Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by morelisp on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:11PM
(#37891516)
I think if you had automatic interpretation, removing much of the financial incentive to learn it, and even likely a large portion of the social incentive, far fewer people would learn it.
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by aldebran on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:42PM
(#37891747)
I’m confused. Is the statement that people learn ASL for money and some social kudos?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by techsupporter on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:43PM
(#37891752)
I'm not sure I understand; why would automatic interpretation reduce the incentive to learn ASL?
I learned ASL, as a hearing person, to be able to communicate with deaf friends anywhere and with my (hearing) spouse and other friends in noisy or large places. It's also a hedge against my future potential hearing loss from tinnitus.
Automatic interpreting wouldn't solve any of those and neither it nor automated captions take the place of human-understood interpreting. I think putting ASL in something like VR where it is more visible to the hearing world might broaden its reach?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by morelisp on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:57PM
(#37902768)
You think if you make it a less commercially viable skill and make it easier to communicate with deaf people without learning it, more people will learn it? Or even the same number of people?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by tempodox on Sunday October 15, 2023 @02:08PM
(#37891934)
Yep, where is “AI” when you need it?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 15, 2023 @02:19PM
(#37892034)
What would be the advantage of ASL over speech recognition for VR?
I suppose if you were on an airplane you could avoid disturbing other passengers, but I don't expect many people to actually use VR on airplanes.
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by pjerem on Sunday October 15, 2023 @02:37PM
(#37892170)
And using VR in planes will be strange enough for at least some years to not add moving your arms in all directions strange.
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by jerska on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:00AM
(#37897287)
Stranger than speaking out loud with your headset on?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by Wowfunhappy on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:18AM
(#37897410)
Well, if you're on an airplane, you could do neither of those things and just watch a movie.
And if you're not out in public, you can use speech recognition more easily than learning ASL.
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by zamalek on Sunday October 15, 2023 @05:45PM
(#37893675)
The format of ASL is better suited for spatial problems. Speaking is one dimensional, it occurs at your mouth.
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 15, 2023 @08:41PM
(#37894761)
Could you please describe an example?
Re:Signtime.apple: One-on-one sign language interpreting by ...
by jakefromstatecs on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:50PM
(#37907162)
ASL recognition is an insanely difficult problem to solve because it requires solving hand, finger, and arm pose estimation with occlusion, which hasn't even been properly solved in VR, let alone through webcams.
As a bonus more people would learn ASL.