Re:US finally moves to cut $2,350 fee for renouncing citizen...
by throwawaymaths on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:49AM
(#37751155)
Suppose you renounce citizenship, pay your capital "gains" taxes on some stock, and then the stock goes to zero the next day (or, rather, goes below your purchase price). Are you entitled to a refund?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US finally moves to cut $2,350 fee for renouncing citizen...
by Retric on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:53AM
(#37751203)
That’s identical to someone selling a stock then falling to set aside capital gains and losing it all gamboling at a craps table.
Whenever you have a tax obligation like this, sell the stock and set the money aside. In the case of renouncing citizenship you can sell all your stock before you leave because you’re facing the same tax liability either way. The only risk is if you do something stupid.
Re:US finally moves to cut $2,350 fee for renouncing citizen...
by throwawaymaths on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:40AM
(#37751793)
Wrong. That's not how capital gains works. Capital gains is assessed at the sale of the underlying instrument. In your gambling example, if your underlying instrument went to below purchase price, you would owe nothing, or better yet, it would yield s deferrable tax credit.
Re:US finally moves to cut $2,350 fee for renouncing citizen...
by Retric on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:51AM
(#37751937)
You must have misunderstood something, renouncing citizenship is a taxable event the same way selling stock is. Thus:
> That’s identical to someone selling a stock then falling to set aside capital gains
You might think the only way to be forced to pay capital gains is on sale, but you’re literally complaining about people being forced to pay capital gains for something else.