I think that's a slightly odd way to think about it, the tax is due when you actually have a capital gain, which in the ordinary course of just owning something you don't.
Of course, many countries don't want to miss out on that just because you moved before you sold, so change in tax residency becomes an event that triggers it as if it had been sold.
What's unusual about the US (currently) is that citizens worldwide are considered resident for tax purposes (as other countries would call it I suppose, since it's typically more about residency than citizenship) whatever their living and working arrangement and wherever else tax may be due.
If it weren't for that, probably nothing about renouncing citizenship would be controversial, because it would be a much more niche desire. Surely the main reason to do it is because you moved and wish to be free of 'doing taxes' (maybe you moved somewhere where that's not even something you have to think about!) in the US?
Arguably it’s simply a question of practicality as nobody can accurately assess how much a painting is worth until it’s sold. Still, it definitely incentivizes bonds which pay on maturity rather than every year.
For most people who aren't insanely rich or aren't getting most of their income via a trust fund, this isn't very relevant. You have the foreign income exclusion (somewhere north of $100k now) and the foreign taxes paid deduction to insulate you from playing taxes in the states. The problem becomes when you are making > $100k in a low tax place like Singapore or Dubai, but even then there is a housing deduction that works for most working class people.
> Surely the main reason to do it is because you moved and wish to be free of 'doing taxes' (maybe you moved somewhere where that's not even something you have to think about!) in the US?
It isn't hard to file if you have simply income to consider. I did it by hand for many years, it took around 15-30 minutes a year.
The loophole is putting all your assets into a trust and declaring beneficiaries of the trust. When you die the beneficiaries only have to pay capital gains from value at the time the trust was _created_. IE the closer to death the trust was created the less tax they pay.
There is slow moving efforts to remove this loophole.
Only on amounts above US$ 12.9M (federally), but there is no tax if the estate passes to the spouse:
* https://www.investopedia.com/estate-tax-exemption-2021-defin...
* https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/inheritancetax.asp
How many estates are above that? In 2021, "only 2,584 estates paid a positive federal estate tax."
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_State...
* https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-estate-tax-fili...
If you inherit an asset your tax basis is its value when the owner died. This may be significantly less than what it is when you actually receive the asset, but it’s likely higher than when that person originally purchased it.
PS: Estates may chose an alternate date 6 months after someone died, which again generally helps.
When you leave they want all accounts to zero out which seems eminently reasonable.
[edit] It's mostly problematic for people who find themselves subjects of the IRS, being born abroad for instance - and they may never have even realized their obligations. They are stuck with paying the IRS forever or renouncing and paying capital gains tax on all their assets. Meanwhile, someone who lives in the US for 8 years as an LPR and decides to leave is free to go after filing an I-407 and picking up their 1040-C sailing permit. The whole taxation on the basis of citizenship instead of residency is fundamentally unfair and broken IMO.
Now, if you taxed capital gains when they occurred rather than when the asset was sold then I would absolutely agree it should be tied to residency. But by deferring it for decades suddenly there’s a major incentive to get out of that obligation.
If Bezos paid up when he relinquished residency and then Amazon went down, should he get a refund? 10 years later? Why not - why should he only owe money if it goes up?
He can do the same exact thing by renouncing his citizenship today and paying the capital gains due, today. It's not a 'loophole' that doesn't already exist. In fact, that's exactly what Eduardo Saverin did. [1]
[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-taxes-idUSBRE84G...
That’s equivalent to what the IRS is doing only moving things forward to residency vs citizenship. The current system is actually better for Bezos because he can move anywhere around the world and keep deferring capital gains until his death when it disappears.
Though this is a serious edge case. 2k people renounced American citizenship in 2019 some years it’s ~10k but only a fraction have any kind of meaningful capital gains liability. The general cases is Americans who get to defer liability not expats with a surprising bill.
Whenever you have a tax obligation like this, sell the stock and set the money aside. In the case of renouncing citizenship you can sell all your stock before you leave because you’re facing the same tax liability either way. The only risk is if you do something stupid.
> That’s identical to someone selling a stock then falling to set aside capital gains
You might think the only way to be forced to pay capital gains is on sale, but you’re literally complaining about people being forced to pay capital gains for something else.
If renouncing citizenship would get you out of that obligation people would do so regularly as a tax break then reapply.