Re:The Game Industry Sucks [video]
by luxuryballs on Saturday September 30, 2023 @03:06PM
(#37718669)
Lost me at “muh capitalism”, pro tip if you want to be taken seriously don't reveal your misunderstanding of economics and 101 level vocabulary words so early in a video about an industry.
Re:The Game Industry Sucks [video]
by clnq on Saturday September 30, 2023 @03:21PM
(#37718809)
Fairly accurate from my many years in AAA.
Another interesting dysfunctional aspect of the industry that wasn't mentioned is that there is a network of studio heads who are often friends with each other, and trends (layoffs, RTO, the $100 game idea, etc) spread in that boys club.
Layoffs sometimes happen before quarter earnings reports to make financials look better. Even entire projects could be cancelled for this. These decisions make little long-term sense as ultimately the business has to return to operation and new people need to be hired. Only the morale is tarnished and institutional knowledge is lost.
But many short-term investors are interested in dividends now, not in the long run. Long-term, they'll invest in whichever company can return the most at any given moment. It's a smart investment strategy from their perspective.
Developers (individual people) really suffer because of this. Many of them are very ambitious as this industry is highly competitive and a certain level of ambition is the price of entry. When layoffs are handed down by executives, same as when unrealistic timelines are imposed, ambitious programmers, designers, and artists have only one choice - to sacrifice the quality of their work, or to crunch and sacrifice their weekends, evenings, family ties, and health. You see the consequences as a player.
There is also a shift from games as the core product being developed, to means of monetization as the core product. Budgets for marketing and monetization are larger than what many would expect.
The executive "class" in the games industry is usually very far detached from these problems and they worry more about financials. There's rarely a lot of communication between execs and all others working in AAAs. There's definitely a lot more communication between every other discipline. In some companies, the only time an average employee would see an executive is during layoffs, project cancellations, restructurings, and similar "difficult news" times.
Re:The Game Industry Sucks [video]
by eurticket on Saturday September 30, 2023 @07:27PM
(#37720966)
I think the rant is more constructive when directed towards how companies are ran into the ground and the workers are the ones to take the hits. Not the c-suite or big decision makers, that made bad decisions.
There are some solid solutions. In game development, why not collect the resources that someone has made; code, models, animations, etc and reuse them to rapidly develop new ideas. Of course some aesthetic choices will not merge correctly with each other but scripts can be easier and sometimes interchangeable. Maybe more game development companies need to focus on these aspects if they already don't; Collecting resources they've already spent money on for moonshot ideas.
Or branching employees off into teams to make moonshot games instead of simply laying them off. After big, failed ideas by the game studio, instead of removing sudo-decay and starting over, why not bring those already trained people with you and start building a solutions culture? And maybe set a challenge to see who can create the best games in these makeshift, small teams -- any number of them could eventually become a major hit for the company.
It seems like the employees that are expendable would have the more interesting ideas and skills and they're never really valued to their potentials.
With that said seeing studios like blizzard and how they hire specialists -- that doesn't really translate to game development as a whole, even if the industry itself seems like a cash grab for those at the top.
Another interesting dysfunctional aspect of the industry that wasn't mentioned is that there is a network of studio heads who are often friends with each other, and trends (layoffs, RTO, the $100 game idea, etc) spread in that boys club.
Layoffs sometimes happen before quarter earnings reports to make financials look better. Even entire projects could be cancelled for this. These decisions make little long-term sense as ultimately the business has to return to operation and new people need to be hired. Only the morale is tarnished and institutional knowledge is lost.
But many short-term investors are interested in dividends now, not in the long run. Long-term, they'll invest in whichever company can return the most at any given moment. It's a smart investment strategy from their perspective.
Developers (individual people) really suffer because of this. Many of them are very ambitious as this industry is highly competitive and a certain level of ambition is the price of entry. When layoffs are handed down by executives, same as when unrealistic timelines are imposed, ambitious programmers, designers, and artists have only one choice - to sacrifice the quality of their work, or to crunch and sacrifice their weekends, evenings, family ties, and health. You see the consequences as a player.
There is also a shift from games as the core product being developed, to means of monetization as the core product. Budgets for marketing and monetization are larger than what many would expect.
The executive "class" in the games industry is usually very far detached from these problems and they worry more about financials. There's rarely a lot of communication between execs and all others working in AAAs. There's definitely a lot more communication between every other discipline. In some companies, the only time an average employee would see an executive is during layoffs, project cancellations, restructurings, and similar "difficult news" times.
There are some solid solutions. In game development, why not collect the resources that someone has made; code, models, animations, etc and reuse them to rapidly develop new ideas. Of course some aesthetic choices will not merge correctly with each other but scripts can be easier and sometimes interchangeable. Maybe more game development companies need to focus on these aspects if they already don't; Collecting resources they've already spent money on for moonshot ideas.
Or branching employees off into teams to make moonshot games instead of simply laying them off. After big, failed ideas by the game studio, instead of removing sudo-decay and starting over, why not bring those already trained people with you and start building a solutions culture? And maybe set a challenge to see who can create the best games in these makeshift, small teams -- any number of them could eventually become a major hit for the company.
It seems like the employees that are expendable would have the more interesting ideas and skills and they're never really valued to their potentials.
With that said seeing studios like blizzard and how they hire specialists -- that doesn't really translate to game development as a whole, even if the industry itself seems like a cash grab for those at the top.