I think WeWork is a great example. That market did need some freshening up and maybe even some full blown disruption, as the incumbents weren’t delivering a modernized co-working experience attractive to young professionals.
But the founder took a great idea way too far, mistaking a straightforward office subleasing business for a cultural movement that could change the way people live and work en-masse.
It’s that founders’ hubris of “I invented the next iPhone and the world will never be the same again.”
But the great irony, given that WeWork might collapse at any moment (or already has?) is that it would probably be a great idea to start that right now or in the next year or so, as CBRE prices collapse and people increasingly look for cheap temporary and part time offices
I would argue that it was a poor idea that was greatly executed.
Everything was great for a while due to execution. But, when the realities or should I say limitations of the poor idea caught up, everything came crashing down.
When I say poor idea, I don't mean bad business in general, but a poor idea for the valuation, investment, growth etc. that was projected. They did not make sense, but investors still threw money at it, which is where the initial great execution comes into picture.
They executed very well initially, showed a lot of growth, acquired a lot of properties, got the buzz, kinda became cool, brand became very well known, etc. But, it soon hit the wall into how much that kind of business can grow, since as you mentioned, Regus has been doing this for a while and does not have anywhere near the valuation that WeWork was able to command.
But, how do you define execution? When does it begin and end? Isn't initial traction, growth, large investment still part of execution.
Let me clarify I never used WeWork till recently, never invested in it or anything and don't like the guy. But I have to give credit where it is due. He (and his team), did build a business and raise shit ton on money. Not everyone with the same idea could have done that.
Hell he even conned A16Z for his next startup, no idea what is going on with that one.
So, even if we thing that he's a con man, which he probably is, he's good at conning people, which is execution.
I don't need to take this further than this. I have no stake in WeWork, but thought I'd still clarify my comment above. I think we're just looking at it differently.
I suspect he knew it was near pyramid scheme when their valuation had 9 zeros
If Softbank are throwing money around, the rational thing is to build as big a net as possible to catch it. If that happens to involve free beer in offices then so be it.
People push for the billonaire option because it’s plausible if they have a revenue machine growing 2x every year and investors behind them. It’s likely their one shot at it.
In business there's the subtle art of keeping expectations and results in healthy alignment. I think there's more pressure to avoid having too little investment than too much, but both can kill you. And it's SO brutal on morale when doubling revenue feels like a failure because 5x was the wildly-unrealistic demand of your pretend valuation.
The founders $5m turnover business success is then relatively a failure at $30m and they are unceremoniously booted out.
"From an entrepreneur’s standpoint, it’s easy to become engrossed in the thrill of securing funding, expanding the team, and growing the business. Yet, more growth doesn’t always equal a better business. Some markets just aren’t that big. Some markets take longer to develop. Furthermore, personal priorities evolve, and one’s perspective on opportunities can shift over time. And, every round of funding shifts the goal posts further out. "