Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by nakkiel on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:36PM
(#3764295)
I'm actually convinced it's a little sad that S3 becomes the defacto standard.
At its core, S3 is a key-value store and I don't think it's a very feature-full one at that. Indeed it has some very good features but I'm afraid people simply implement its API rather than spend time innovating.
Two things that I have in mind: - Retention delay - REST API (although both Swift and RiakCS implement that)
I think Basho made a good strategic choice with what they call "Per-Tenant Visibility", which will facilitate other cloud hosting providers that compete with Amazon reselling Riak CS as a storage service.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by izak30 on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @12:50PM
(#3762500)
I think Basho made a good strategic choice with what they call "Per-Tenant Visibility", which will facilitate other cloud hosting providers that compete with Amazon reselling Riak CS as a storage service.
Yeah, OpenStack has that as well, from my understanding. I'm trying to figure out the other differences between the two.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by rarrrrrr on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @02:54PM
(#3763050)
According to the GigaOM article, Basho is charging $10,000 in licensing per storage server, so I guess it's not actually free and open source software. :(
Nimbus.io is AGPL, Swift is Apache, Walrus is either GPLv3 or BSD.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by hkarthik on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:55AM
(#3761484)
Basho's products look great, but I hardly hear of anyone using them. Most folks in the Ruby community tend gravitate towards MySQL, MongoDB, and Postgres. Any insight as to why that is? Riak looks like a pretty solid database too.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by bonzoesc on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:13AM
(#3761568)
(Disclosure: I'm a Developer Advocate employed by Basho)
Postgres is a better fit for most Ruby web applications. When you first launch your app, you'll have a tiny handful of users and won't have any problems fitting it in a free Heroku instance on the free 5MB shared Postgres, and the compromises you'd have to make with your data model to fit a database like Riak aren't going to pay off until you get enormous. Postgres and ActiveRecord get the job done quickly and without fuss, and allow you to launch quickly and see how your app is received.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by tlack on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @11:43AM
(#3762109)
He is right in that you don't hear much about Riak success stories, even though from the word on the street it's a good product. Perhaps this is something you guys could focus on putting together?
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by nl on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:04AM
(#3761525)
Riak's sweet spot is with data sizes quite a lot larger than the typical RoR app.
Riak has a tunable consistency model, and there are a lot less applications that need tunable consistency compared with those that need the strengths of the SQL databases (everyone knows them, they just work) or MongoDB (designed from the ground up to be a developer friendly document database).
The closest Riak competitor is probably Cassandra (in terms of technical attributes), and you don't see huge numbers of Ruby apps using Cassandra either.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by bitops on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @02:15PM
(#3762881)
They didn't kill it, they just stopped supporting and developing it. I spoke to them at Clojure/West about luwak and they said that Riak-CS is the better alternative; they wrote Riak-CS to replace luwak.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by meepmorp on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:53AM
(#3761472)
By subscription feed, do you mean support for the enterprise product or for this new offering? I didn't see numbers for either on the website - can you ballpark what they are?
And is your problem with the quantity of dollars, or with the fact that they charge at all?
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by chaostheory on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @12:02PM
(#3762230)
> By subscription feed, do you mean support for the enterprise product or for this new offering? I
Yes
> And is your problem with the quantity of dollars, or with the fact that they charge at all?
Quantity, in particular how much they charge per server. I don't think it would be fair for basho for me to spout specifics, but as late of last year it seemed rather exorbitant especially for an open source product.
This is the main reason my large employer didn't even bother to seriously look at what their products had to offer. Both 10gen (Mongodb) and one of the companies offering Cassandra support contracts were a lot more reasonable.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by madworld on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @12:18PM
(#3762330)
> This is the main reason my large employer didn't even bother to seriously look at what their products had to offer. Both 10gen (Mongodb) and one of the companies offering Cassandra support contracts were a lot more reasonable.
When we contacted both 10gen and Basho a few months ago, Basho's support rates were cheaper than 10gen. We didn't look at Datastax at the time, so I can't comment on that comparison.
Re:Basho Unveils New Cloud Storage Software: Riak CS
by robterrell on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:54AM
(#3761797)
Basho has a "Riak Enterprise for Startups" which they describe as a "pay what you can" service for self-funded or angel-funded companies. I don't know what price they quoted you (would be interested to know) but it seems like you could pay whatever you felt it was worth until your first round closes.
Otherwise, it's nice to see S3 becoming a web storage standard (or one standard emerging in general). Openstack Swift also supports it.
At its core, S3 is a key-value store and I don't think it's a very feature-full one at that. Indeed it has some very good features but I'm afraid people simply implement its API rather than spend time innovating.
Two things that I have in mind: - Retention delay - REST API (although both Swift and RiakCS implement that)
I'm sure I've overlooked a few, but the ones I'm aware of (roughly in chronological order of when they first became usable) are:
Eucalyptus's Walrus http://open.eucalyptus.com/wiki/EucalyptusStorage_v1.4
OpenStack's Swift http://swift.openstack.org/
SpiderOak's Nimbus.io https://nimbus.io/
Basho's Riak CS http://basho.com/products/riakcs/
Glad to see so much interest in this space.
I think Basho made a good strategic choice with what they call "Per-Tenant Visibility", which will facilitate other cloud hosting providers that compete with Amazon reselling Riak CS as a storage service.
Yeah, OpenStack has that as well, from my understanding. I'm trying to figure out the other differences between the two.
Nimbus.io is AGPL, Swift is Apache, Walrus is either GPLv3 or BSD.
http://devblog.seomoz.org/2011/10/using-riak-for-ranking-col...
I know of a couple other ruby shops that use riak. Github uses it a bit. Spreedly uses it as well.
Postgres is a better fit for most Ruby web applications. When you first launch your app, you'll have a tiny handful of users and won't have any problems fitting it in a free Heroku instance on the free 5MB shared Postgres, and the compromises you'd have to make with your data model to fit a database like Riak aren't going to pay off until you get enormous. Postgres and ActiveRecord get the job done quickly and without fuss, and allow you to launch quickly and see how your app is received.
You can always scale later: https://gettingreal.37signals.com/ch04_Scale_Later.php
Parts of it may well be open sourced over time.
Riak has a tunable consistency model, and there are a lot less applications that need tunable consistency compared with those that need the strengths of the SQL databases (everyone knows them, they just work) or MongoDB (designed from the ground up to be a developer friendly document database).
The closest Riak competitor is probably Cassandra (in terms of technical attributes), and you don't see huge numbers of Ruby apps using Cassandra either.
http://wiki.basho.com/Riak-Comparisons.html is worth reading.
And is your problem with the quantity of dollars, or with the fact that they charge at all?
Yes
> And is your problem with the quantity of dollars, or with the fact that they charge at all?
Quantity, in particular how much they charge per server. I don't think it would be fair for basho for me to spout specifics, but as late of last year it seemed rather exorbitant especially for an open source product.
This is the main reason my large employer didn't even bother to seriously look at what their products had to offer. Both 10gen (Mongodb) and one of the companies offering Cassandra support contracts were a lot more reasonable.
When we contacted both 10gen and Basho a few months ago, Basho's support rates were cheaper than 10gen. We didn't look at Datastax at the time, so I can't comment on that comparison.