News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bhouston on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:20AM (#37703784)
Are age limits viable in our aging population? I think they may not work because it would exclude so many people and many voters will be aged as well? I think a low bar competency test would be more viable.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by goda90 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#37703844)
Politicians make up a tiny percentage of the population and babies haven't stopped being born at any point, so there will always be a population under 65 from which to elect people. If voters over 65 feel left out because they can't vote for someone their age bracket, I don't know what to tell them except "welcome to the party".
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by RhysU on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:26PM (#37712558)
Weird SciFi idea: The human race is dying after such an amendment passes. The US Constitution finally crumbles because there is no one under 65 left in the country, making it ungovernable due to amendment ratification requirements.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by coldpie on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:22AM (#37703823)
Tests for public participation have a real, real bad history, and for good reason. Age is a simple and objective measure.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bhouston on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#37703847)
I agree. It is just that people's facilities fall off at different rates, but as others pointed out, it is hard to make an objective test that also can not be gamed.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by runeofdoom on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:01AM (#37704393)
There's nothing to prevent an older politician from advising their colleagues, serving on committee staffs or even lobbying. They're not prevented from participantion, they'd be prevented from being elected.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by archontes on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:31AM (#37704849)
It's just that that's not actually really important. The test of a good system is one that admits that its members will retire and adjusts accordingly.

In the military, you're always training a replacement, and come 65 (or 68), you're retiring, regardless of your capacity.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by the8472 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:47AM (#37704191)
Age limits work for keeping those noisy kids out, should also help with senile old farts.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by JWLong on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:52AM (#37704244)
I’m fairly certain that percentage will still be less than the number of minors, which no one has a problem with excluding in the same way.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:36AM (#37704938)
And maybe elders should be excluded for the same reason!

That is: Why do we exclude people under 18 from voting? Because we think they don't have the mental tools to understand policy well enough to make an informed decision. Well, if seniors don't have the mental tools anymore, should they be allowed to vote?

And this is even stronger with holding office. You can vote at 18, but you can't be a representative until 25, or a senator until 35. Why? Because you need to be old enough to (hopefully) have some judgment. Well, what if you're too old to have judgment?

So, yeah, excluding seniors from office would in fact be reasonable. Or at least requiring an annual mental competency test.

Unfortunately, we'll never get it without a state-driven constitutional convention, because those with the most power in Congress are highly correlated with those with the highest age.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:18AM (#37705516)
Remember that much of our current system has been a slow increase of the "popular" vote, from landholders to men to adults. At some point it'll go to "everyone above the age of 0" but let's not ignore that kids will at first vote the way their parents do, and then vote the exact opposite for awhile.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by poulsbohemian on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:01PM (#37707942)
I don't think we need to assume that actual children will someday vote. It's not punitive to say that we should have some age threshold into adulthood and its responsibilities. There are so many facets of society that necessitate some degree of protection of young people that it isn't unfair or unrealistic to also create a barrier around their full participation in our Democratic society.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by User23 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:15AM (#37704608)
The Church, which is certainly something of a gerontocracy, excludes the elderly Cardinals from Papal elections too. It's not intrinsically unjust anymore than excluding the very young is.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:16AM (#37705491)
To be fair, that limit is 80 and likely has more to do with not forcing elderly Cardinals to travel (many would and even still do out of a feeling of duty; it's basically literally the only "job" a Cardinal has that's not just him being a bishop).
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by telotortium on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:12PM (#37711202)
Currently, bishops are generally expected to submit their resignation to the pope upon turning 75 years old, although the pope may elect to retain the bishop.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by checkyoursudo on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:32AM (#37705730)
If lower bounds are reasonable for certain reasons, then it seems reasonable to apply those certain reasons to upper bounds.

Not every 15 year old would make an unsatisfactory legislator, and yet ...