News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by coldpie on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:18AM (#37703765)
Yes, and she's not the only one who is (edit: was) serving without being functional[1]. We need to start talking about upper age limits for public office. I believe it'd require a constitutional amendment, but I expect there's lots of support for it from all sides. I'd suggest 65 as a maximum age for being elected, which means one could serve to about age 71, for a six-year Senate term.

[1] This article is from six years ago. https://www3.bostonglobe.com/news/science/2017/10/11/congres...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bhouston on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:20AM (#37703784)
Are age limits viable in our aging population? I think they may not work because it would exclude so many people and many voters will be aged as well? I think a low bar competency test would be more viable.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by goda90 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#37703844)
Politicians make up a tiny percentage of the population and babies haven't stopped being born at any point, so there will always be a population under 65 from which to elect people. If voters over 65 feel left out because they can't vote for someone their age bracket, I don't know what to tell them except "welcome to the party".
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by RhysU on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:26PM (#37712558)
Weird SciFi idea: The human race is dying after such an amendment passes. The US Constitution finally crumbles because there is no one under 65 left in the country, making it ungovernable due to amendment ratification requirements.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by coldpie on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:22AM (#37703823)
Tests for public participation have a real, real bad history, and for good reason. Age is a simple and objective measure.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bhouston on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#37703847)
I agree. It is just that people's facilities fall off at different rates, but as others pointed out, it is hard to make an objective test that also can not be gamed.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by runeofdoom on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:01AM (#37704393)
There's nothing to prevent an older politician from advising their colleagues, serving on committee staffs or even lobbying. They're not prevented from participantion, they'd be prevented from being elected.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by archontes on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:31AM (#37704849)
It's just that that's not actually really important. The test of a good system is one that admits that its members will retire and adjusts accordingly.

In the military, you're always training a replacement, and come 65 (or 68), you're retiring, regardless of your capacity.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by the8472 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:47AM (#37704191)
Age limits work for keeping those noisy kids out, should also help with senile old farts.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by JWLong on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:52AM (#37704244)
I’m fairly certain that percentage will still be less than the number of minors, which no one has a problem with excluding in the same way.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:36AM (#37704938)
And maybe elders should be excluded for the same reason!

That is: Why do we exclude people under 18 from voting? Because we think they don't have the mental tools to understand policy well enough to make an informed decision. Well, if seniors don't have the mental tools anymore, should they be allowed to vote?

And this is even stronger with holding office. You can vote at 18, but you can't be a representative until 25, or a senator until 35. Why? Because you need to be old enough to (hopefully) have some judgment. Well, what if you're too old to have judgment?

So, yeah, excluding seniors from office would in fact be reasonable. Or at least requiring an annual mental competency test.

Unfortunately, we'll never get it without a state-driven constitutional convention, because those with the most power in Congress are highly correlated with those with the highest age.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:18AM (#37705516)
Remember that much of our current system has been a slow increase of the "popular" vote, from landholders to men to adults. At some point it'll go to "everyone above the age of 0" but let's not ignore that kids will at first vote the way their parents do, and then vote the exact opposite for awhile.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by poulsbohemian on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:01PM (#37707942)
I don't think we need to assume that actual children will someday vote. It's not punitive to say that we should have some age threshold into adulthood and its responsibilities. There are so many facets of society that necessitate some degree of protection of young people that it isn't unfair or unrealistic to also create a barrier around their full participation in our Democratic society.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by User23 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:15AM (#37704608)
The Church, which is certainly something of a gerontocracy, excludes the elderly Cardinals from Papal elections too. It's not intrinsically unjust anymore than excluding the very young is.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:16AM (#37705491)
To be fair, that limit is 80 and likely has more to do with not forcing elderly Cardinals to travel (many would and even still do out of a feeling of duty; it's basically literally the only "job" a Cardinal has that's not just him being a bishop).
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by telotortium on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:12PM (#37711202)
Currently, bishops are generally expected to submit their resignation to the pope upon turning 75 years old, although the pope may elect to retain the bishop.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by checkyoursudo on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:32AM (#37705730)
If lower bounds are reasonable for certain reasons, then it seems reasonable to apply those certain reasons to upper bounds.

Not every 15 year old would make an unsatisfactory legislator, and yet ...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by rasz on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:39AM (#37704066)
>not the only one who is (edit: was)

is: "McConnell’s frozen moment renews questions about America’s aged leaders" https://edition.cnn.com/2023/08/31/politics/mitch-mcconnell-...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by MisterBastahrd on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:36AM (#37704031)
Why exactly should the elderly be exempt from proper representation? There are plenty of things to criticize Nancy Pelosi about, for example, but still she's more intelligent and coherent than 99% of Congress.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bell-cot on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:51AM (#37704237)
Those in their first ~2 decades of life have long been exempted from proper representation, and I've never heard the elderly complain about that. Having both ends cut off sounds more fair and balanced to me.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by alphabettsy on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:28AM (#37704802)
Comparing a child to someone in their 70s with a lifetime of experience is silly. Maybe there should be limits once in office at a certain age, but not everyone ages the same.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by firebat45 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:37AM (#37704965)
Having a lifetime of experience does not necessarily make someone smart, rational, or even coherent. It especially does not make someone interested in voting for changes that will improve the lives of people younger than them.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by alphabettsy on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:03AM (#37712887)
That’s why we have elections. Being youthful doesn’t imply any of those things either and guarantees limited experience. I’m not arguing that young people shouldn’t be in office. I’m just not sure an arbitrary age limit is appropriate either.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by pierat on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:39AM (#37704991)
"Adolescence" was a made-up term to remove personal sovereignty over younger people who know full well, and would do, but aren't legally permitted to do so. They're also subject to our laws. They should have their say as well.

And then we see under-18 routinely be charged as adults.

And yes, if 15 year olds could vote and run for office, I do think we'd see more issues aimed at the younger generations ALONG WITH longer views of how our government is run. And we're seeing the judicial side of this with youngsters suing for climate devastation, like https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/08/1...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by SamPatt on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:54AM (#37705186)
I used to believe this - and even advocate for change - then I watched my children become teenagers.

There is truth to the idea that, whether due to life experience or brain development, teenagers struggle with proper decision-making.

I don't like the arbitrary nature of age cutoffs, but I would no longer support the idea of giving more political power to anyone under 18.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:29PM (#37706577)
> There is truth to the idea that, whether due to life experience or brain development, teenagers struggle with proper decision-making.

I don't like the arbitrary nature of age cutoffs, but I would no longer support the idea of giving more political power to anyone under 18.

while that's just an anecdote, even if it were the norm, it is also the norm for old people of a sufficient age

if it makes you feel better, we can administer cognitive tests to old people and determine at what point they fall into "teenager" level of mental acuity

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by SamPatt on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:46PM (#37708544)
There is much less variance on cognitive ability on the younger end of our lives than the higher end. Arbitrary age limits in youth are unfair, but less unfair than the same on the upper end of life.

I had a friend who remained sharp until her mid 90s. I have family members who shouldn't be voting in their early 70s. That range is massive, whereas we can mostly agree that nearly all 14 year olds aren't capable, but most 20 year olds are - unfair but not as vast a range.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:46PM (#37709247)
> There is much less variance on cognitive ability on the younger end of our lives than the higher end.

I'm not sure that's true. Mental maturity in kids varies widely, too. There are some pretty mentally mature kids changing the world. Look at Greta Thunberg.

There are also many fewer years for older people to live with the consequences of their votes. Everything has trade-offs. In this case, the loss would not be as bad as the loss we get from excluding those below 18.

Whatever the counterexample of sharp old people, I can think of one for sharp young people. We ignore those exceptions for young people, we can ignore them for old people, too. And if you're worried the old-age cutoff will be too young, just pick whatever age's median mental acuity matches 18 year olds - what's good for the gosling is good for the goose.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by coldpie on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:16PM (#37709602)
Your friend could still vote, just not run for office at 90 years old. This seems like a fine compromise to avoid the Feinstein/McConnell/RBG/etc pattern.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by pierat on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:47PM (#37706834)
Then why is anyone under 18 charged in criminal court as adults?

If you get ages can be seen to have the same legal cognitive patters as an adult, why shouldn't they also have the same rights as an adult?

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by SamPatt on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:40PM (#37708459)
Part of the criminal justice system is removing dangerous people from society. Sometimes you can make this determination before their 18th birthday. In general I agree with you though.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by alphabettsy on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:01AM (#37712879)
I don’t believe they should be.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:21AM (#37705557)
We already allow 19-30 year olds to vote, and it doesn't really seem to move the needle much in areas they are supposedly interested in.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by schnebbau on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:43AM (#37705057)
My father is in his 70s and can barely remember what he had for breakfast. He should not be representing anyone, or even voting for that matter.

There's no way to separate the able minded from the seniles fairly, so an age limit is the best way to do it.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:19AM (#37705538)
Does your father continue to vote the same way he has most of his life?
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:27PM (#37706535)
can you call it voting if they have less idea what's going on around them than a teenager?
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by schnebbau on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:13PM (#37709567)
Yes. But his party has changed a little in the last few years and I feel he would not be voting for them now if he could understand that.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by alphabettsy on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:05AM (#37712892)
> There's no way to separate the able minded from the seniles fairly, so an age limit is the best way to do it.

Sorry about your father, but there are plenty of 70 year olds who are extremely competent, capable and that also bring valuable connections and experience.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bell-cot on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:44AM (#37705072)
If you've been around many kids, you know that "18" is completely arbitrary, and adult-ish maturity comes to some far sooner than to others. (And to a few, it never does seem to come.)

And if you've been around many elderly people, you know that quite a few are less competent to vote than the average 14-year-old student council member, and that letting ~all of them do so is no less arbitrary than that "18".

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by jfengel on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:55AM (#37704284)
They shouldn't, though Congress has a massive skew towards them. The median senator is on Social Security. The median House member is just shy of being able to make tax-free withdrawals from their 401(k)s.

The minimum ages necessarily put an upward skew on it, but very few are anywhere near the minimum. There is little need to ensure representation for the elderly. And meantime, anybody of working age is badly under-represented.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by edgyquant on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#37705593)
Very few young people have the privilege to afford campaigning. It makes sense most people able to do so are old enough to have the savings, skills or passive income that allows them the freedom to hit the campaign trail.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by jfengel on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:41PM (#37708472)
Which is yet more reason to give us something to put a thumb on the younger side of the scale.

An age limit would be a crude form of that. So would a term limit.

We could alter the seniority system that gives much more weight to people who have been there the longest. But that's a rule Congress passes for itself, and it's hard to imagine many incumbents giving up on a privilege they've been waiting for.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by wiredfool on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:53AM (#37704260)
Reagan wasn’t all there for his second term.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by baggachipz on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:54AM (#37704282)
As far as I'm concerned, his entire term.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by mc32 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:47AM (#37705111)
Also see FDR...
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by readthenotes1 on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:42AM (#37705887)
And Woodrow Wilson and Strom Thurmond and Fetterman and...
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by heylook on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:26PM (#37719996)
wait, what exactly gives you the impression that Fetterman isn't all there?

this is an interview he gave within the last week: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qldqgtCYMs0