When you leave they want all accounts to zero out which seems eminently reasonable.
[edit] It's mostly problematic for people who find themselves subjects of the IRS, being born abroad for instance - and they may never have even realized their obligations. They are stuck with paying the IRS forever or renouncing and paying capital gains tax on all their assets. Meanwhile, someone who lives in the US for 8 years as an LPR and decides to leave is free to go after filing an I-407 and picking up their 1040-C sailing permit. The whole taxation on the basis of citizenship instead of residency is fundamentally unfair and broken IMO.
Now, if you taxed capital gains when they occurred rather than when the asset was sold then I would absolutely agree it should be tied to residency. But by deferring it for decades suddenly there’s a major incentive to get out of that obligation.
If Bezos paid up when he relinquished residency and then Amazon went down, should he get a refund? 10 years later? Why not - why should he only owe money if it goes up?
He can do the same exact thing by renouncing his citizenship today and paying the capital gains due, today. It's not a 'loophole' that doesn't already exist. In fact, that's exactly what Eduardo Saverin did. [1]
[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-taxes-idUSBRE84G...
That’s equivalent to what the IRS is doing only moving things forward to residency vs citizenship. The current system is actually better for Bezos because he can move anywhere around the world and keep deferring capital gains until his death when it disappears.
Though this is a serious edge case. 2k people renounced American citizenship in 2019 some years it’s ~10k but only a fraction have any kind of meaningful capital gains liability. The general cases is Americans who get to defer liability not expats with a surprising bill.