News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by slavik81 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:37PM (#37668071)
> One current obstacle is infrastructure: the Debian build and CI infrastructures (both hardware and software) were not designed with GPUs in mind. This is also being worked on.

One thing that is still lacking is funding. AMD has provided RDNA 2 and RDNA 3 GPUs for the Debian CI, but to fill out the rest of the architecture matrix I have been personally buying GPUs. That's been sufficient for covering most architectures, but we will need a sponsor if we are to acquire CDNA 2 and CDNA 3 hardware.

Our goal is to cover every modern discrete AMD GPU architecture on the CI. At the moment, that would be Navi 33, Navi 32, Navi 31, Navi 24, Navi 23, Navi 22, Navi 21, Navi 14, Navi 12, Navi 10, Aldebaran, Arcturus, Vega 20, Vega 10, and (maybe) Polaris. I have been very successful at bringing the AMD GPU libraries to architectures that are not officially supported upstream. Unfortunately, I can't afford to keep buying systems out of my personal funds. I have personally spent ~7k USD on hardware for the CI and I have been offered reimbursement from the Debian project for my next ~5k USD in spending. That has been a good start, but we could do more to improve hardware support on Debian if we had more funding available.

Please consider donating to the Debian Project [1] if you wish to support their efforts.

[1]: https://www.debian.org/donations

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by ssivark on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:28PM (#37668550)
> but to fill out the rest of the architecture matrix I have been personally buying GPUs. That's been sufficient for covering most architectures, but we will need a sponsor if we are to acquire CDNA 2 and CDNA 3 hardware.

This seems like the kind of thing that AMD should be providing (or at least sponsoring) as a matter of principle — regardless of whether it can be funded in other ways I.e. if anyone in AMD cared this problem would be solved trivially. The fact that you are finding it out of pocket is seriously calling into question AMD’s commitment. What am I missing here?

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by neilv on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:26PM (#37669618)
I think Debian is one of the first places AMD should be looking to fund for ROCm.

Especially if there's already motivated capable volunteer labor, and all they need is equipment, and maybe a devrel point of contact.

The cost seems like a few peanuts dug out of the sofa cushions, on a strategic push like this.

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by ksec on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:32PM (#37669174)
> Unfortunately, I can't afford to keep buying systems out of my personal funds. I have personally spent ~7k USD on hardware for the CI and I have been offered reimbursement from the Debian project for my next ~5k USD in spending.

This is ridiculous. There is absolutely ZERO reason why AMD are not giving or donated by AMD at the minimum. I am sure some AMD folks are on HN. Please link this comment to Dr.Lisa Su and get this sorted out.

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by coherentpony on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:40PM (#37669236)
> I am sure some AMD folks are on HN

The person you're responding to is an AMD employee.

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @01:50AM (#37670677)
Then that says even worse things about priorities, if someone working there can't find anyone to provide one of each GPU.
Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by fransje26 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @04:35AM (#37671800)
"You can talk the talk, but can you walk the walk?"

It pretty much looks like AMD really cannot put their money where their mouth is, and can't bring itself to actually do what is necessary to compete with the green team.

As a personal anecdote from ~4/5 years back, we contacted an AMD sales rep (AMD Germany) about a product we were developing, that was absolutely flying on NVIDIA consumer hardware. We wanted to know if there was a possibility to explore how it would run on AMD hardware, with maybe a bit of support. They didn't even bother to reply..

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by tiberious726 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @01:34PM (#37678151)
If that's true, in what world is ROCm a priority for AMD at all? They can't even throw a few old cards on the project?!?
Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by bick_nyers on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @11:41AM (#37676329)
Thank you for your service, breaking the NVIDIA monopoly on AI will only be possible from the efforts of people such as yourself.

May I ask, why isn't AMD providing GPUs beyond RDNA 2/3 for you? Is it just because that is considered the priority as those are the newer cards?

I have an RX 580 8GB at home I would be happy to give you free of charge if you don't have access to that card (Polaris 20).

Re:ROCm Is AMD's #1 Priority, Executive Says by slavik81 on Saturday September 30, 2023 @07:40PM (#37721040)
[delayed]