News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by drpossum on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:41PM (#37694706)
Having been on the "actually has to deal with the aftermath of investing in no-code" that is when the cost comes in. Out of the literally dozen or so places I've worked and the half of those that went heavy on low code, it has never worked. The complexity becomes too great after a few months of "wins" and the system falls over on itself because the people using low code need increasingly complex things. But I assume as a marketer once you've finished your sale you move on to the next one. Because that what they all did.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by cm2012 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:43PM (#37694739)
The trick is to use the no code implementation to learn what you need to build from scratch. Don't think of it as expensive time to redo - think of it as valuable work finding out what your org actually needed. I'm sure you know that people don't even know what they need when they send developers their brief half the time.

It's like excel. Yes excel is used for all sorts of messy things its not ideal for, and would be better built by a programmer. But the excel file teaches the developer what their co workers actually need the product to do. It's not wasted time, it's invaluable.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by mellosouls on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:20PM (#37696032)
That's a good observation but falls apart if actual developers have to maintain the Rube-Goldberg app created by well-meaning "Citizen Developers" (© Acme No-Code Corp) using a framework which is only intended for prototypes but not fit for purpose beyond that.

Of course, that's a management issue - but managers who are easily taken in by consultancy sweet talk about the power of these frameworks are not always the most likely to understand the problems they cause or have the wisdom or resources to clean up afterwards by doing what you suggest.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by The_Colonel on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:29AM (#37701664)
We can't design tools which are incompetent-manager-proof. There are companies with incompetent management having no clue about software development, but business selection should eventually sort them out.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by leejoramo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:49PM (#37696972)
The most successful projects I have been on started with a smart manager, admin, engineer or other non-programmer who used Excel, FileMaker, FrontPage or the like. Using the tools they know defined their real scope of work.

Projects that start at an empty white board are much harder, which scope creep and higher failure rates

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by pdimitar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:04PM (#37697644)
I don't see how it's a valuable work finding out what your org actually needed if the cost compared to a proper programmer [team] is 3x - 10x more.

I mean I get what you're saying but finding one senior dev and onboarding him into the business and using him as a litmus test for most of your ideas as your concept evolves seems like the more sensible and cheaper option.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by Brian_K_White on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:04PM (#37698065)
The most valuable code is the 2 or 3 prototypes you intentionally wrote in python and throw entirely away.

The no-code could easily fall into the same category, as valuable hashing-out process.

Any "proper programmer" should know this.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by pdimitar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:07PM (#37698096)
I as "a proper programmer" also include cost analysis, which was the main argument given by my parent poster.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by The_Colonel on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:32AM (#37701695)
> I don't see how it's a valuable work finding out what your org actually needed if the cost compared to a proper programmer [team] is 3x - 10x more.

They seem to be talking about building real production systems using no-code.

Building a prototype using no-code can be faster (at least in some cases) than coding them. Esp. if you consider the cross-org coordination needed to get an allocation for dev team.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by Dwolb on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:33PM (#37695422)
A rogue marketer at a former company spent weeks with Zapier "trying to improve analytics". They went way too far to the point of saying, "I almost re-built Segment with Zapier".

Needless to say the Rube Goldberg machine of Zaps was impossible to debug and all the data and metrics ended up being wrong for the whole quarter.

We ripped it all out and had to start fresh.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by FridgeSeal on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:57PM (#37697043)
Low-code-no-code: it’s all fun and games until it isn’t; and when it isn’t it’s an tire-fire.
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by ebiester on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:04PM (#37698461)
It did a good job, then. How long would it have taken for the marketer to get their project prioritized if it hadn’t already demonstrated value?
Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by ramesh31 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:07PM (#37695860)
>The complexity becomes too great after a few months of "wins" and the system falls over on itself because the people using low code need increasingly complex things. But I assume as a marketer once you've finished your sale you move on to the next one.

And those "few months of wins" can mean millions of dollars in revenue for the business that would have been lost with a longer time to market. If it works, it works. And if it breaks, it can be plugged up until something can replace it. But nothing can replace lost time in a competitive industry.

Re:Tell HN: Enterprises spend 10x more to build no-code solu... by hftthw on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:50PM (#37696356)
It also means tens of millions of losses when the data pipeline falls over silently.

My first job out of university was to work on a compliance tool after someone used yahoo finance for exchange rates in a business critical spreadsheet. The losses were large enough to threaten the viability of the company.

Picking pennies in front of steamrolles is a pretty good description of putting no code in production.