News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by kristopolous on Sunday October 08, 2023 @12:52PM (#37812151)
And this is yet again why I'm on the left and not a liberal.

Drug problems are solved by better access to quality health care and not punitive policing

This action commits state resources and funds to snatching people up, so it's not like we can't afford the better way - we're just allocating our people and efforts to ineffective methods.

Chasing around users to lock them in cages for 20 years is way more expensive than actually solving the problem of abuse. The only reason a better way stays impossible is because there's an ideological commitment on the part of mainstream political beliefs to keeping it impossible.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by rayiner on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:41PM (#37812656)
> Drug problems are solved by better access to quality health care and not punitive policing

Doesn’t seem to be working in California. In reality, it seems like the only solution to drug problems is a culture that ostracizes drug users while harshly punishing drug merchants.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by caesil on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:08PM (#37812335)
This has nothing to do with the center left versus the far left and everything to do with the fact that Gavin Newsom personally wants to run for president.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by meroes on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:11PM (#37812373)
(Sarcastically) Agreed! There’s lots of hit pieces against Newsom getting lots of air time! On Reddit there were 3-4 different ones on most news subs and then the Israel-Palestine news took over everything on Reddit.

Man I need to get off social media as it’s completely overrun with moneyed/political interests.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by thejazzman on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:17PM (#37815921)
Welcome to 2015, my friend!
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by itsoktocry on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:26PM (#37812511)
>Drug problems are solved by better access to quality health care and not punitive policing

Really? Can you point anywhere where drug problems are "solved"?

Portugal used to be the poster child for this, but opinion is shifting because it hasn't solved anything[0]. We are trying the same in Canada, with similarly mediocre results.

[0]https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/07/portugal-dru...

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by dundarious on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:33PM (#37812580)
Portugal is not a wealthy country and one of the areas where funding has dropped significantly below adequate levels is the support infrastructure around decriminalization. As with all austerity politics, there are loud reactionary voices who prefer the punitive approach.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by rayiner on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:46PM (#37812702)
Drugs is a solved problem in most Asian countries that are much poorer than Portugal.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by dundarious on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:00PM (#37812859)
Did the Duterte approach "work" in an unambiguous and uncontroversial way? Many such examples exist to dismiss your glib point.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by arroz on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:00PM (#37812863)
It’s not a solved problem. It’s a nonexistent problem. You can’t solve a problem you don’t have.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by mirashii on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#37812774)
From the article you linked:

> João Goulão — head of Portugal’s national institute on drug use and the architect of decriminalization — admitted to the local press in December that “what we have today no longer serves as an example to anyone.” Rather than fault the policy, however, he blames a lack of funding.

> Twenty years ago, “we were quite successful in dealing with the big problem, the epidemic of heroin use and all the related effects,” Goulão said in an interview with The Washington Post. “But we have had a kind of disinvestment, a freezing in our response … and we lost some efficacy.”

The story turns out to be much the same as a common trope for those who wish to undo successful policies here in the US: under-fund them as sabotage, and then call them failed when the lack of funding causes lower efficacy. Additionally, prohibitionist policies and the policing drug use has been rising (see 24,25,26 at https://substanceabusepolicy.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1...) over the second half of the time drugs have been decriminalized, so the rollbacks in societal gains need to be taken with a grain of salt.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by itsoktocry on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:15PM (#37813003)
So it's not solved?

Perpetually spending more and more money is not a solution. I'm also not surprised to see the architect blame funding as opposed to admitting their policy failed.

Again, we are trying to do the same in Canada, and while overdoses are decreasing, these policies are not solving the crisis. In some places they are making it worse.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by kristopolous on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:22PM (#37813067)
> Perpetually spending more and more money is not a solution.

That's how running a society works.

The criminalize and lockup method isn't free of cost

Are you expecting biological addiction to be like breeded out of the gene pool? How would a $0 cost solution eventually happen?

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by happytiger on Sunday October 08, 2023 @03:39PM (#37813727)
I feel like many of these solutions are fueled first by ideology, and only then by the evidence.

On the right, people criticize and blame the users, rant about personal responsibility, and try to lock drug users and the mentally ill up and throw away the keys. This is failed policy.

On the left, people invest in legalization and treatment as a personal ideology and don’t seem to be willing to admit when their policies fail. It almost seems like a failed policy conflates to some kind of personal failure that cannot be examined or criticized. And instead of policy failure, it’s always a funding issue, no matter how many times consistent results emerge. This is looking more and more like failed policy too.

I’ve seen it in Van, Portland, Sacramento, Seattle, San Francisco and LA, and it’s pretty consistently not only not getting better but getting much worse.

Ultimately, neither approach seems to be working very well. And in the meantime people are living lives of hopelessness and despair in tremendously awful conditions.

Are there no other options available than these two counter positions? I think we should be having more of an open dialogue about how to solve the problem and be more ready to examine the evidence, even when it doesn’t support our positions, for the greater good of those suffering, and I often see conversations on the topic break down into the tit for tat I’m seeing here. These kinds of conversations are the default, and solve nothing.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by nullindividual on Sunday October 08, 2023 @05:34PM (#37814623)
Neither Portland nor Seattle have received funding to tamper drug addiction to the necessary degree to provide indication that such a policy would work or not, which leads me to believe your other examples also did not get such funding, thus negating your entire argument, sans the failure of the lock em up policy, of course.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by happytiger on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:23PM (#37815966)
But in doing so you’re doing precisely what I’ve referenced as leading with ideology.

You are making assumptions about funding being the issue based on what you think should work and then attacking my argument by justifying your belief with assumptions to support the conclusion you want instead of letting the data and the facts lead.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by huytersd on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:07PM (#37815867)
For what it’s worth, draconian penalties against drug use, possession and trafficking actually do work. Countries like Singapore and many middle eastern countries have death penalties for drug smuggling and life sentences for simple possession and these places genuinely have very low drug usage in society. As a civilized society it’s really not worth killing people over this though.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by huytersd on Sunday October 08, 2023 @08:58PM (#37815820)
You’re going to perpetually spend on crime caused by junkies, it’s serious financial burden on the healthcare system and a social burden on families. You’re much better off spending a fraction of that money on rehab.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by trogdor on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:20AM (#37821359)
Treatment works best when people are motivated to get clean. It doesn’t work when they are not. Moreover, the likelihood of good long-term outcomes decreases dramatically when addiction is comorbid with other serious mental illness.

Sadly, I don’t believe that most mentally ill, homeless addicts are going to get better. It’s a terrible situation, and I don’t know of a solution.

I don’t think anyone does.

I would also note that most rehab facilities for substance use disorders espouse an abstinence-based approach to treatment. That approach simply doesn’t work. The standard of care for opioid use disorder is medication assisted treatment, which is both evidence-based and far more effective than abstinence-based programs. The difference in outcomes is stark, particularly since dropout often results in death.

Bottom line, though, from my perspective: you can’t effectively treat people unless and until they are motivated to enter into and engage with a treatment program. “Junkies” of the type you describe rarely fit that bill. Drug courts are a good step in the right direction, but they need to take a more evidence-based approach to their operations.

I wish there was an easy solution to this problem, but there isn’t.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by turquoisevar on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:32PM (#37816015)
To add to that, while Portugal is now often brought forward as the “poster child” now that efficacy stats benefit the “law & order” types, a lot of Western European countries have way more compassionate laws and regulations on drugs and far outperform the US both in stats as well as the boots in the ground situation on the streets.

As per usual this is presented as a “uniquely American” issue, when in reality many other countries have found solutions to mitigate the issue.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by kristopolous on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:31PM (#37813134)
That's a matter of definition.

In Los Angeles I can easily find needles in the streets and large encampments of people on drugs.

In say Tokyo, Copenhagen, Stockholm, I cannot. The money and resources we're throwing at the problem is being ineffectively allocated and structured because we're spending more and it's doing less.

By solved here I mean if we spend billions on a problem we shouldn't be getting increasingly large sprawling encampments as a result.

Even poorer cities with plenty of problems of their own like Mexico City and Bangkok had nothing like the issues I've seen on the streets of our wealthiest cities such as San Francisco

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by Mountain_Skies on Sunday October 08, 2023 @03:44PM (#37813774)
Just handing out housing doesn't solve the problems that lead to homelessness except in a very small minority of cases, which are also the cases most likely to resolve with less drastic interventions by giving hand ups.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by jitl on Sunday October 08, 2023 @05:45PM (#37814690)
handing out housing does actually solve homelessness. Once the unhoused have house, they are no longer unhoused.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by wombat-man on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:07PM (#37812317)
I mean they aren't even bothering to go after opiate users in CA at least based on anecdotes I've heard. Maybe official decriminalization is a step too far for newsom.
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by ssalka on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:15PM (#37812416)
There is a big difference between opiates, which are widely abused, and psychedelics, which have far lesser risk of abuse and are generally safer physically to consume.

I agree with caesil that this is posturing to support his presidential run, whether for public perception or lobbying/fundraising reasons.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by weaksauce on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:00PM (#37812860)
If you read the veto letter from him it's pretty reasonable in what he's willing to agree to:

https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/SB-58-Veto...

he's not anti-mushrooms but he's anti-unfettered access to mushrooms without guidelines in place. I don't know if it's the right call or not but mushrooms are something that's not really fit for general consumption; cannabis being fairly benign and understood is a different issue altogether and one that makes sense to have fairly unfettered access to at a population level.

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by konfusinomicon on Sunday October 08, 2023 @07:10PM (#37815267)
someone that commits a drug crime that results in a 20 year sentence wouldn't benefit from decriminalization at all. I feel like you'd have to get caught with several metric tons of mushrooms and be clearly involved in a massive distribution enterprise to pull 20 years
Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by kristopolous on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @01:08AM (#37828699)
...or be black...

In the deep south there's black people that get lifetime terms for $20 in weed

Re:CA Gov. Newsom vetoes bill that would have decriminalized... by jonmayer on Sunday October 08, 2023 @11:04PM (#37816522)
To my great sadness, I have known too many people who I consider to be addicts and abusers of drugs, both illegal and prescription.

Except I've never met anyone with an abusive or addictive relationship to psilocybin. I just haven't seen it. Seriously, when was the last time you heard of a family giving someone a mushroom intervention?