News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on AI by siliconc0w on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @07:13PM (#37758841)
For me the more pressing concern is more societal unrest, economic and monopolistic - e.g workers being displaced without enough new jobs being created. Or every communication channel being spammed with no ability to discern trustworthy/authentic content. Or too few large companies hoarding the GPUs and owning the biggest most effective models which allows them not only to consolidate power in the AI industry but own/decide winners in every other industry. You can kinda see this now with Nvidia basically trading GPUs for equity.

The 'regulate it like nukes' thing because teenagers might ask it to end the world thing seems pretty far down the line.

Re:John Carmack on AI by ChatGTP on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @07:18PM (#37758874)
I hope the uber captialists decide they can use AI to build a space utopa for their families in another solar system and go there :)

I honestly don't give a shit about jobs, or having a job, I have one because the system says I need one, if I don't need a job, I'd be so so so much better off.

I'm certain we have enough technology and nohow to feed, house and provide electricity for everyone on earth without them having a 9-5.

Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:14PM (#37759325)
This view is hilarious. That you think you can sit around and produce nothing while everyone else around you produces everything you need. Or that everyone can stop what they're doing and still provide you with that. You're just lazy with dreams of contributing nothing and thats not admirable. Until the day where robots are literally walking around wiping our ass, people need to do things.
Re:John Carmack on AI by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @02:26AM (#37761537)
Check his username.
Re:John Carmack on AI by gmerc on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @02:26AM (#37761541)
The simple fix is to scale the maximum work week based on available work, partially socializing the efficient gain from AI to society which provided much of the training data.

How much can be up for debate, but giving it all to corporates is going to be a replay of the run up to WW2

Re:John Carmack on AI by ChatGTP on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:54AM (#37762613)
You completely misconstrued what I said actually.

I like working, I like making things, I just don't care about having a "job" which I tie my identity too.

Also, I have a Japanese Toto I imported from Japan, it's literally a robotic toilet that wipes my ass for me. Try again angry man.

Re:John Carmack on AI by marcus_holmes on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:58AM (#37762641)
> That you think you can sit around and produce nothing while everyone else around you produces everything you need.

Yet that's exactly what the "leisure class" do. Inherit enough money and that's your life. Why is that not equally hilarious? Why do only some of us get to have that and it's OK?

Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @07:59PM (#37773314)
The vast majority of people who have money didnt inherit it. The vast majority worked for it.

You dont have it because you didnt earn it. Instead you're on the internet demanding like a child that you dont need to work for anything. Thats the difference between people with money and yourself.

Re:John Carmack on AI by marcus_holmes on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @08:35PM (#37773538)
I'm not asking for money. I'm asking why it's OK to inherit money from your parents and do nothing useful your whole life. Why do we give those people a free pass?
Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @09:52PM (#37774064)
People who receive money dont necessarily expect and demand to sit on their ass. It just happens to them and they got lucky.

And theres not a "pass" you or anyone else is entitled to give. Its not your property or family matter.

Re:John Carmack on AI by brokenmachine on Friday October 06, 2023 @12:42AM (#37787175)
Nobody ever earned a billion dollars.
Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Friday October 06, 2023 @11:36AM (#37792188)
This is what people who have never built anything like to say.

Bezos as an example built a great service. An exchange of value between willing customers and what he created happens repeatedly. Therefore he earned the billions. Thats how it works. The more value you create for the most people makes you more money. And I cant think of a more fair system.

Re:John Carmack on AI by brokenmachine on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:14AM (#37799168)
He didn't build all that by himself, and there's (hundreds of) thousands of workers doing the actual physical work for him.

Those Amazon servers don't magically teleport the packages to the customers.

All because he's lobbied, and continues to lobby, to not pay enough taxes. The tax system is unbelievably unfair.

Re:John Carmack on AI by marcus_holmes on Sunday October 08, 2023 @11:42PM (#37816716)
It's not fair because some people inherit enough money to never have to work. If you actually wanted a fair system then we would all spend our childhoods in a boarding school with no contact with our parents, and no inheritance. But that's not feasible, so we're stuck with this unfair system. But let's not pretend it's fair.

Those who "create value" often don't. The continuing enshittification of everything is removing value from customers, yet the CEOs who are forcing it on their customers are getting paid vast salaries. We all know that they're destroying value and that their organisations will eventually be replaced by ones that actually value customers, but they continue to be rewarded.

You have a very naive view of capitalism.

Re:John Carmack on AI by thelastparadise on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @07:32AM (#37763651)
> the day where robots are literally walking around wiping our ass

You jest, but there's quite a lot of elderly, frail, incontinent boomers who are or soon will be in need of this service.

The Millennials zoomers and alphas seem to have little to no interest in doing the asswiping themselves.

Re:John Carmack on AI by ChatGTP on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @09:45AM (#37765086)
It's called a washlet or a bidet, check it out.
Re:John Carmack on AI by Lio on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @05:05AM (#37762677)
> I hope the uber captialists decide they can use AI to build a space utopa for their families in another solar system and go there :)

Sounds a bit like Douglas Adams' Golgafrinchan Ark Fleet Ship B, except for tech bros instead of telephone sanitisers or advertising executives.

Re:John Carmack on AI by mindwok on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:01PM (#37759192)
In terms of communication channels being spammed: I am actually hopeful for this because it will just create enormous incentives for us to rethink our communication channels to be much more selective. For example, moving email to be a pull-based system from people I'm actually interested in hearing from rather than an open door with less-than-perfect spam filters. Or making telephone numbers something that have to be mutually exchanged to allow access.
Re:John Carmack on AI by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:24PM (#37759403)
> Or making telephone numbers something that have to be mutually exchanged to allow access.

How would this work? Do you have to meet in person?

Re:John Carmack on AI by mindwok on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:47PM (#37759566)
I was thinking that, or you have to accept a request from someone before they can call you for example.
Re:John Carmack on AI by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:53PM (#37759603)
In person seems impractical for businesses or for foreign correspondence, which is kind of the thing phone excels at. And having to accept a sent request just makes that the vector for abuse doesn't it?
Re:John Carmack on AI by mindwok on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @01:54AM (#37761316)
There's potential for abusing a sent request, but because most people won't accept them it basically removes the incentive to bother abusing it. It's at least much less abusive then calling people.
Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:07PM (#37759260)
Think of it a bit differently. Think of production being so efficient and labor free that producing goods and services is extremely cheap and in turn produces abundance.

Theres a reason why Jamie Dimon is saying people will be working 3 days per week in a generation because of AI.

And its why in capitalistic and technology forward societies the poor are generally better off than every generation prior.

Re:John Carmack on AI by SoftTalker on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:12PM (#37759317)
I could see this happening ... in a generation. We're a long way off and tech changes quickly but the large physical plant investments in producing real products is slower. It will be some time before AI and robots are good enough to replace a lot of the labor that humans do, but I see no inherent reason that it won't happen.

Right now the main thing AI is good at is quickly generating bullshit, so those are the jobs that are going to be first to be replaced.

Re:John Carmack on AI by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:08PM (#37759276)
Didn't people say that about personal computers as well? Compared to a few generations ago we have everything in cheap abundance but we're still working 5+ days a week.
Re:John Carmack on AI by trident5000 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:10PM (#37759295)
Maybe the work week hasnt shrunk yet, but the amount of goods and services available at an affordable price to the average joe is way up.
Re:John Carmack on AI by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:15PM (#37759333)
The work week hasn't shrunk at all, and many goods and services are cheaper but housing isn't and many people live paycheck to paycheck.

I have my reservations that THIS revolution will be the one that solves our problems. A jump in technology is simply a way for those with the means to get more out of those without. AI isn't an equalizer, compute seems like it'll be the new valuable resource and you can buy that with cash.

Re:John Carmack on AI by SoftTalker on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:35PM (#37759486)
Many people have always lived paycheck to paycheck. Maybe part of it is that people are bidding up rents because everything else is relatively cheap?
Re:John Carmack on AI by gumballindie on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:05AM (#37762236)
Yes but pay has gone down in real terms and people afford less of what’s important - owning a home, raising a family. We do indeed have more of the stuff we dont need, or want.
Re:John Carmack on AI by piva00 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @12:23AM (#37760823)
> Modern technic has made it possible to diminish enormously the amount of labor necessary to produce the necessaries of life for every one.

...

> Suppose that at a given moment a certain number of people are engaged in the manufacture of pins. They make as many pins as the world needs, working (say) eight hours a day. Someone makes an invention by which the same number of men can make twice as many pins as before. But the world does not need twice as many pins: pins are already so cheap that hardly any more will be bought at a lower price. In a sensible world everybody concerned in the manufacture of pins would take to working four hours instead of eight, and everything else would go on as before. But in the actual world this would be thought demoralizing. The men still work eight hours, there are too many pins, some employers go bankrupt, and half the men previously concerned in making pins are thrown out of work.

...

> If the ordinary wage-earner worked four hours a day there would be enough for everybody, and no unemployment — assuming a certain very moderate amount of sensible organization. This idea shocks the well-to-do, because they are convinced that the poor would not know how to use so much leisure. In America men often work long hours even when they are already well-off; such men, naturally, are indignant at the idea of leisure for wage-earners except as the grim punishment of unemployment, in fact, they dislike leisure even for their sons.

Bertrand Russell was already talking about how the eight hours workday was a wasteful bullshit in 1932.

Re:John Carmack on AI by thelastparadise on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @07:37AM (#37763701)
> This idea shocks the well-to-do

The well-to-do also need to have an underclass to distinguish themselves from, otherwise they become common. To them, becoming common is one of the worst things that could happen.

Re:John Carmack on AI by Aerroon on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:02AM (#37762204)
>The 'regulate it like nukes' thing because teenagers might ask it to end the world thing seems pretty far down the line.

It's straight up absurd. AI is going to have no appreciable effect on this, because it would simply be disseminating existing knowledge. You can already look up how to build a nuclear bomb. It's not some kind of big secret that nobody's allowed to know. The same goes for all the other world-ending scenarios. AI can't act on its own in the physical world. Even when it eventually does, it will be bound by the same limitations people are.

I agree that the real dangers AI presents are much more mundane. People being able to do things so much more efficiently is going to cause instability in people's lives whose jobs it will affect. It won't replace everyone, but it will cause problems - people have to learn new skills, find new jobs etc.

Re:John Carmack on AI by didibus on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:37AM (#37762489)
AI alone, but logically AI eventually combines with capabilities from robotics, or is able to reach into auto-pilots of cars and planes, drones, self-manned turrets, missile controls, etc. No?
Re:John Carmack on AI by johnthewise on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:32AM (#37762452)
>AI can't act on its own in the physical world.

If it can earn money or is given money, it can certainly get people to do things in the physical world.

Re:John Carmack on AI by mo_42 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @04:58AM (#37762639)
AIs are already acting in the physical world: Any AI (e.g., ChatGPT) changes the configuration of the human brain of those who use it.

Sure, it's a rather philosophical argument currently, but this will change.

If I would be a malicious actor, I'd create a chat bot that sneaks in responses that are in favor of my agenda. In that I'll make my users the puppets of the AI.

Re:John Carmack on AI by omnimus on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @06:08AM (#37763038)
Its not like this hasnt been always happening. Its the reason billionares buy media companies, fake news, astroturfing, bans of books… does it even matter if its Andrew Tate or “AI” spewing nonsense?
Re:John Carmack on AI by thelastparadise on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @07:28AM (#37763615)
> I'd create a chat bot that sneaks in responses that are in favor of my agenda

They're already doing this as there's a clear far left bias/lecturing that occurs in the models, especially those put out by OpenAI.

Re:John Carmack on AI by omnimus on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @02:08PM (#37769231)
Any proof of this? Example?
Re:John Carmack on AI by omnimus on Thursday October 05, 2023 @05:05AM (#37776389)
Oh yeah i thought so. This shows who is biased here.

The AI doesnt care or know. its about what source the material is taught on. Turns out a lot literature, academic texts and even stuff on the internet is leaning left (and right). So this naturally seeps in.

When you live in a bubble left or right you will see the problem everywhere.

Re:John Carmack on AI by throwbmw on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @07:58AM (#37763884)
"Any AI (e.g., ChatGPT) changes the configuration of the human brain of those who use it.

Can you elaborate more?

Re:John Carmack on AI by mo_42 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @09:10AM (#37764549)
As soon as I observe the behavior or output of an agent or AI, the configuration of my brain changes. This is somewhat tautological as observation is connected to memory and thus brain changes.

I guess the more interesting question is whether there are lasting changes. I'm not an expert in learning, memory, or brain development. Even without much knowledge it should be clear that frequent interaction will have lasting changes. For example, ChatGPT is biased in the sense that it does not know about all the books that haven't been digitalized. Used frequently, those missing books will be reflected in my brain.

Another example could be a chess training AI. If I train with an AI, I could have blind spots in the landscape of chess skills that are deliberately (or not) excluded. So clearly, this AI would change my brain but not only in a way I intend.