News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:09PM (#37695892)
I never really got this until I was talking to a scientist in our organization and she was bemoaning the fact that it was taking her team hours to do some basic analysis of files that our instrument exported.

"So why don't you make a request for Software to add that data to the file? We could do it easily enough."

"I did! but they keep telling me it's not high enough priority so it gets pushed out to 'the next release' every time"

"OK, I'll write you an offline tool to process the data."

Took me an afternoon to write a simple C# tool to ingest a number of files and spit out the data that she needed. She had been waiting over a year for my software team to get the go-ahead to do it as a built-in feature. And this was taking a biochemist on average 3 hours every day to do by hand!

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by MichaelZuo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:38PM (#37696249)
This is a great example, thanks for sharing.

Too many folks on HN claim that normal companies are close to as efficient as they can be. It's nowhere near close, more like hundred dollar bills lying on the floor everywhere in nearly every office.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by BeetleB on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:19PM (#37696025)
> Took me an afternoon to write a simple C# tool to ingest a number of files and spit out the data that she needed. She had been waiting over a year for my software team to get the go-ahead to do it as a built-in feature.

The counter to this is that this tool now has no support (which may be fine depending on the tool).

I remember my first job which was 30% SW and 70% other engineering. We wrote a few tools to automate stuff that our customers used.

One of our customers came to my manager and told us he had a tool we wrote over 5 years prior. It was a small Perl script. Their data source had changed formatting a bit and now the script no longer worked. They wanted us to update the script. Several hours were spent between the two teams arguing. My manager did not want to own it. He said he had no record of it, and none of the people on his team had any memory of it. We did not own it. They kept insisting "One of the engineers in your team (who had since left the company) wrote it, so you own it!"

I pointed out to the coworker that the request was so trivial we could have solved it in under an hour, and the company had lost more money by arguing. The counter was "If we fix it, they'll keep coming back to us and in the long run more money would be lost."

Over the years, I've realized how right he is.

I do occasionally write simple scripts to help our customers, but management always makes it clear to them that this is an unsupported prototype, and the customer needs to maintain it.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by hooverd on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:44PM (#37696313)
I think some teams could do really well to have an embedded developer- someone who can understand both fields decently enough.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by analog31 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:30PM (#37696749)
I've been in that role. It's utterly thankless. You will experience every way that the devs and non-devs can't work together. The devs will treat you like a scab. You'll discover all of the non-technical reasons why it's hard to be a dev, without being paid like one.

Today, my rule is that I only code for myself, and share my code with others who are also good coders. I'll use code to produce a result and share the result. This also lets me off the hook from all sorts of things like UI's, installers, etc.

Anybody who's a good enough dev to do it for money, and can stand doing it, should be.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by jwsteigerwalt on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:09PM (#37697151)
I’ve been in that role and it’s incredibly rewarding. The satisfaction from delivering something valuable to the sales leaders I partner with when they get something they genuinely appreciate trumps any commit dashboard.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by Sylamore on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:13AM (#37699532)
While I agree in principal, speaking as someone who's been that person it creates a lot of stress when it's just one person. You never get a break from enhancing or fixing and maintaining the tools that the rest of the team is using, and probably lose opportunities in your "other" skills. You'll probably get no support from the actual dev groups in the company, never get funding to hire a contractor (which almost never works out anyway), potentially end up stuck career wise because if the tools are really useful your manager isn't gonna want to lose you to a promotion.

A small "tools" team shared across some related disciplines under common leadership would be more ideal in my experience, but normally it's either beg for the real dev teams scraps or go rogue.

I like using code to solve problems and automate things, but I have no desire to be a full time coder just like I don't have a strong desire to be a people manager.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:50PM (#37696357)
And that's a perfectly valid rebuttal. Over time, she occasionally asked for more features, and I obliged as time permitted. The requests were always reasonable, and I checked the source into our generic "Tools" repository in case someone else ever took it over.

The bigger problem I saw was the shortsightedness of the organization. The software group had a history of writing small test tools for other groups, but no one ever considered listening to what she was asking for and checking if there was another way of getting the data besides changing the Product itself. It's always easier to just say No, even when there's a clear benefit to someone else.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by Spooky23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:50PM (#37696979)
It’s all a power dynamic.

Saying no is a power move that gives you street cred in the organization. Helping people is for the meek.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by the_sleaze9 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:16PM (#37697226)
Maybe, more likely an issue of incentives.

Manager is not incentivized to do X? Then forget it. Not my job, not my problem.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by mvdtnz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:24PM (#37697283)
They came back to you once after 5 years, what makes you think it would get worse over time?
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by RileyJames on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:58PM (#37698821)
And if by worse, it’s one hour every year, the argument is still a worse trade off for both time and customer & employee morale.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by BeetleB on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:13AM (#37699530)
"Past outcomes are not indicative of future results" Just because they came back after 5 years doesn't mean it will be 5 years before they come back again. It was, in fact, quite unpredictable. We didn't want to be on the hook every time their data source changed the format of the data. If this work is so important, they need to work with the team pumping out the data to have it standardized and stable.

This was in an org that was sorely lacking programming talent, and management clearly did not want to hire SW engineers. There was always a lot more work than there were engineers for, so it was a continuous battle of demarcating boundaries. If you start doing SW favors, everyone will want it from you, and will push the upper managers to force you (or your team) to do it. None of this will matter for promotions, because SW was secondary to our jobs. Without a hard stance, you'll drown.

As another commenter said, it was an incentives problem. Right or wrong, good or bad, helping people with small scripts was not something that would ever be rewarded.

It was also a matter of principle: If you do someone a favor, and they come back to you with an attitude and insist you owe them because you did them a favor, you stop doing those favors for them. That was something I would see often in that org (even outside of SW work): If you do work for someone, they expect you to own it.

Overall, the culture was poor. But I've found elements of it in most jobs.

Judging from the comments, it's evident I wasn't clear enough: When I said "our customer", I did not mean an external customer, but an internal team. We were a service/expertise department that helped various teams in the company with our expertise (and the expertise was not software). This was all informal - there was no monetary accounting/SLAs for our services.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by proamdev123 on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:58AM (#37702524)
> As another commenter said, it was an incentives problem. Right or wrong, good or bad, helping people with small scripts was not something that would ever be rewarded.

I agree with you here. The long queues for internal dev support is indicative of high demand for that support. If the organization can’t or won’t staff properly to provide that support, both the users AND the devs are forced to make tough choices.

So the devs say “No” to requests (or it takes an inordinately long time to get done), and so the business users make their own tools.

And the cycle continues…

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by thesnide on Sunday October 01, 2023 @04:06AM (#37723815)
The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

As soon as you make something easier to optimize, you'll end up spending more than before.

Sometimes you create a lot of value in the process, so it can be a good thing. But its costs has to be taken into account.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by Brian_K_White on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:27PM (#37697807)
Just bill for it, support and all. Make the customer say no. Or if they're willing to pay then great.

It's terrible customer support for the company to give them something one day and then deny all responsibility another day.

Even if the original team shouldn't have done it, they already did and it was never the customers fault.

The manager was not right at all, and this comes from no newbie who just hasn't been around that block yet.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by proamdev123 on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:01AM (#37702559)
> Just bill for it, support and all. Make the customer say no. Or if they're willing to pay then great.

This is probably the best solution. The organization still has to be prepared that business users will make their own tools, though. And they will frequently get things wrong, because they’re not developers.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by jemmyw on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:17AM (#37701569)
I guess there's a different though - if its for a customer then its potentially something that you should be charging for. If the "customer" is actually another department in your company and the automation helps then the company should have software devs allocated to internal tools - they'll probably find a lot more places to smooth things out if they're allowed to look.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by proamdev123 on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:54AM (#37702465)
> The counter was "If we fix it, they'll keep coming back to us and in the long run more money would be lost."

And this is why people develop their own tools.

Then the same people that wouldn’t help say, “Why did you build this monstrosity it Excel/Access/$OtherNoCodeTool ?!”

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by BeetleB on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:17PM (#37708139)
> Then the same people that wouldn’t help say, “Why did you build this monstrosity it Excel/Access/$OtherNoCodeTool ?!”

Not me :-) If Excel solves your problem, go for it. If it becomes a monstrosity and a bottleneck, then their management needs to allocate proper resources (i.e. hire their own devs). And they often do. The ones we see are the leftovers, where the ROI for a highly paid dev doesn't exist, so it's more economical to stick with the monstrosity.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by eviks on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:49AM (#37703267)
What's the counter? You could have effectively no support either way, only this way you at least have a working (perl) script

The long argument is also pretty flawed without any cost estimates, like, maybe they'd come to your every 5 years for a hour worth of work, but then looking up history and arguing about it takes longer

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by cm2012 on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:20PM (#37708180)
Not to mention this discounts the human cost. Marketers who have to wait 9 months to get anything done, and are forbidden from doing work themselves, realize the company doesn't actually care about accomplishing things and the passion dies. Why bother trying to come up with new and innovative things to test that could move the needle if its a kafkaesque nightmare every time?
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by projectileboy on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:08PM (#37696523)
Another example of: you can’t manage what you can’t measure, but be careful what you measure because that’s what you get. Alternately: measuring cost is easy, measuring value is hard. So we don’t hire another dev because that’s expensive, whereas I don’t see all the time wasted by the people I already employ. Having said all that, it’s a hard problem, and I’m not sure what general advice can be applied.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by proamdev123 on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:50AM (#37703275)
Fantastic insights here.

I’d add that another invisible cost(?) is that business users are going to develop their own tools no matter what. Why? Because they need them to do their jobs! So development is happening, whether it’s done by people with the title “developer” or not.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by pier25 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:47PM (#37697507)
I had the opposite experience.

At a previous company, one dev spent about 2-3 hours every single day to download PDFs with bank reports and then manually doing the conciliation.

I thought this was ridiculous. One afternoon I made a quick desktop app where he could drop the PDFs and get some JSONs back with all the data. The idea was that he then could semi automate the concilition with those JSONs.

Years later I left that company and he still was wasting all that time doing manual conciliation.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by charlie0 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:04PM (#37698070)
Yep, adoption is another major issue. I'm shocked at the number of people who continue wasting hours because they don't don't want to learn the newer faster way.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by creakingstairs on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:57PM (#37699116)
It’s learned helplessness. They learned that doing the job faster is not only reward-less but only gets them more work.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by shpongled on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:59AM (#37699799)
That sounds like a major skill or motivation issue.

I wouldn't want a "dev" who spent 2-3 hours a day doing something like this manually working with me.