:07AM (#37914365)
My team is full of it. People that needed to be catered with useless titles just to retain them. We have like 40 Head of XYZ for 10 Senior Devs, it's insanity. The thing is they don't even care about the money if they get a fancy title they would do it for the same money.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by wildrhythms on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:27AM (#37914699)
I am an engineer and I will work on a project from conceptualization to production and there are a dozen 'Project managers' and 'Program managers' who come out of the woodwork to take credit at launch. I've never seen them in a single meeting. What the hell do they do?
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by jasonlotito on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:17AM (#37914536)
People are optimizing for what the businesses value. If you make these titles attractive, why wouldn't you expect people to optimize for them? It's not the people's fault; it's the company leadership. Couple that with companies that don't care about the employees, of course, titles will matter. Say what you want, but someone with only a history of Junior Engineer on their CV will get looked at differently when they have to find a new job.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:21AM (#37914606)
> If you make these titles attractive, why wouldn't you expect people to optimize for them?

There is a cultural component to it, and it travels. People coming from a corporate culture attach value to these titles in a way we traditionally did not in Silicon Valley. The interesting thing is seeing how they then breathe power into those words; I remember one senior-ish person who proceeded to attempt pulling rank on her peers on the back of the new title. In most cases, it didn't work. But in some cases, it did, including with people who were otherwise insensitive to titles.

My broad takeaway is trading titles for money is a deal with the devil. Eventually, the thing you're giving away gains animation.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by jasonlotito on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:37AM (#37914851)
I agree. But the mentality of SV is essentially winner take all. People talk a good game, but everyone is really out for themselves. You see this all the time here on HN, this mentality. Everyone is happy to deal with the devil.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by zeroCalories on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @12:51PM (#37917926)
I don't think that's the case. I think there is an aspect of shame if you don't get increasingly senior roles as you advance in a career. The pay is secondary for these people.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:12AM (#37914435)
> how much of this middle management heavy organizational structure was introduced by cultures that place undue significance to 'becoming a manager'

Big teams need management. Small teams, less so. The largest tech companies are larger today than ever before. And there are more tech companies above virtually any threshold now than there were then. It follows that the average person in tech now works at a larger company than previously.

The number of people in small start-ups may be larger than ever before. But, because of the distribution, they're outnumbered still by those in large organizations that require bureaucracy to stay aligned.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by mikrl on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:52AM (#37915054)
My previous employer was so top heavy it was unreal.

I counted maybe 4-5 managers with some variation of Director/VP of Software/Engineering/SWE/SWEProject and yet more kept getting promoted into that echelon over my time there, with no clear indication of what most of them did. For a 400 person operation that did two giant layoffs.

On my end though, management was worse than useless and did absolutely none of the things that good managers I’ve had previously (or subsequently) have done.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bionhoward on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:15AM (#37914492)
I’m honestly shocked by the number of non technical people “managing” software projects. If you can’t run the system on your machine, then how the heck do you even know if it’s done or not? Honestly, TDD ought to be a fundamental everyday skill requirement for managers.

If you want to clean house at your company to improve profitability and productivity, then just go around to every manager in charge of a software project and ask them to show you the code for the e2e test and run it. Anyone who can’t do that doesn’t belong in a leadership position. Manager implies leader implies knowing the fundamentals.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by op00to on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:26AM (#37914678)
I'm confused. I would call my QA manager and ask them to show me, if I was in the situation you state and needed that information. Why would someone who's managing a large project be specifically skilled in the specialized actions of a Quality Engineer?
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by wildrhythms on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:28AM (#37914727)
I believe the manager should at least know how to do the job of the people whose work they oversee... how else would you possibly check the quality of the work? Lol
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by davzie on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:36AM (#37914843)
Well, as a thought experiment; should the CEO of the company know how to do every function he or she hires for within their business?
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by curt15 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:42AM (#37914906)
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ghaff on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:51AM (#37917011)
That's specifically software--which is his background. However, while I have no doubt he had and has some high-level familiarity with finance, marketing, and other functions that reported to him as CEO, he probably didn't have the level of deep operational knowledge of those areas that the people hired specifically for those roles did.

I have no doubt he could learn them. He's a smart guy. But the idea that he could drop into any job at Microsoft and excel on Day One is silly.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by throwaway38475 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:44AM (#37914948)
I worked in construction prior to tech and yes, the General Contractor or Foreman may not know the latest in framing or concrete technology, or even be good at specific tasks like drywall. But they understand the job, can do it if need be, but most importantly can judge the quality.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by nine_zeros on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:45AM (#37914965)
> Well, as a thought experiment; should the CEO of the company know how to do every function he or she hires for within their business?

No, but they should at least know how to do the job of their SVPs or VPs in their absence. In fact, many times when the SVP departs, their reports are expected to report to the CEO directly.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bee_rider on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:03AM (#37916250)
But if the job of the SVP and VP includes being able to do the job of the people that report to them then doesn’t this require the CEO to ultimately know how to do everything?
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by svnt on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:22AM (#37916564)
Role competency and the ability to assess role competency are two different skills.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by nine_zeros on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:18AM (#37916506)
There is a depth first and a breadth first traversal aspect to it. Which is why a skilled CEO, presents themselves as a backstop, but simultaneously starts the hunt for a new SVP or an interim SVP.

But even appointing someone new for that role will require the CEO to understand that role very well. They truly can't appoint someone competent in that role without being competent themselves.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bee_rider on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:38AM (#37916825)
A DFS and a BFS both visit every (connected) node, haha.

I don’t think the original comment was saying that it is crucial for somebody to fill in for their reports (that might be true, but it is a different aspect). Rather, they were saying that the manager’s skill set must include the skill-set of the person being managed, in order to evaluate the latter.

I think there’s some truth to this, but there’s also obviously got to be some attenuation factor going on, otherwise we get this “visit every node” problem.

The suggestion of firing every manager that can’t run the test suite seems like it ignores this attenuation factor. It might be a set of command line scripts with funky in-house flags. But they should be able to draw some some of useful conclusions from the output IMO.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bionhoward on Saturday October 21, 2023 @08:27AM (#37966248)
No, the CEO needs to know how to clone the repo, read and write E2E test code (basically usage examples), and run the “make test” or whatever to check their (the managers’) E2E tests are running and which properties pass or fail. Otherwise, the “non technical” manager is unwilling (not incapable…just too lazy) to understand the definition of “done” so they’ll be clueless about if the thing is working or not, they’ll be forced to play telephone to add a simple test expectation and then they need to have a meeting to beg someone else to write a function. That’s a leech, not a leader!
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by op00to on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:53AM (#37915069)
A QA manager understands that far better than I would. I would communicate with the QA manager.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bethekind on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:37AM (#37916803)
I think managers should be able to have meaningful discussions with people one, two and even three levels below them.

If they're out of touch with the layfolk or can't detect when the people reporting to them are too optimistic/pessimistic, it'll cause issues down the road.

Ol' musky boi has been known to talk to low level engineers and ignore in betweens to understand issues better

Nvidia boss has been known to take reports from people way lower in the chain.

Both have been known to do a decent job in directing these large orgs directions faster than most.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by mc32 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:23AM (#37914629)
It could also just be part of an industry maturing.

Competition has picked all the low hanging fruit and it’s all more or less become another commodity industry.

There was also the switch from people who were naturally attracted to SW Feb, CS and EE, to now people who specifically pursue the industry for the perks and not because they’re into it. I think this started about 2005 or so as things became inflated. The dotcom boom certainly perked the ears of many new college freshmen back then and they eventually entered the workforce.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by adra on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:34AM (#37914805)
Nah, as someone who popped into the industry around 2k, a bunch of people bounced out of IT never to return either during or shortly after 2000. To me, its fely a little frothy since ~2010 but this is clearly a subjective approximation. I'm sure a historical compensation chart will show when salaries started to grow precipitous and with them those keen for big wages followed.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by ghaff on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#37917334)
Around 2010 is about the right date. Things had picked back up in tech by 2005/6 approximately but, by then, as you say a fair number of people had just left the industry or never entered it. And, of course, the great recession was not that far in the future.

I was laid off right after 9/11 and I was very lucky that someone I knew who owned a very small company was still doing OK and they hired me; certainly I wasn't getting so much as a nibble anywhere else. (They did end up struggling but I was still there for a decently long time, albeit at an unexceptional salary.)

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by Eumenes on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @09:55AM (#37915099)
I've noticed this big time post pandemic. I'm seeing EMs with < 4-5 years of experience who are managing engineers with 10-15+ years of experience. These are quite frankly, kids, and it really shows. They could really use more time behind a keyboard.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by bee_rider on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:12AM (#37916391)
This is the result of telling everybody that they will be screwed and unemployable if they get a humanities degree: a bunch of people who aren’t technical at all have struggled through STEM degrees out of fear. Oops, there goes that signal.

They don’t need more time behind the keyboard, we as a society need to figure out how to provide middle class lifestyles to people who aren’t good behind the keyboard.

I mean we’re talking about careers that will start building generational wealth, it is not surprising that people will do whatever they need to get in.

Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by Eumenes on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:25AM (#37916604)
Idk if this trend of ICs being rapidly promoted into management has to do with humanity degrees or generational wealth. If anything, I find these individuals to be well off and from respectable schools. It reminds me more of the hustle and career driven attitude of the finance and MBA world, where the prestige is centered in having high # of direct reports, or lofty titles.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by jmopp on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @12:58PM (#37918025)
People underestimate the value of a humanities degree. The point of studying literature or art history is not to study literature or art history, it's to study how people operate from an emotional point of view, and see how the way people acted on their feelings in the past influenced the present. That's a pretty good background to have if you're going to be a people manager. Despite what we like to believe, we are not rational creatures.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by Eumenes on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @03:31PM (#37920371)
Yeah having art history majors manage engineering projects is how you get Boeing 737 MAX disasters. Perhaps okay if you're developing a mobile app or dating website but mission critical and real world scenarios, we should be striving for excellence.
Re:Working in Silicon Valley was fun. Now it's just another ... by icedchai on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @11:57AM (#37917090)
So true. I love going on calls and discovering there are more "managers" than actual ICs. Does anyone around here do any work? The pandemic created a layer of professional meeting attenders that talk a bunch and do very little.