News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by boeingUH60 on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:09PM (#37794888)
Kaiser 2022 revenue; $68 billion. Net income; $925 million. CEO pay; $13.3 million base and $2.3 million "Other." [1]

Kaiser Foundation Health Plan and Kaiser Foundation Hospitals earned a combined $100 billion in revenue in 2021 [2]. It's the highest-grossing non-profit organization in the USA and probably the world, lol...net income margins are slim though.

1- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/941.... 2- https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/states/CA

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by kosherhurricane on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:41PM (#37795283)
Kaiser is non profit. They dont have shareholders and no dividends. The 1B net income that year is because some years they run a deficit.

If the workers get paid more through this strike, it will translates directly to higher prices.

Even after that, Kaiser will stay a low cost provider. Becasue they are non-profit.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by runako on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:47PM (#37795364)
> If the workers get paid more through this strike, it will translates directly to higher prices.

Has Kaiser not raised prices for health insurance premiums or other fees since 2020? Because that would be notable and they absolutely should lead with that.

My suspicion is they didn't mention that because they have been raising the fees they charge their customers faster than they have been raising wages, like many employers.

Either way, it doesn't matter all that much if their wages aren't keeping pace with inflation. That would almost definitionally lead to the kind of labor shortages described in the article.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by gshubert17 on Friday October 06, 2023 @05:00PM (#37796362)
I've had the same Medicare advantage plan with Kaiser in Colorado since 2019: My monthly costs for Kaiser, and then for Medicare part B: 2019: 370.50 135.50 2020: 360.50 144.60 2021: 294.50 148.50 2022: 236.50 170.10 2023: 236.50 164.90 2024: 236.50 ?? Before 2019 I had a different plan. I was retired but not yet eligible for medicare. Prices for such pre-medicare plans have increased significantly over this period.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by droopyEyelids on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:54PM (#37795452)
The math of health providers is always super sketchy, because they 'donate' their emergency service to the indigent at a non-discounted rate and deduct that from their profits.

Aside from the fact that those non-discounted rates are astronomically high in the USA, they also don't have to worry about anyone analyzing the list of services provided, so the medical billing errors in the provider's favor don't have a chance of being questioned.

Large medical provider accounting is right next to Hollywood accounting in the staggering games played with profit, expense, and loss.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by lotsofpulp on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:09PM (#37795661)
> The math of health providers is always super sketchy, because they 'donate' their emergency service to the indigent at a non-discounted rate and deduct that from their profits.

This makes no sense. If they are the healthcare provider, then services provided to the indigent go in the expenses column, and revenue is in the revenue column.

And you cannot “deduct” anything from profit, it is literally all revenues minus all expenses. And also Kaiser is a non profit.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by nwiswell on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:38PM (#37796071)
Just because Kaiser is one parent entity doesn't mean there isn't a wholly owned "insurance" entity and a "provider" entity.

I'm no expert but in that case I imagine it would be fully GAAP for the provider entity to bill a non-discounted rate to the insurance entity, even though the insurance entity is recognizing no offsetting revenues because the person is question is not part of the insurance pool.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by boeingUH60 on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:12PM (#37795703)
Cue armchair accountants on HN..
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by jeffreyrogers on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:27PM (#37795108)
That seems like a reasonable amount for the CEO of a massive health care system. Not an easy business to manage and someone who can manage a business that large could do lots of other things. Kaiser is also pretty efficient as far as health care organizations go.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by boeingUH60 on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:30PM (#37795141)
Sure, I'm not complaining, just trying to provide context..
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by PaulHoule on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:35PM (#37795195)
Kaiser is a Colossus, it was more-or-less the first HMO. I've been reading about it in the context of health care economics since the 1980s.

I was getting a test at the hospital in my town the other day and got asked by the technician about my job, which involves public opinion data, and that got into "why are people unhappy with the economy today?" which got into strikes, and she volunteered Kaiser as an example so people like her are very away this is going on.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by rightbyte on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:00PM (#37795532)
I am quite sure someone about as competent would do his job for far less. I got this feeling the higher you go the less skill based recruitment is and the more connections and friends matter.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by gongdzhauh on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:31PM (#37795980)
You can say the same thing about professional athletes. Sure, there are bench players in the NBA that would love to start for the Warriors for half of what Steph Curry makes, and they'd probably do a pretty good job. They're amazing basketball players after all. They're likely in the top 1,000 basketball players in the whole world. But they are probably not going to lead the Warriors to a championship. In some situations it's worth paying for that extra little bit of skill+talent.

I'm not sure if that small margin matters for running a major HMO, but I could imagine it does. And that small margin might just be having connections and friends. Maybe having those connections and friends is that extra value proposition that a good CEO brings.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:40PM (#37796109)
I think a key difference is that sports regularly "tests" performance to help make sure the cream rises to the top. The practice squads are are playing the exact same positions to vie for a starting gig. How many B-squad business types get to head-to-head with an active CEO for long enough to see who's really got the chops?

As a layperson, it seems like the research is mixed as to whether a specific CEO really matters that much to the bottom line. Despite the inconclusive evidence, though, they sure get paid well like it's a given that they really, really matter.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by btilly on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:52PM (#37796264)
Overall, there is a negative correlation between CEO pay and performance.

https://chiefexecutive.net/higher-ceo-pay-produce-better-com...

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:57PM (#37796337)
There are other studies that show the opposite though and it's important to not draw strong conclusions from a single study. To quote one study:

"compensation arrangements are endogenous and correlated with many unobservables, measuring their causal effects on behavior and firm value is extremely difficult"

Frydman, C. and Jenter, D., 2010. CEO compensation. Annu. Rev. Financ. Econ., 2(1), pp.75-102.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by confidantlake on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:35PM (#37796041)
You can say that but the analogy makes little sense.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by JambalayaJim on Saturday October 07, 2023 @02:17PM (#37804147)
The difference between Steph Curry and some nba basketball player in the 99.9% percentile actually does matter a lot. And keep in mind hat Curry’s salary is actually lower than his value to a team because of salary cap structures.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by boeingUH60 on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:10PM (#37795671)
> I got this feeling the higher you go the less skill based recruitment is and the more connections and friends matter.

That’s fact not feeling. There are very few positions at the top and an oversupply of skilled people willing to fill them.

It becomes a matter of getting favored by the right people…sure executives put in the work but impressing the right people at the right time is how one progresses in the upper echelons.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by dfadsadsf on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:24PM (#37795886)
There is oversupply of people willing to fill high level positions. Problem is that if you want people who have proven that they are skilled (aka successfully held equivalent or higher position at similar company) the pool is much smaller and competition for them is much higher. In addition executive leaving is very disruptive (takes 6+ months to find new one, etc) so you want to pay above average so he does not leave which leads to arms race in salaries.

On what executive mishire can cause just look at recent events at Flexport. It takes 1+ year to understand that executive is failing and course correction is extremely expensive and disruptive.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by hotnfresh on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:43PM (#37796143)
Promoting up from within, and grooming successors who started low down the ladder in the company, used to be common.

Now we hire straight in from B-schools at VP or director level, and one of those ends up CEO eventually (if a CEO's not simply hired from outside, directly).

This practice seems to have dramatically increased the cost of executives. I wonder if it's increased quality.

[EDIT] OK not straight from b-school, they have to do a stint in management consulting or whatever first. Because having that be something that the totally inexperienced do makes complete sense.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:51PM (#37796250)
The idea of hiring straight from B-schools, without experience, tells me B-schools schools have decided to sell out to maximize student throughput. It used to be that very few people got accepted to B-schools without at least a decade or so of experience.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:49PM (#37796215)
>In addition executive leaving is very disruptive (takes 6+ months to find new one, etc)

Ironically, I read this as an indicator of a bad leader and one who doesn't deserve high pay. A good leader should be regularly training their underlings to make sure there are as few hiccups as possible if they get hit by a bus.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by josephh on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:11PM (#37795681)
Could you provide a list of names who can/are willing to do it for less? I think our executive recruiting folks (from a lage-cap company) would be more than happy to get some referrals :)

/s

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by jeffreyrogers on Saturday October 07, 2023 @05:22PM (#37805690)
Given the wide variation in quality among US healthcare organizations, and the fact that Kaiser has been consistently one of the better ones across most quality metrics, I think you are wrong and are underestimating the challenge involved in both running an organization of Kaiser's size and of recruiting an appropriate person for that role.

I do agree that assessment is less skill based at those levels, but that is largely because the job is not hard skill based. That doesn't mean the person doesn't matter or that they are interchangeable. No one but Steve Jobs could've turned around Apple for example.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by derstander on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:07PM (#37795641)
> That seems like a reasonable amount for the CEO of a massive health care system. Not an easy business to manage and someone who can manage a business that large could do lots of other things.

As far as US CEO salaries go, I agree that it doesn’t sound particularly egregious.

Compare that with, say, Nintendo’s President, who makes the equivalent of $2.4 million.

https://www.nintendo.co.jp/ir/pdf/2023/annual2303e.pdf

Executive pay in the US seems to be high compared to at least Japan. Are US executives really that much better than Japanese executives scored against objective metrics?

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by dfadsadsf on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:17PM (#37795784)
Japanese companies did not do very well over the last 20 years (by pretty much any metric) so objectively US executives as a group did significantly better than Japanese executives as a group. In addition you can't talk only CEO salaries without mentioning that salaries in US are overall much higher than in Japan. 13M salary for somebody managing 305k employees sounds very reasonable when senior manager/director (manages 50 people) at tech company makes 1M+.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by femiagbabiaka on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:31PM (#37795983)
Assigning macroeconomic trends to the actions of CEOs seems off. A really good CEO (if that exists) can not fight decades of terrible macro.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:46PM (#37796183)
Compare it to the past US CEO pay then. In the heyday of the American economic boom of the 1960s, the CEO-to-worker pay gap was an order of magnitude lower. What's a bit odd to me is how the social norms have shifted regarding this, to the point where average Americans defend it as just.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by Shaanie on Friday October 06, 2023 @05:37PM (#37796762)
Did you adjust for company size? I bet the average s&p 500 company is much larger than they were in the 60s. Doesn't seem strange or unjust to me that a ceo of a $1 trillion market cap company can demand higher pay than one for a $1 billion company.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by derstander on Friday October 06, 2023 @06:35PM (#37797234)
> Did you adjust for company size? I bet the average s&p 500 company is much larger than they were in the 60s.

If you adjust for company size then you should adjust for inflation as well. I’d be interested in knowing for sure, but if I had to, I’d guess they’re 5-10x, not 1000x, bigger.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by bumby on Friday October 06, 2023 @09:55PM (#37798378)
As another commenter mentioned, there’s a lot that goes into market cap. The adjusted PE is quite a bit higher than the 1960s, implying the market caps are overvalued by comparison, so I’m not sure market cap is a great proxy.

One other way to measure it is by worker productivity, which has also increased since the 1960s. Somehow those productivity gains are disproportionately hoovered up by management.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by xkcd-sucks on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:17PM (#37795793)
> Are US executives really that much better than Japanese executives scored against objective metrics?

At negotiation and price discovery, clearly they are :)

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by hotnfresh on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:26PM (#37795911)
US execs seem to be really good at using company money to provide back-scratching favors to board members. Maybe they're less-good at that in other countries, so boards don't reward them as well.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by pc86 on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:24PM (#37795881)
US developer pay is easily 2-3x that of our Western European counterparts. The gap widens tremendously as you move further East in Europe and especially into the middle east, Asia and SE Asia. But you get American developers (myself included) coming out of the woodwork to defend that.

Comparing the President of a Japanese video game company to the CEO of major American healthcare organization with ~6-7x the revenue isn't really an apt comparison, is it?

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by derstander on Friday October 06, 2023 @06:04PM (#37796996)
> Comparing the President of a Japanese video game company to the CEO of major American healthcare organization with ~6-7x the revenue isn't really an apt comparison, is it?

Why wouldn’t it be? And if it’s not, how about a comparison between Sony and KP? Sony’s revenue in 2022 was $88B (though with a much larger net of $6.7B instead of KP’s $0.9B). Sony’s CEO was paid $4.4M.

https://www.sony.com/en/SonyInfo/IR/library/FY2022_20F_PDF.p...

I also think spinning Nintendo as simply a Japanese video game company undersells their global presence as well as the fact that they build hardware in addition to software. My guess is that Nintendo or Sony have a much greater global presence than KP though I certainly could be wrong.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by DanAtC on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:42PM (#37795298)
Sounds like the workers are due $925mm
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by lucaspm98 on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:57PM (#37795495)
Will their wages be garnished if the slim 1.3% margins turn negative?
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:46PM (#37796189)
No, healthcare costs will increase in order to support robust wages and reasonable practitioner patient ratios. Inelastic demand for services that keep people alive do that.

No healthcare CEO or hospital administrator is coming to change your bed pan or put a PICC line in, or stop you from bleeding out in the emergency department or the operating room.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by undersuit on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:46PM (#37796190)
No, they'll continue to be laid off like in previous years.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by imnotlost on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:52PM (#37795433)
Or return premiums to the marks, eh, victims, eh, members.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by riku_iki on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:52PM (#37795424)
> revenue; $68 billion. Net income; $925 million

sounds like profit margin is very small and they can go underwater any moment.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by smileysteve on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:40PM (#37796112)
Seems compatible with the Aca caps.

Where 80 of revenues had to be spent on healthcare expenses for insurers.

https://www.healthcare.gov/health-care-law-protections/rate-....

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by angstrom on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:14PM (#37795736)
Now do United Health
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by riku_iki on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:17PM (#37795785)
how its relevant?
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by mvdtnz on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:46PM (#37796179)
You need to downvote and ignore people who respond with things like "now do X", "relevant username", "get out of here with your facts and logic" and similar Redditisms. The best we can hope for is for the Reddit interlopers to quietly go away.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by candiddevmike on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:49PM (#37796224)
As a non profit, your goal is to show as little profit as possible. So you play hide the money in board salaries, "outside consultants", executive pay and retirement plans, etc.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by riku_iki on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:51PM (#37796257)
I think non-profit can be profitable, they just don't distribute profit to shareholders.

Distributing profit through pay, plans and bonuses sound like blatant fraud and they likely trying to avoid it.

Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by llsf on Friday October 06, 2023 @03:55PM (#37795469)
Technicality, but Kaiser Permanente is a not-for-profit health plans. I believe it does have part that are non-profit, but in large it is a non-for-profit organization.
Re:More than 75,000 Kaiser workers go on strike in clash wit... by billy99k on Friday October 06, 2023 @08:07PM (#37797870)
Well, they could divide up the CEOs pay and give those 75,000 workers the $175 they deserve.