Combine it with personal website ranking and lenses, it surpasses Google easily.
Also since it has no ads, there’s no noise.
I don’t use Microsoft products, so I can’t comment on Bing.
I suspect this is a niche feature for power-users only. HN is filled with power users, so they love Kagi, but it doesn't necessarily translate to the masses.
I think it’s important to measure and quantify these things.
I can't provide you with side-by-side examples because I don't compile lists of such examples. I'm searching to find stuff, not researching search quality. I just know that I have more problems getting good search results from Google over a couple of the other engines.
If a user of service thinks a different service is better, then it is better for them by definition. "Better" is a subjective thing. If X seems better for me than Y, then it is.
"Are US drivers licenses forgery-proof?" and "Can US Real-ID drivers licenses be forged?"
gave utterly irrelevant #1 or #2 hits: nothing to do with US or Real-ID (zero mentions), it's about New South Wales, Australia (lots of mentions of "NSW"). (although from US magazine Wired.com, but Google can still tell this article is totally irrelevant).
2) I previously in 2022 posted "Google search relevance fail: result for “Africa longitude” [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30337563] where the #1 site hit and text result were the grossly misleading "Africa/Coordinates 8.7832° S, 34.5085° E", which is not a range, or even a centroid, just a junk location in southern Tanzania, where a (Russian?) SEO spam person seemed to have dropped a bogus pin, mislabeled "оф. 3, 27 ул. Хабаровская, Bila Tserkva, Russia". In Tanzania. 17 months later and same gloriously unfixed garbage results.
Other bizarre top hits were the small Ottawa e-commerce digital-map site https://www.mapsofworld.com/lat_long/africa.html, with the incomplete and inaccurate non-sentence "Africa's latitude and longitude lies between 9.1021° N, 18.2812° E." (That e-ecommerce store seems to have an autogenerated page with incorrect information on latitude and missing longitude for each country).
These are cases where Google itself 5 years ago would have done better. Or compare to Kagi.