I would disagree with that. I like being able to download a copy of all my data from all these big websites. Since I no longer use Twitter/X, it's nice to have a copy of everything I have posted there.
Why would you want a law with high compliance costs to solve a problem that was already solved? It makes no sense to impose the costs unless the thing it purports to solve actually presents as a problem.
Product design doesn't need to be written into law.
Please stop repeating that argument, it's not true. There's periodic review proces built in into this legislation.
>attempted to enforce a similar mandate for micro-USB back in the day - can you imagine if they succeeded?
That would be great. Probably Apple would transition to the USB-C a few years ago with everyone instead current nonsense.
Lightning originated when there was a talk about mandating micro-USB and finally died, after 11 years, when USB-C was mandated. If not for that legislation it would still be alive.
It's actually faster that way.
Now it will be a chicken and egg problem. No one will want to put a new connector in phones, because they'd need usb c too anyways. So no new standard will emerge with wide enough industry support. If the micro usb "mandate" was as binding and restrictive as this one, we would not have had usb c.
This is why the USB Implimentation Forum exists. If you want to put a new connector in phones, do it; just do it through the proper, standardized and official channels. If every manufacturer had their own competing charging standard, we would be back to square 1 with 15 different ways to route serial data and 15w of juice. As companies like Apple have so gratefully demonstrated, most companies tend to invent those chargers for licensing royalties rather than a willingness to push the envelope on charging or data transfer technology.
And plus... it's a serial cable. The demand for "research and development" has remained the same since they figured out how to flatten the type B connector. You can't fool anybody by releasing a 'new and improved' cable or connector that is just the same serial bus with proprietary mumbo-jumbo on top.
And this sums up the issue perfectly. “I don’t want improvements. I want design by committee least common denominator”
I think I'll give EU a chance before I will agree that they created bottle neck by this legislation.
The EU just mandated a charging standard. It didn’t mandate that Apple go whole hog implementing the USB 3.1 protocol including video over USB C - all things that the typical Android phone doesn’t do.
When do you think mobile devices will be limited by USB-C? Another 20 years? Is it worth for you to allow mess, vendor locks and ripping of customers for another quarter of century, because some magic connector that solves problem we don't know exists can be delayed by 2-3 years? Really?
Anti-competitive practices from corporations delay progress way more than that.
If micro usb was enforced, USB C in its current form wouldn’t exist.
A periodic review process won't matter. Somebody has to actually research, design and create an alternative. Why would they spend resources on that if their competitors can just decide that they're not allowed to use it?
Not at all, I think it achieved exactly what it was designed to do. The part where we blindly accept cookie banners without holding companies accountable for doing so much tracking (or put them in place without questioning if they're needed) is totally on us.
GDPR did give us the tools and the means, we just don't take full advantage of them.
Chat control is not really tech regulation though, even if it affects tech the proposal is written by people who have no idea what the fuck they are doing. Ylva Johansson (The MEP responsible for it) has even said straight out she has no idea if or how this should be complied with but "They will figure it out" (They being tech companies). With people like that deciding our laws of course you end up with shit like this.