News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:05PM (#37648943)
Good. I don't see this as a safety issue so much as a make-work law. If a human would have to be in a self-driving truck at all times and ready to assume the controls on a moment's notice, that's basically human-driven with extra steps. Either the tech is good enough to be autonomous, or it's not good enough to replace a human driver in the first place. And as a driver, I don't think I'd want to be legally responsible for whatever boneheaded move a truck might take in the moments before I could regain control over it. "Hey, I know it was the AI that decided to swerve into the crowd of toddlers, and you only had 300ms to respond, but you were the one sitting in the driver's seat..."

Now, I'm not thrilled with the idea of ending human jobs without giving those people a way to survive. Even if I weren't sympathetic to those hard-working people who are ready and willing to do the tough jobs that keep society running -- and I hope it's obvious that I am -- enlightened self interest means that I don't want all of to be unemployed and hungry. That's bad for everyone. I also wish we shipped more freight via train, which is cheaper and way more environmentally friendly. Making it easier and cheaper to ship even more via truck is probably the wrong path to optimize.

But all that aside, I still think this is a well intended but ultimately wrong solution. Frankly, it seems like it'd be cheaper and more efficient to pay those drivers to stay home rather than pay them to perch in a self-driving truck.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by thegrim33 on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:23PM (#37649189)
"Either the tech is good enough to be autonomous ..[]" - The issue is that the tech currently, categorically, is not good enough to be autonomous. There's no "self-driving" system that even claims to be a level 5 system.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:28PM (#37649260)
If Level 5 means there is no driver, then Cruise and Waymo already don't have drivers.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by KerrAvon on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:30PM (#37649296)
Cruise and Waymo are level 4.

https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:37PM (#37649405)
That's why I said, "If Level 5 means no driver..." I said that for a reason that's germaine to the subject at hand, autonomous trucks: I'm not persuaded autonomous trucks need the level 5 defined in the way the link you provided defines it.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:09PM (#37649867)
The difference from 4 to 5 is the breadth of conditions under which autonomous driving is viable, seemingly with locality as a limiting factor. If a route has the truck leaving the local municipality, the truck is likely not autonomous, even at level 4. I'd be curious if it's possible to schedule a route from San Francisco to Sacramento (let alone San Francisco to New York City) with either Cruise or Waymo, assuming it's necessary to take a highway for such a trip.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:51PM (#37650424)
> If a route has the truck leaving the local municipality, the truck is likely not autonomous.

I don't understand what you mean. Can you clarify?

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 25, 2023 @06:05PM (#37651357)
From the above link (https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update) under "What do these features do?" for "SAE Lvel 4":

> These features can drive the vehicle under limited conditions and will not operate unless all required conditions are met.

If one of these conditions is locality then the vehicle cannot be driven autonomously outside that locale. If a freight truck needs to go from City A to City B -- as they often do -- but the autonomous software only works in City A, then the truck won't be driven autonomously even if it's otherwise capable of autonomous driving.

So I slightly misspoke by saying it's "not autonomous" but going into level 4 vs. level 5, a freight truck is not functionally autonomous until it's level 5. It can be driven autonomously in some conditions but such conditions are almost certainly not all conditions that human freight drivers encounter daily.

(FWIW, I also entered the conversation late and am mostly responding to this: "I'm not persuaded autonomous trucks need the level 5 defined in the way the link you provided defines it.")

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:08PM (#37652011)
Thanks for entering the conversation when you did. I hope you'll entertain it for a little longer, but if not, no worries.

I'm just thinking, what if those conditions don't prohibit a truck from operating outside of a locale, but rather, they prohibit a truck from operating on anything but certain prescribed routes, on interstates, connecting ports and rail terminals and distribution centers, in the right lane only, in daylight, and in good weather conditions only? Is that level 5? It doesn't sound like level 5 to me. It sounds like level 4. And yet, it also sounds like it would still be very useful to someone running a fleet of trucks.

So again, I'm not persuaded level 5 is necessary for autonomous trucks. Some kinds of trucking would be excluded until we get to level 5, but that still leaves some useful trucking that could be handled by level 4.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:21AM (#37654307)
To your point I suspect Level 4 could fulfill most of those conditions. At least enough to require a driver only to drive within city limits.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:49AM (#37654523)
Haha yep. Like a bar pilot.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by BobbyJo on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:23PM (#37649184)
If even 50% of those workers perform other jobs, society as a whole will be wealthier, while having the same number of people.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:45PM (#37649522)
I agree, if we can get them into other jobs. So many other times we've seen workers who flat-out refused to participate in retraining because politicians talked them out of it. I'm specifically thinking of coal miners who believed the lie that their jobs were coming back, and based on that turned away free education offers that would have given them modern-world skills.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by EatingWithForks on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:50PM (#37649597)
Gonna be honest: if someone told me my tech job had been replaced with all its benefits (wfh! office stipend!) and now I have to retrain as a plumber, including back to the shitty apprenticeship system for low pay and low benefits (starting from the bottom again) I would also get really damn upset and resist that. There will be a lot of tooth gnashing on my end even if you pay for my apprenticeship and initial training, I'm still significantly worse off for the literal rest of my whole life.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:04PM (#37649788)
I get why it sucks, but every day someone resists retraining from a dying or dead occupation is a day they’re not getting experience in a new job. In the case of the coal miners, those jobs were gone. No amount of bargaining would bring them back. The mines aren’t going to re-open. The affected people didn’t get to choose between retraining or keeping their current jobs. They had to choose between learning new marketable skills in a classroom or scrabbling through whatever remaining local jobs they could find.

We’re not there with truck driving yet, but to me it seems inevitable. I wouldn’t consider it as a brand new career worth starting today if my intent were to retire from it.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by EatingWithForks on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:28PM (#37650157)
I'm only arguing that it makes complete sense why people are resisting if someone is telling them otherwise. I would also cling to my livelihood if my alternative was losing my home, my healthcare, my stability. And I'd further be insulted by people offering me retraining programs that don't actually train me to a lateral career. I'm trying to practice some empathy, man.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:45PM (#37650351)
I'm empathetic. My family background is solidly working class. My dad worked in a funeral home. My mom retired from a railroad. My brother-in-law drives long-haul trucks for a living. My ancestors were farmers, miners, settlers, and little horse teamsters. I love these people and want good things for them.

But there's "is" vs "ought". It ought to be the case that these hard-working people can earn a decent living doing the jobs they spent many years in. It is the case that a lot of those jobs are disappearing as the natural result of technological and societal changes. My grandpa couldn't have delivered ice in downtown St. Louis with a horse and cart today if he wanted to. That job no longer exists. In the case of coal mining, most people don't want those jobs to exist anymore: each ton of coal pulled out of the ground is nearly 3 tons of CO2 gas into the air (purely from the burning process, not counting the effort to mine it).

I don't have the answers here. I don't know what we should be doing. I sure don't want my BIL to lose his career. But what is the kind, empathetic thing to do? We've gone from zero to having self-driving cars zipping around San Francisco in a few short years. What will they be like in 10 years? 20? I don't know when it'll happen, but it seems absolutely inevitable that at some point in the near future, autonomous vehicles will be better drivers than we are. After that, do we build a little passenger cabin onto automated vehicles so that we can pay "drivers" to pretend to operate them? Even if we did, how long can we keep that going? I don't know. I just can't see a path where that's the new state of affairs forever.

Sometimes love means having hard, uncomfortable conversations. I think that's where we're at today with jobs like mining, and where we'll be soon with other careers.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @10:51PM (#37653737)
Would it go down easier if you were offered a home, healthcare, and stability in lieu of re-training?
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by grecy on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:56PM (#37649682)
For sure, but I wonder what you (or anyone) is going to do about it.

Eventually, you simply have to go to work for a roof over your head, food and healthcare.

It doesn't really matter if you like it or not. If you current job ceases to exist you will get another job, or you will die.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by EatingWithForks on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:58PM (#37649715)
Yes, I'm just pointing out the retraining isn't actually the real alternative people think it is. It's directly lowering the quality of life and destroying the economic future of an entire industry's worth of people and all their families/dependents. This is important to deal with as it is, not with some bs "well we offered them retraining!" as if that means anything.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:07PM (#37649836)
But not as much as not retraining. Given the choice between a ship and a lifeboat, I’d take the ship. Choosing between a lifeboat and treading water, scoot over and hand me an oar.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by EatingWithForks on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:25PM (#37650100)
I'm arguing that retraining isn't really the lifeboat people are saying it is.

Just be upfront: removing jobs is drowning people. That's it. Don't comfort yourself with "retraining" programs like they mean anything. They don't. Acting like you're giving them an oar is just insulting them on top of taking their livelihoods, so I understand the anger.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by grecy on Monday September 25, 2023 @08:04PM (#37652515)
> It's directly lowering the quality of life

I would argue that any long-haul trucker or coal miner will have a much higher quality of life when those jobs go away and they re-train for something where they don't have to be away from their families doing dangerous things.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:43PM (#37652314)
> Eventually, you simply have to go to work for a roof over your head, food and healthcare

No, you don't. Plenty of retired people don't go to work and yet they have all of those things.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by grecy on Monday September 25, 2023 @10:23PM (#37653543)
> No, you don't. Plenty of retired people don't go to work and yet they have all of those things

of course, retirement is an option.

But we're talking about people that need to re-train, so I'm assuming here we're talking about people who are not yet ready to retire

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @10:24PM (#37653554)
If somebody can't or won't re-train, then I would say they're ready to retire.
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by grecy on Monday September 25, 2023 @10:59PM (#37653787)
They might want to, but obviously they can't if they don't have enough saved
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:11PM (#37653853)
I don't regard that as obvious. A social safety net COULD catch them when they fall out of the workforce. We don't seem to have such a safety net in America, but that's a consequence of politics, not of economics or technology. Confronting those politics admittedly is a tall order, but consider the alternative: retarding innovation, wasting human potential, and maintaining make-work jobs because politics is hard? Is that really the hill you wanna die on?
Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by grecy on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:22PM (#37653923)
> but consider the alternative

You make it sound like there are only two choices:

1. Confronting the politics of building a social saftey net in America.

2. Retarding innovation, wasting human potential, etc. etc.

Yet there is a perfectly good third solution that has worked countless times in history when technology has made certain jobs redundant, and will without a doubt continue to work long into the future.

3. Re-skill and get a different job.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:43PM (#37654043)
You made it sound like there's only one choice when you wrote above:

> Eventually, you simply have to go to work for a roof over your head, food and healthcare.

I'm glad we finally agree that there are at least three choices, that building a safety net is one of them, and that going to work so that you have a roof, food, and healthcare isn't the only one.

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by user3939382 on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:24PM (#37649202)
> freight via train, which is cheaper and way more environmentally friendly

>.> ohio

Re:California governor vetoes bill to require human operator... by kstrauser on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:40PM (#37649443)
It's all about per-mile safety and economy. Ohio was bad. Having that same amount of the same chemicals shipped via highways that snake through the middles of cities would be vastly worse.