News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by mardifoufs on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @09:55AM (#37832151)
Not remotely the same for micro usb. It wasn't the same law.

Now it will be a chicken and egg problem. No one will want to put a new connector in phones, because they'd need usb c too anyways. So no new standard will emerge with wide enough industry support. If the micro usb "mandate" was as binding and restrictive as this one, we would not have had usb c.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @01:22PM (#37834859)
> No one will want to put a new connector in phones, because they'd need usb c too anyways.

This is why the USB Implimentation Forum exists. If you want to put a new connector in phones, do it; just do it through the proper, standardized and official channels. If every manufacturer had their own competing charging standard, we would be back to square 1 with 15 different ways to route serial data and 15w of juice. As companies like Apple have so gratefully demonstrated, most companies tend to invent those chargers for licensing royalties rather than a willingness to push the envelope on charging or data transfer technology.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by xvector on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @03:28PM (#37836382)
The problem is that nobody will be willing to invest in the research and development needed to do so. It's a chicken and an egg problem.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @05:30PM (#37837832)
Good. I don't want a company to create and monopolize some arbitrary improvement over the current technology. I want those developments to be forced into standardization to compete, and offer backwards-compatibility just like USB does.

And plus... it's a serial cable. The demand for "research and development" has remained the same since they figured out how to flatten the type B connector. You can't fool anybody by releasing a 'new and improved' cable or connector that is just the same serial bus with proprietary mumbo-jumbo on top.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @05:33PM (#37837879)
> Good. I don't want a company to create and monopolize some arbitrary improvement over the current technology.

And this sums up the issue perfectly. “I don’t want improvements. I want design by committee least common denominator”

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:05PM (#37839370)
When it comes to charging and serial standards which have not meaningfully evolved in over a decade... yeah. It would be kinda nice to trade marginal improvement for compatibility and stability. The USB-C connector is not limiting smartphone data or charging speeds anyways.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:57PM (#37839729)
And no one will ever need more than 640K of memory…
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @12:04PM (#37846256)
I'm happy to wait for the first iPhone that needs to exceed 60w of charging and Thunderbolt 4 speeds.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by dzikimarian on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:34AM (#37841286)
For now I see that Apple took USB-C and used it implement 23 years old protocol in it's mid-range device.

I think I'll give EU a chance before I will agree that they created bottle neck by this legislation.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @10:33AM (#37844916)
The iPhone Pro is a midrange device?

The EU just mandated a charging standard. It didn’t mandate that Apple go whole hog implementing the USB 3.1 protocol including video over USB C - all things that the typical Android phone doesn’t do.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by dzikimarian on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:24AM (#37858530)
Regular iPhone is midrange - it has USB 2.0, and yet it just started to be sold. Apparently 23 years old solution is still ok for lots of the people.

When do you think mobile devices will be limited by USB-C? Another 20 years? Is it worth for you to allow mess, vendor locks and ripping of customers for another quarter of century, because some magic connector that solves problem we don't know exists can be delayed by 2-3 years? Really?

Anti-competitive practices from corporations delay progress way more than that.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:03AM (#37887015)
And yet, the price of a goopd USB C cable from Amazon is no less expensive than a 3rd party Lightning cable.