Re:Is Software Engineering Real Engineering?
by velcrovan on Thursday October 05, 2023 @11:50AM
(#37780169)
You are begging the question. The three statements in your list are indeed true. I am saying that they should not be true.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Is Software Engineering Real Engineering?
by AlotOfReading on Thursday October 05, 2023 @12:47PM
(#37780896)
They've been true for over a century at this point though. Since I assume you aren't complaining about every vehicle ever produced not being signed by PEs, what is it about software that you think it should require a PE stamp when hardware should not?
Re:Is Software Engineering Real Engineering?
by velcrovan on Thursday October 05, 2023 @04:49PM
(#37784124)
> They've been true for over a century at this point though.
The duration of the status quo doesn’t feel at all relevant to my argument.
> what is it about software that you think it should require a PE stamp when hardware should not?
Any profession of system design whose failure mode is “people die” would better serve a culture that abhors preventable deaths if governed by the same licensure, liability, professional ethics and independent verification used by electrical and structural engineering. I don’t make any distinction between hardware and software, but this article happens to be about software, so that’s what we’re discussing.