News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by bee_rider on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:48PM (#37850683)
Did the Amiga 500 have better graphics than the PCs of the early 90’s? Because those graphics look a bit better than Wolfenstein 3D.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by HappyDaoDude on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:58PM (#37850789)
For 2D stuff definitely, but that was because of some neat dedicated graphics processor and a fixed platform for developers to target. The Amiga range in that sense was WAY beyond others in terms of audio/visuals when it came out. In that sense it was closer to the home consoles than a typical PC.

It led to the odd situation where you had PC's that had these killer CPU's but everything else about the system was holding them back. The Amiga had an average CPU (8Mhz 68K) but everything else was picking up a lot of slack.

As for this example, this is exceptionally good for the Amiga. I don't recall there being anything even remotely close to this in its time. Hackers are just gonna optimise way beyond reason and I love it.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:12PM (#37850967)
Are hackers optimizing? Or are they writing the same code they always did but now code-generation targeting these platforms is optimizing?
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by tuukkah on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:41PM (#37851304)
There isn't much the compiler can optimize on such a simple CPU as the m68k when the source is simple C or hand-optimized assembler code to begin with.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by mike_hock on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @07:20PM (#37851634)
Contemporary compilers definitely do a lot of CPU-agnostic optimizations that ye olde compilers weren't capable of. The only new CPU features that fundamentally change this are vector instructions, and compilers still suck at autovectorization.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by gpderetta on Thursday October 12, 2023 @06:41AM (#37855488)
Contemporary compilers are "optimized" to optimize for superscalar, fully pipelined, out of order cpus with plenty of ram and caches. Literally nothing in common with a 68k. Also modern compilers wouldn't even know how to produce code for the amiga coprocessors.

This engine very likely is written in hand optimized, clock-exact, asm.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by alxmdev on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:26PM (#37851129)
Tooling and code generation improvements no doubt help a lot, but IMO those improvements must be coupled with creative manual optimizations in order to get something like this out of a platform that was tailored for rectangular 2D bitmaps.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:34PM (#37851213)
It's extremely impressive in any case.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by ekianjo on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:21PM (#37851076)
Optimization and hardware tricks
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by wk_end on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @08:13PM (#37852018)
This was almost definitely written in asm, no code generation involved.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by tom_ on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @09:52PM (#37852596)
They are optimizing, probably. Thanks to the internet, knowledge sharing is substantially simplified compared to the 1990s, and it's massively easier to find people to collaborate with. Hard to understate how difficult it was to find useful info back in the day.

Additionally, anybody that grew up coding on the Amiga has had 30, 35 years to think about it since! - and they are probably still young enough (or, more accurately, probably not yet properly old enough...) that time has, for now, added more to their abilities than it has taken away.

And: modern PCs are ridiculously fast! A table or routine that would have taken your Amiga days to produce, even assuming you'd have considered the idea feasible in the first place ("b-but - you'd need a temporary 512 MByte table for that!!") can be generated in 5 minutes with some python code on your 10 year old laptop.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by Zardoz84 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @06:00AM (#37855243)
The IBM PC (and clones) at the time of launch of the Amiga 500, had at best an 80286 at 6 to 12Mhz . I would call it roughly equivalent CPU with the 68000 at 8Mhz (16 bit segmented addressing vs 16/32bit hybrid with planar ram addressing)
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by HappyDaoDude on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:12PM (#37865307)
At launch definitely was a decent little performer. That said, the 386 was probably launched shortly afterwards as well. The funny thing is that it wasn't until almost the mass adoption of high speed 386's and the 486 in the early 90's that we finally saw a lot of stuff that over took things the Amiga and SNES for that matter. A big part of that was VGA graphics via the VESA bus. The ISA bus did a lot to hold back video out put on these systems. Graphics was almost an afterthought by comparison.

I mean things like Commander Keen were considered really decent for side scrolling graphics on PC but would be seen as trivial on a system like the Amiga and maybe even the NES using early 80's tech. It was a long time until the PC could scroll graphics as smoothly as the NES could with Super Mario in 1985. Custom ASIC designs just had to so leverage back then. It is something we are moving back into nowadays with chiplet designs and SoC's in general. Just look at the processor blow outs on something like the M1/M2 to see this.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by actionfromafar on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:54PM (#37850736)
Yes and no. It's complicated. For textured 3D games, even with 256 colors, the PCs with VGA were better. Wolfenstein catered to EGA, with 16 colors.

For smooth frame synced 2D games (no lag, no jitterynes, no tearing) Amiga was hands down better, but those kinds of games were falling out of style in the early 90s.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by mysterydip on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:17PM (#37851025)
You may be thinking of catacomb 3D, which was a predecessor and EGA
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by spitfire on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:57PM (#37850782)
Wolfenstein was mode 13h 256 VGA colour.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by quadcore on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:13PM (#37850982)
Certainly it was mode X rather.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by polpo on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @07:27PM (#37851694)
Just looked at the Wolf3D source (https://github.com/id-Software/wolf3d/tree/master/WOLFSRC) - it uses VGA in unchained mode but still at 320x200. So not exactly Mode X, but "Mode Y".
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by bluescrn on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:30PM (#37851174)
The Amiga really struggled to handle Wolfenstein/Doom clones due to the layout of it's video memory making if even harder for the already-slow CPU. The chips that made it great at 2D games held it back at 3D.

This new engine is an absolute masterpiece of Amiga coding. The many mid-90s attempts to do similar things tended to need more powerful Amigas (at least an A1200, preferably with an 030 or better accelerator card and extra RAM) for less impressive results.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by johnnyworker on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @10:33PM (#37852869)
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by dabeeeenster on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:53PM (#37850728)
Yeah they did at the time for sure. When the A500 was released PC games were generally CGA/EGA. The A500 was way ahead of its time, especially when you account for how much they cost.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by bee_rider on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @09:00PM (#37852298)
What really impressed me is that I was born around the same time as the A500 but I remember playing PC games that looked worse than this, hahaha.

Part of it is surely that I was using hand-me-down PCs and there was probably some time lag on the games that my dad would get through the sneaker-net.

The art style is also really solid and modern which I’m sure helps hide some of the limitations.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by markmark on Thursday October 12, 2023 @12:57AM (#37853592)
Around the time I got my A500, my neighbour's dad bought a PC that ran California Games in CGA at about one frame per second. I'm sure there were much better PCs available, but it didn't impress us kids much. They _did_ have Leisure Suit Larry though...
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by rasz on Thursday October 12, 2023 @07:24PM (#37864485)
Sounds like something like Amstrad PC1512 - ~$100 cheaper than Amiga 500, cheaper even that Atari 520ST with mono monitor.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by ekianjo on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:20PM (#37851063)
Until Wing Commander came out, mostly yes.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by bitwize on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @10:06PM (#37852689)
The Amiga smoked PCs when it came out. PCs didn't really come into their own until the 486 became commonplace, but once it did the Amiga was struggling to keep up, games-wise. For example, the PC port of Mortal Kombat was the most arcade-accurate home port of any system. The Amiga port was nearly, but not quite, as good.
Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by simne on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @10:50PM (#37852977)
Yes and no. PCs from beginning was very simple business machines, for accounting, but later benefited from free market and cheap clones.

As for me, VGA was wonder, I now think from marketing considerations, PCs way was to make Super-EGA, with little colors, but high resolution. But, sometimes wonders happen.

Amigas, or to be more exact, Commodore computers, from beginning made as home computers, with decent integrated graphics and sound.

Unfortunately, Amiga parent company was very aggressive against clones, and from what I hear, was not effectively managed (or may be, just tried to made too complex architecture). So after some time, initial superiority was lost, and PCs not just dominated market, but also, once become better technically (because of constant competition on free market).

Approx after 1987-middle 1990s, Amiga become technically lagged behind forever, then parent company bankrupt and now, each year, Amigas become more history artifacts.

Re:Grind – A first person shooter for Amiga 500 by badpun on Thursday October 12, 2023 @04:11AM (#37854668)
Notice the large black borders around the gameplay area. That's due to hardware being too weak to render the game on entire screen.