Even if you assume that the only thing Linux has to offer is graphical windowing environments; there are a lot of other enviornments besides gnome/unity...
Xfce, awesome, kde, xmonad, lxde, fvwm95(joke), etc....
https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/38/windows-alt-tab/
https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/97/coverflow-alt-tab/
Au contraire, I now consider gnome usable for the first time. The fact that apps didn't really exist but as a collection of individual windows drove me crazy.
Note that I'm not arguing against having an app concept or a "switch app" action. The problem is killing the "switch window" action.
Of course, so much more was gained, the point of no return has long been reached ;-) Now the question, to Gnome 3 or not to Gnome 3?
Am I going to freak out as a gnome-do + compiz + dual monitor (laptop + external) user, or, with time, one adjusts, and, like an arranged marriage, learns to love the other?
That's putting it mildly. A split menu may be correct from some design point of view (e.g DRY principle) but from a usability point of view, it's recipe for frustration.
On a more general note, does no one else consider Mac-style "alt-tab switches apps" and "global menu" usability mistakes? (on grounds of being modal)
With both Unity and Gnome adopting these, I no longer have a compelling reason to switch from Mac back to Linux.
Which is a pity really, because Gnome 3 is one of the prettiest and most usable desktops I've seen: I love how the windows key gives you access to the dock, all windows, workspaces and search at the same time.